How many New York City students drop out of high school each year? Answering that question isn’t as easy as you’d think, because not everyone agrees on what should be counted as “dropping out.”
Last June, the Department of Education (DoE) announced that the dropout rate had fallen to a low of about 13%. But what if that’s because of calculation methods, and not student performance?
That’s the question asked by Jennifer L. Jennings of Columbia University’s Department of Sociology and Leonie Haimson, executive director of the education nonprofit Class Size Matters, in the report High School Discharges Revisited: Changes in New York City’s Discharge Rates, 2000-2007. This report, published last April, looks at how New York City classifies students who begin public high school in the city but don’t graduate.
‘Discharge’ or Dropout?
Some of these kids are classified as “transfers.” Others are “discharges.” Some of the discharges are counted as dropouts, and some aren’t. But a discharged kid that the federal government would count as a dropout isn’t always counted that way in New York City.
For example, a student who withdraws from school because she’s pregnant would be counted as a dropout under federal guidelines. But in New York City, she’s just a discharged student who doesn’t add to the official dropout number.
Likewise, if a student is expelled from school, he’s dropped out according to federal classification. But in New York, he’s just a discharged student. The same is true for students who leave high school after the age of 21 without graduating, or who enroll in a full-time GED program that’s not run by New York City schools: The feds call them dropouts but the city does not.
No Disclosure
Of course, there are legitimate reasons why a student leaving a school would be considered merely “discharged” and not a dropout-for instance, if a student moves out of the city or transfers to a private school. But because the city doesn’t disclose records showing who was discharged for what reason, we don’t know which discharges are dropouts under another name.
What is clear is that New York City schools discharge thousands of students each year. By publicly reporting its discharge records in detail, the DoE could provide a much clearer picture of how many students who start high school actually finish.
Case Study:
What Shrank the Class of ’07?
Of the nearly 89,000 students who enrolled as New York City high school freshmen in 2003, less than half graduated within four years. The city’s official graduation rate does not take into account the 18,000 “discharged” students.
TOTAL DID NOT graduate: 53%
Discharged 21%
Still in school 19%
Dropped out 11%
GED 2%
Graduated on time: 47%
*These figures do not include Special Education students. Data is from the NYC Dept. of Education Research and Policy Support Group.
Are Dropout Numbers Real?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.