Baptized and Bat Mitzvahed

Like most other kids, I had no choice over which religion I’d follow growing up. But now that I’m in a position to choose, I’m not sure whether I feel closer to Judaism or Christianity.
I was born Catholic. I was baptized when I was an infant, and for many years, my mom, my older sister Monique, and I went to church every Sunday. Mom made sure that we said our prayers each night and read the Bible.
Still, I wasn’t really into church. I was often bored and usually fell asleep.
But if I needed guidance, I would pray to God on my own. I felt like I had my own personal connection to him outside of church.
A Happy Catholic
And I loved the holidays. Christmas was my favorite because it was when all my family and friends came together, exchanged presents and had fun. I also liked Easter because I enjoyed coloring and hiding the eggs with my family and receiving baskets of candy from them.
I was happy being Catholic, but that changed when my Mom decided to remarry.
My parents separated when I was three. When I turned 7, my mother met a Jewish man from Israel named Eli.
“What do you think of him?” my mom asked Monique and me after she’d brought him to the house.
Engaged to a Jewish Man
We told her we didn’t like him because he bought us fake Barbies and told corny jokes. We preferred other guys she’d dated.
But my mom just laughed at what we said. I felt like our opinion didn’t really matter. She wanted to be with him, regardless of what we thought. So after dating for a year, they got engaged.
Since Eli was Jewish, and his religion was important to him, my mom started to practice Judaism before she got married, right around the time I made my communion. I was 8.
I was so proud when I made my communion. I felt like it was an accomplishment because I knew I’d finally be able to eat the holy bread that the priest gave out at every Sunday service.
No Holy Bread for Me
But soon after my communion, we stopped going to church. I felt cheated that I wasn’t able to eat the bread.
Then my mom started to teach me about Judaism and the stories behind it. I liked some things about the religion, like the idea of only worshipping God and not having to pray to Jesus.
I didn’t realize, however, that Mom was planning to marry Eli and then convert. I figured that she just wanted to educate me about another religion.
After a while, she asked me and Monique if we wanted to become Jewish. I felt like I didn’t really have a choice because we weren’t going to church anymore. So I said to myself, “What the hell, I’ll convert.”
But I didn’t realize just how different Judaism was from Catholicism. I didn’t fully understand that converting meant I wouldn’t be Catholic anymore.
Converted to Judaism
Monique, my mom, and I went to a rabbi for the ceremony to change our religion. Monique, who was 11, thought what Mom was having us do was stupid, but I went along with it.
At first I didn’t think that much about my new religion. We even celebrated the first Christmas after our conversion. But the following December, Mom said, “We’re not celebrating Christmas or Easter anymore. You’ve had eight years of celebrating Christmas and that’s plenty.”
I was devastated. It was the first day of Hanukah, but I was so upset about not having Christmas that I cried the whole day.
Sad Over Christmas Memories
I thought about how I used to wake up early and run into the living room and see tons of presents. Christmas songs went through my head, which made me feel even sadder. Something that was a major part of me had been taken away.
Celebrating Hanukah for the first time was so boring. All we did was light candles. I just sat there, playing with a dreidel.
Over the next few years, I struggled with my conversion. Every time Christmas came, I felt pain in my heart. I really missed celebrating the holiday. I didn’t feel Jewish. I felt like I was pretending to be something I wasn’t.
We Moved to Israel
Then Eli decided he wanted to live in Israel to be closer to his parents. So my mom decided we would move there to start a new life with him in a different country.
Moving to Israel when I was 11 changed how Jewish I felt. I moved to a place where almost everyone around me was Jewish.
After we moved, Eli became more religious, which meant he was more strict about us observing the rules of the religion. We weren’t allowed to use electricity on Friday nights and Saturdays in observation of Shabbat (the Jewish Sabbath).
I was required to wear dresses and go to yeshiva, which is a Jewish school. I only ate kosher food and said prayers before every meal, before I went to sleep, when I went to the bathroom, and when I woke up.
Hard to Adjust at First
At first, it was very hard for me, because it’s not easy changing everything you used to do and wear and eat. Ob-serving the Shabbat was hard, too. I sometimes felt so bored without electricity because I couldn’t watch TV or listen to music.
When I wanted to watch TV on Saturdays, my mom made it seem like I was doing something wrong to God. She’d say God just wants us to rest on that day.
Still, sometimes I’d sneak and watch TV in my room, making sure I locked the door. I never got in trouble, but I did feel guilty breaking Shabbat when my mom talked about how important it was.
I felt angry at Eli, too. When my sister or I turned the lights on by accident, Eli would yell at us and attempt to hit us. This made me furious.
I Felt More Connected
But, in other ways, I began to feel more connected to the religion. All that praying was paying off. I felt more in touch with God, like I was sending him a direct, continuous message that I believed in him.
Praying also seemed easier when I was surrounded by my Jewish friends. We often celebrated holidays and rituals together. On Fridays and Saturdays, when we couldn’t use electricity, my friends and I would do things like play hide and seek. That’s when Shabbat was fun.
And I even began to enjoy some of the traditions, like making my bat mitzvah. A bat mitzvah is like a graduation that celebrates a girl becoming more mature. My bat mitzvah reminded me of my communion.
We Left Israel
Even though I was adjusting to Judaism, things weren’t working out with my mother and Eli. So after living in Israel for a year, my mom, Monique, and I moved back to America, along with my brother, who was born before we moved to Israel, and my little sister, who was born in Israel.
Eli followed my mom back to the U.S. and they tried to stay together one more time. But it didn’t work, so they eventually got a divorce. It felt good to have him out of our lives.
As a family, we stopped being so religious, but we still celebrated the Jewish holidays because my half-siblings were being raised as Jews. At first, I still only ate kosher foods because I felt guilty when I ate non-kosher. And I still celebrated Hanukah and most of the Jewish holidays, since my mom celebrated them.
But little by little, I became less strict about observing them. I felt a sense of freedom and relief since I could now practice Judaism in my own way. I felt like I had more control of my life.
But I also felt trapped by confusion. I didn’t know what to consider myself, since deep down inside, I still felt Catholic.
When I visited my real father, he’d say, “Whatever you’re born into, that’s what you are. You’re just practicing Judaism.” For a while, I considered converting to Catholicism again. But after putting so much into Judaism, I felt that it had become my religion.
Christmas Not the Same
Since I missed Christmas so much, I urged Mom to start celebrating it again, alongside Hanukah. But celebrating Christmas again didn’t feel the same. She just didn’t have the same holiday spirit that I remembered.
I’m still very confused about religion, which is why I don’t go to church or temple anymore. I’m not sure which place I’d feel more comfortable in. But I continue to hold onto my faith in God because I believe that he’s the Creator, and I have a deep connection to him.
Told Mom How I Felt
Two years ago, when I was 15, I told my mom how I felt. “You shouldn’t have made me convert so young and so soon, and then, on top of it all, move to a different country,” I said.
I told her she didn’t give me or my sister time to think about converting, and that we hadn’t practiced the religion before we converted to give us a taste of what it would be like. I told her that at such a young age, a kid doesn’t know enough about life to make a decision about what religion she wants to have.
“What do you want me to do?” she said. “People make mistakes and you’ll get over it.
I was angry at her response. I resent having been yanked back and forth between religions. It made my life confusing.
I can’t change the past, but at least I know I won’t confuse my children. I will raise them under one religion and then they can decide if they want to stick to it or change it as they get older. My kids will have a choice.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.