You’ve looked through various guidebooks, tons of colorful brochures, visited 10 colleges in five days, and now you have a list of schools you’re dying to go to. The next logical question is: how do you get in?
Well, the first thing you need to do is get applications from the schools you’re interested in. Deadlines vary and can be anywhere from the end of December to the end of February. So, if you’re a senior in high school and still haven’t gotten your applications, get on the phone as soon as you finish this article.
The easiest way to get an application is to call or write to the college. (You can get the addresses and phone numbers from college guidebooks or from your school’s college office.) SUNY and CUNY applications may be available in your school.
Filling Out the Forms
Next, you have to fill out those applications. But before you do, make copies of all the blank application forms and practice on those first. Neatness counts. “Sloppy applications are an automatic negative,” says Edward Custard, a former college admissions officer and author of The Big Book of Colleges. “Make sure [your application] is legible and well put-together.”
The first page of most applications asks for the same basic information (such as your full name, address, and social security number). They get a little tedious after a while so pay attention to what you’re doing or you’ll make mistakes. (I had to use the white-out a lot, because I kept filling in my home address where they asked for my school’s address.)
Most schools also ask you to submit a personal essay, a high school transcript, SAT scores, teacher recommendations and financial aid forms. If you are planning on applying for financial aid, make sure you get all the forms you need for each college. Make sure you meet all deadlines for all the parts of the applications.
Now that you know how to apply to the colleges on your list, you’re probably wondering: so what do colleges look at when going through their pile of applications? How do they decide who to accept and who to reject? And what can I do to get them to accept me?
Grades and SATS
The first and most important thing they look at is your high school transcript. That’s the piece of paper which lists all the courses you’ve taken in high school along with the grades you got. (Unfortunately, there’s not much a senior can do about that “F” in freshman math!)
Admissions officers say that they not only look at your grades but also at the kind of courses you took. If you’re wondering which is more important-taking hard courses or getting good grades, there’s no easy answer. If you want to impress them, Custard says, “Take the most challenging courses and do well.”
The next important things are your SAT scores. When you look up a college in a guidebook, the average SAT scores of students who have been admitted to the school may be listed. Although most colleges don’t automatically reject students just because their SATs fall below a certain score, SATs are one of the main criteria they use to weed out applicants.
Some colleges require that in addition to the SAT I (the three-hour test with verbal and math sections), you also take three SAT II tests (these are one-hour tests in subjects like Math, Biology, a foreign language, etc.). Make sure you take all the required tests. (By the way, there are a few colleges, like Bates College in Maine, that don’t require any sort of standardized tests.)
Recommendations and Essays
Grades and scores aren’t the only things that matter. Colleges also want to know what kind of person you are and one way they find that out is through teacher recommendations. (I hated this part-it can be a little embarrassing asking teachers to write them for you.) Some schools don’t require any recommendations, some require one, and others require two. They usually want teachers from your junior year-check the applications to see if a specific year or subject teacher is required.
Jennifer Fondiller, director of admissions at Eugene Lang College, says that colleges use these recommendations to see how involved a student was in class. Custard adds that they are also “supposed to show a side of students that’s more human than the numbers.” He says colleges want to know about your “personal strengths-self-discipline, intellectual curiosity, self-awareness.”
So a teacher who’s just going to talk about your grades won’t really help. It’s best to ask teachers in whose class you did reasonably well and who also got to know you. Remember that recommendations take time to write and you’re not the only person who needs one. Don’t wait until the day before they’re due to ask. Make sure you give your teachers enough time and all the information they will need.
Some colleges accept one or two additional recommendations from people who know you from outside of school (for example: a boss, a coach or an advisor for an extracurricular activity). But five recommendations from your family members aren’t going to help!
Then there’s the personal essay. This could be the best part of your application or one of the worst experiences of your life. Like the recommendations, your essay is supposed to help the colleges get to know you as an individual. Some colleges give you specific questions to answer, and others just give a general question like, “Tell us something about yourself that is not mentioned anywhere else in the application.” Custard advises that whatever the question is, “always write about yourself.” (For more advice on writing the essay, see the story on page 11.)
Activities and Interests
The colleges aren’t just looking for people to fill up their classrooms. They also want students who will get involved in other aspects of campus life. This is where your extracurricular activities come in. These tell the colleges more about your talents and the kinds of things that interest you.
Fondiller says that “what you do outside of school is very important.” According to Custard, colleges look for “breadth and depth.” Senior year is not the time to run and join 10 different clubs and sports teams. Colleges are more impressed with someone who’s been heavily involved in a few different activities over time. And it’s not just school-related activities that count. If you have job or do volunteer work outside of school, make sure the colleges know that.
Another way that colleges get to know applicants is through interviews. These are either conducted by the admissions officers themselves or by alumni of the school. Not all schools require interviews but most offer them.
If an interview is not required, it may not be in your best interest to do one. Custard warns, “Interviews can go badly-[they are] not an automatic positive.” But if you think you can make a better impression in person than on paper, it may be a good idea.
Fondiller advises students to be themselves, but to approach the interview in a formal way, the way you would a job interview. Dress nicely (but not too nicely), don’t chew gum, don’t be late, etc.
Go prepared with information about the school (they’ll probably ask why you want to go to there and it’ll help if you can be specific). Most interviewers won’t ask you weird questions like, “If you could be a vegetable for a day, which one would you be?” They’re more likely to ask about your schoolwork and your extracurricular activities. And remember: an interview is also an opportunity for you to ask questions about the school.
Some final advice: If you have any questions at any time during this whole process, ask your counselors or call the colleges. (If you need more help than your school can provide, try contacting one of the “College Help” organizations listed on page 14.) Use the resourcesyou have available to you and some common sense. Make sure you meet all deadlines and that you respond to all correspondence (calls, letters) from the schools you are applying to. And, by the way, don’t forget to enjoy your senior year in high school!
Applying to College: What Do They Want from Me?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.