Barriers Must Come Down: Limited Access Often Confronts the Disabled

It’s easy for non-disabled people to take simple things for granted-walking up and down a flight of stairs, catching a cab, hopping on a bus or riding the subway. But for people with disabilities, these things are often difficult or even impossible to do.
“Being in a wheelchair, it’s hard to maneuver around the halls, and a lot of the bathrooms aren’t accessible for wheelchairs,” explained Keith Givens, 20, a mobility disabled student who attends Francis Lewis HS in Queens.
Most school and office buildings aren’t accessible to the disabled. They don’t have entrance ramps or doorways and bathrooms wide enough for people in wheelchairs, and some don’t even have elevators.
A Barrier Free School
P.S. 146 in Manhattan is one school that was made barrier free to accommodate students with mobility impairments.
“We probably have about 150 students in the special education program,” said Charles Evans, supervisor of special education at P.S. 146. He said that about 30 students are in wheelchairs and many take mainstreamed classes as well as special education classes.
Carol Ann Roberson, former director of the Mayor’s Office for People with Disabilities, said that all people who are mobility impaired would have greater freedom if schools, buildings, train stations, and city buses were barrier free.
Roberson, who’s quadriplegic (she cannot use her four limbs), stated that new and renovated buildings and public transportation are legally required to be barrier free, and accessibility is improving for the disabled. But she said old attitudes remain.
“People have stereotypes…about people with disabilities, and because of those stereotypes and myths, it’s difficult for people without disabilities to see people with disabilities as being similar,” explained Roberson.
Transportation Is an Obstacle
Transportation is a big obstacle for many disabled people. Public transportation does not -adequately serve the needs of mobility impaired people, especially those who use wheelchairs.
“Sometimes the [city] bus driver will say the lift is broken, he doesn’t have a key, or he doesn’t know how to operate it, but I now have a key for the lift,” said Givens. Mobility impaired people are given keys to operate these lifts.
Yet this does not guarantee access to city buses because many bus drivers don’t stop to pick up the disabled. Also, not all buses are equipped with lifts.
Roberson said that if she wanted to use the subway, she would have to ask herself many questions: Is the train station barrier free? And if so, when I get to my destination, is that station barrier free?
Roberson’s luckier than most disabled people. “My husband has a van,” she said. “He drives me to work. He has a ramp; he takes it out and rolls me up into the van.”
$250 Per Week
But very few mobility impaired people have the resources to buy their own van. Many are forced to pay as much as $250 a week for specially-equipped vans or buses to pick them up at their homes because the train stations and city buses aren’t accessible.
Roberson added that one common barrier that is often overlooked is the curb at the end of a block.
“If there’s no curb-cut [ramp], then the person in a wheelchair won’t be able to cross the street,” said Roberson.
Mariluz Gonzalez, 19, attends Theodore Roosevelt HS and has cerebral palsy. She said that her biggest obstacle in using a wheelchair is lack of independence: “Not being able to travel alone. I can do it, but I don’t like it.”
“When I go out I can leave the wheelchair at home. I can walk by two people holding my hands for support,” said Jean Yuin, 21, Francis Lewis HS. Yuin, like Gonzalez, rarely travels alone.
Mobility impaired for nine years, Yuin was born in the Philippines. She said that most schools in her country are not accessible to disabled students.
Legal Requirements
But changes are being made to the building code.
“All new buildings in New York City after August 1987 must be totally accessible, inside and outside, to people with disabilities,” said Roberson. She added that buildings undergoing major renovations will also have to come into total compliance.
It’s a slow process, but eventually all new schools, office buildings, restaurants, stores, and public transportation will be barrier free and people with mobility impairments will have greater freedom.
In the meantime, Roberson hopes that attitudes toward the disabled will continue to change.
“Students should be aware that other students that have disabilities are very much like they are,” said Roberson. “I hope the students will be the ones to change all of the negative attitudes toward people with disabilities.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.