My school, Secondary School for Journalism, got a C on its progress report, and I think that’s what it deserved. Some students are slackers-they don’t take school seriously and fail horribly. Others, like me, work to their full potential. So the C seems like an average of the slacker F’s and the hardworking A’s.
But I think that grading high schools is pointless. If a school gets a bad grade because of low test scores or poor attendance, what can a principal or a teacher actually do to make students study? What can they do to make students come to school, or to respect administrators, fellow students or themselves?
In my opinion, it’s not the responsibility of teachers or administrators to lecture students about coming to school, doing homework or respecting each other: it’s the students’ responsibility. After all, high school students are nearly adults. The school staff should only help students who want to help themselves.
Bridging the Gap
I’m also not sure the reports always reflect the effort that good teachers put in. When I looked at my school’s progress report online, I noticed we only had a 50% pass rate for our global history Regents. But one of my favorite instructors teaches global history and works hard to teach us good techniques for passing the test. I think this shows that a teacher that may really care may be misjudged or misrepresented because of students’ performance.
I was surprised to learn from the report that only 17.2% of high schools in the city scored worse than we did, which means nearly 83% did the same or better. That makes me upset. I’m graduating this year. But if I were staying at my school for another two years, I think this grade would make me push harder to achieve success. I’d also encourage my friends to work hard to bridge the achievement gap.
Breaking Down the Grade
Good Grades Are Up to the Students
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.