Names have been changed.
Last November, our teacher told us we were having a student government election. At first I wasn’t interested because I knew being an elected official takes a lot of work. But my friends who were already planning on getting involved wanted my support, so I said OK. There were two parties. I joined one and was chosen to run for vice president.
I didn’t have much experience working in a group. When I did, I was usually critical because I’m a perfectionist. I always said whatever opinions were in my mind, without thinking how that might make the other person feel.
For instance, I remember an English project where we had to make a magazine. One of our group members asked me to proofread her paragraph. I found many grammar and spelling errors, so I told her, “You have to always keep an eye on these small details, because these mistakes are OK for little kids, but not for a high school student.” She never asked me to check her work again. Now I realize the way I said it was mean.
React With Tact
Working in a group like this was different because this wasn’t just a small class project. We had to learn to get along and problem-solve every day throughout the month-long campaign. I knew I couldn’t be my usual critical self who got mad if someone wasn’t doing his or her part to my satisfaction. I didn’t figure this out right away, however.
When I first joined the group, I got furious with one of the members, John, because he kept making decisions on his own without talking to the rest of us. He arranged a bake sale, gave someone a leadership position in our group, and dropped out of a presentation we were making to the school at the last minute.
So when he tried to give another student a leadership position without talking with us, my temperature went up, my face turned red, and I felt like my throat was burning. “Why do you need a group if you are making all the decisions by yourself?” I asked. John tried to defend himself by saying, “I thought I told you guys before.” He looked to each of us us to find an ally, but everyone else was shaking their heads as if to say, “Sorry, John.” So I continued, “Well, you thought you did. But you really should’ve told us what you were planning. This is about group work, not your ego.”
Everyone stared at me in shock because of my outburst. I was so angry I didn’t realize I had embarrassed him in front of everyone. And that was unnecessary, even if I was right. It also embarrassed me to think I had done that. Also, he really cared about the whole group so what I said was unfair. “I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have yelled at you,” I said. I was relieved that he was more easygoing about accepting my apology than I’d expected. (He also did check in with us before making decisions after that.)
Rallying Support
One afternoon, we had to give a presentation to the students to try to get their support. The next day, one of the sophomores in our group posted a video of our presentation on Facebook.
It showed our other vice presidential candidate yelling at the students, “You guys don’t know English, that’s the problem. You have to study!” I attend an international high school and what he meant was that students who hadn’t learned much English yet should study harder to attain a brighter future. But because he is also still learning English, it came off like he was lecturing them and trying to make them feel inadequate. Most of the students took that as an insult, so they started writing comments. One said: “Look at what this group said. Is there anyone still supporting them?”
This obviously wasn’t an effective way to rally support for our party. My first instinct was to yell at him. I tried to control myself so I didn’t sound like I was bossing him around. Calmly I said, “I understand what you were trying to say, but without realizing it you’ve insulted some students. Maybe next time we should practice before making speeches.”
He accepted my suggestion and the conversation was a peaceful one. I also wrote an apology on the Facebook page. In the past, I was always too proud to apologize even when it was my fault, not to mention apologizing for someone else. But now I knew if one person in the group made a mistake, it reflected on all of us. I also felt that instead of blaming him, we should figure out a way to solve it.
Inter-Party Squabbles
As the election neared, discussions within our group sometimes ended in arguments. Most of the time, it was about responsibilities. I brought a girl named Sally into the party and recommended her as the treasurer. I thought she’d be an asset since she’s helpful and passionate about wanting to make changes in our school. Then a few weeks before the election, she fought with John because he said she wasn’t handling her responsibilities well. Even though he apologized to her, she wanted to quit because she felt insulted.
The day before the election, I asked Sally if she could stay in the classroom to talk before lunch. I pulled up a chair in front of her to start the conversation.
“We all know you helped us a lot and John apologized, so can you forgive him and come back?” I was really thinking how disappointed I was that this girl, who I recommended, quit over one argument. But I kept that to myself.
“OK, if you want me to stand with you guys on the stage tomorrow, I will. But I don’t want to be involved anymore.”
“No!” I said, “It’s not about just standing with us, but to be part of us! You really shouldn’t leave just because you disagree with one person.”
“But…” she was about to say something, but I interrupted her.
“OK, this is what I think. As a group, it’s normal that we have arguments, but we need to understand each other’s perspectives and work it out. We can agree to disagree because we still have to be united as a group. Please think about it.”
Then I left the room. I was prepared for her to leave the group and I’d accept it without making it into a big deal. In the past, I would have fought with her and straightforwardly called her out because she was exaggerating a tiny issue. But by now, I’d learned that I have to be able to compromise and respect other people’s decisions even when they differ from mine.
On Election Day, our group members met in the auditorium. Sally wasn’t there. The whole school filed in and took their seats. As the lights dimmed before our campaign video was to start, all eyes turned toward the screen. Then someone tapped me on the shoulder. I turned and there was Sally standing next to me with her arms opened. She smiled and gave me a hug, “Hey,” she said. I held back my tears, but I could hear my voice shaking, “Hey, welcome back.” When the lights came back on one more person was on stage with us. I realized she really thought about my words and they affected her in a positive way.
We ended up winning the election and I am enjoying my term as class vice president. I’ve learned that there will always be conflicts, and you can either handle them in an unproductive way or with tact. With the unproductive way, you might make enemies; but with the tactful way, you form alliances and can actually affect positive change. For instance, I’m currently working on trying to change the lunch schedule because a lot of students have lunch at 10 a.m. They eat so early, and then they’re hungry later in the afternoon. Although we can’t force people to do or think as we wish, trying to understand other people’s points of view, can lead to compromise to satisfy both sides.
Becoming a Team Player
Running for student council taught me tact
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.