Barton Students Sound Off About School Closing

Clara Barton High School, located in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn, was ordered closed for two months in September due to a dangerous substance called asbestos, disrupting the lives of thousands of students.
Asbestos can resist heat and is able to keep its chemical makeup for long periods of time. It was used for fire-proofing school buildings, insulating boiler rooms, and improving sound in auditoriums. Because asbestos was so inexpensive in the 1940s, it was installed in buildings and schools throughout the country.
In the 1970s, however, it was discovered that asbestos causes cancer.
When asbestos becomes crumbled and broken, it releases invisible particles that get absorbed into the lungs. The more crumbled the asbestos becomes, the more particles are released, and the greater the chance of getting a type of lung cancer called asbestosis.
Problem Since ’84
Teachers in Clara Barton had been complaining of the potential health hazards since 1984, but were practically ignored by an official in the Division of School Buildings at the Board of Education.
After the teachers at Clara Barton hired an asbestos expert who found unacceptable levels of asbestos in some classrooms, they informed School Building officials in July, but these officials didn’t finish their own tests until late August.
The Board of Education finally had planned to clean away the asbestos over the summer.
But because the Division of School Buildings messed up, the removal began late and Barton had to be closed in September for two months. (It reopened in late October.)
While Clara Barton was closed, the students were transferred to different schools all over Brooklyn and Queens.
‘Kicked Out of Home’
It was like getting kicked out of my own home. I love my school and I’m proud of it. It was my home away from home, and now they’re gonna tell me I can’t go there anymore, that’s b.s.,” said one student.
“In a way it’s for the best that they closed the school. Now they can remove the asbestos and no one will get hurt by it,” said 16-year-old Tammy Lilly.
Another high school, Julia Richman on East 67th St. in Manhattan, was closed the first day of school, September 14, and remained closed until September 17.
Teachers in the school complained that there might be asbestos contamination due to construction in the school cafeteria, which was supposed to have been finished by the end of August but was not.
Clara Barton teachers have gone through a great deal of trouble since 1984 to protect themselves and the students from this dangerous poison.
“They thought the problem would solve itself, so they didn’t worry about it. Instead they left it and thought it would go away,” said Suzy Whilby, 19, of Clara Barton.
The students at Barton were transferred to four different schools: York College, Eli Whitney HS, East New York HS, and Paul Robeson HS. Along with the students, the teachers were also transferred to the same schools.
Two Hour Train Rides
“This whole mix-up is affecting me in a really bad way. Now the train ride takes two hours to get to York College. And the classes are not even that great, because they have only one teacher in a class with 70 kids and the classes are slow,” said 17-year-old Sharon Telford.
“Some of the classes don’t even have a blackboard,” she continued. “And all the materials for colleges are at Barton. We are using textbooks that are so old other schools won’t use them, because our books are back at Barton.
“If it wasn’t for our guidance counselors, we would not have gotten our transcripts. I’m in the Honors program, and I need recommendations from my teachers to get into a good college. I don’t know how I’m going to get them,” said Sharon.
“I don’t think it’s fair that the Board of Education did this to us. They just pulled us out of school and sent us all over the place. Clara Barton is where I belong. It’s the school I chose to go to,” said Keasha Johnson.
“I know I would rather be in Clara Barton instead of York College,” she continued. “They were telling us back at Barton that we would like it there. I don’t know why. They don’t even have any windows.”
“People were getting sick and coughing. Most of them were absent from school. We even had to take tests while the construction people were hammering away. The dust in the cafeteria, caused by the asbestos, was so thick it was foggy,” remembered Sharon.
Keasha Johnson, 17, commented, “I feel real bad about it ’cause they’re messing me up. Right now we’re behind three months in our senior dues. They knew that the problem was there and they didn’t do anything about it. Now it’s too late.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.