I had just made it up all five flights of stairs to my school, Brooklyn Academy of Science and the Environment (BASE), when I saw a poster that read, “On BASE’s progress report, we got a B.” At first, I didn’t even know what it meant. I thought to myself, “Does this mean we all got a B average on our report cards?” That couldn’t be possible.
As the day went on, the progress report became a faint memory among the many concerns inside my head, like classes, projects and upcoming tests. And no one was talking about it. All students were talking about was the American Music Awards, the latest gossip in school and things they’d done over the weekend.
All About High Scores
But on my way home after school, I heard people talking about how the New York City Department of Education (DOE) had started grading schools, and on the train I saw someone reading a newspaper article about it.
I wondered to myself, “How could BASE have gotten a B?” I thought that our school was all about getting high scores, and I was surprised we hadn’t gotten an A. I know lots of students who are either merit roll students (like me) or are on the honor roll. And the majority of students pass their science Regents tests, since it’s a school for science and environmental studies.
I wanted to know what factors made us get a B so I could understand our grade better. I decided to look at our full progress report on the DOE website.
What Our Grade Means
I found out that the report is made up of three categories. There’s school environment, which includes things like safety and respect, academic expectations, engagement and attendance. We scored a 4.2 out of 15 on that part, which didn’t surprise me. When it comes to environment, our school isn’t exactly on point.
Students in our school and all the other schools in the building have to go through scanning machines to get in, which is a hassle. Our school isn’t great when it comes to respect, either. Some students disrespect the teachers, assistant principals, security guards and office workers.
The next category is student performance, where we scored a 14.2 out of 30. I was surprised that we didn’t do better in that area. There are a lot of bright and intelligent students in this school who do exceptional work.
The last category is student progress, which looks at how much student test scores improved from last year. We got a 30.2 out of 55. This category counts for more than half of the progress report grade, which may explain why we got an overall grade of a B even though we didn’t do great in student performance or environment.
I have to admit, when I first heard that the DOE was grading schools, I didn’t understand the point. I felt like it must care more about the reputation of its schools than the welfare of its students. But since researching what progress reports are and reviewing my school’s progress report, I feel like I understand the situation a lot better.
It seems like the DOE is checking out schools to see if anything is wrong with them, and holding schools responsible to improve. That’s a good thing for all New York City schools.
Predicting Problems
But I think there’s a problem with the new system. One of the biggest consequences of the progress reports is that if any school gets a D or F, or gets a C three years in a row, the DOE may either kick out the current principal or permanently close the school.
I predict that this will just cause more problems. If kids from schools that get shut down have to transfer to other schools, it could make other schools in the area overcrowded. Then, those schools might end up becoming as bad as the schools that got closed. That would make it harder for kids to get the education that they deserve. And whether you’re already at a good school or transferring in from a bad one, that’s not fair for any student.
Breaking Down the Grade
Surprised by a'B'
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.