“Come on, ma, I can’t take back the empty bottles to the store, they won’t take them. Suppose my friends see me carrying back bottles? I will be the laughing stock of the school tomorrow.”
These are the words we use when our mothers tell us to take back empty bottles and cans to the store for the five cent deposit. Do they ring a bell?
Well, they should, because we are not the only teenagers who take back cans and bottles in return for some of that green stuff.
But often we see store windows with signs saying “No returns” or “Returns only after 5 p.m.”
Or if you make it inside the store, there is the tough looking storeowner gnashing his teeth when he sees you with a bag of empties.
But what a lot of teenagers do not know is that the stores which sell these cans and bottles are supposed to take them back-up to 240 cans and bottles per person each day is what the law says.
And you don’t have to return them to the store you bought them from-only a store which carries the brand you are returning.
So we decided to act as undercover cops and visit a couple of stores and see if they were obeying the Bottle Bill law.
‘Take Them to the Supermarket’
We hit the streets of Manhattan first, but not before Eric borrowed his brother’s Mets cap to disguise his adorable face, and maybe even meet Strawberry on the way.
We went first to a store on 94th St. on the west side called “Te-Amo” where the man behind the counter said, “The only bottles we redeem are the ones that are bought from the store immediately. The store is too small, take them to the supermarket.”
We saw no point in arguing with him, and we couldn’t arrest the guy, so we left for a store on 110th St. by the name of “Village Cigars.”
A man who seemed to be the owner said he didn’t take bottles, and that we should take them to the supermarket. Again, we didn’t argue, especially with him on the phone. He could have dialed 911.
From there we went to the Bronx, passing Yankee stadium and on to 898 Gerard Ave. to a store called “Big Apple Food Store.” The owner told us, “No, we don’t take bottles, I only take five bottles at the most at a time.”
With the angry expression he had on his face, we figured he must have still been upset about the Yankees not making it to the pennant race, and we left.
From there we went to another store in the Bronx at 870 River Ave. called “Primadora.” A skinny man muttered that we should take them to the supermarket.
We took his advice and went to the supermarket. The cashier, with a nice enough smile, told us to bring the bottles into the store. Since we did not actually have any bottles, and were just roving reporters on an investigation to demand justice for the American people, we went on to other stores.
‘We don’t Take Bottles’
To “Brooklyn, Brooklyn” we went, to a little store on Livingston St. that only bore the name of “LottoNewspapers.” The man behind the counter said, “No, we don’t do that, we don’t take bottles.”
I kept asking him over and over why he didn’t take bottles. He didn’t answer me for a while and started to pout his face at me.
His boss then dragged him away from the counter and said, “Because we sell drinks at a lower price.”
I thought we were going to have a fight. But we restrained ourselves. Also, the guy was bigger than us and much meaner too.
We went to our last store, “Best Total” at 235 Duffield St. There a very humble Chinese lady told us in a very mild and nice tone of voice that the only bottles she takes are the ones that are actually bought there.
The storeowners and other workers need to take a lesson from her in the art of self-discipline, as she seemed to be the nicest person we met on the street so far.
Anyway, Mr. Storeowner, will you please take the empty bottles and cans and be nice about it? We are not trying to run you out of business.
You see, we are neither poor nor rich but there are times when the little change will come in handy to buy a pack of gum, bags of potato chips, or some candy.
If not us, think about the least fortunate, the people who search the garbage for bottles and cans to make a living.
If not, we will have the New York State Dept. of Environmental Conservation, and the Mayor’s and the Governor’s offices on your doorstep.
Bottle Bill or Bottle Bull?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.