I interviewed Mel Schneiderman, a psychologist who has two important titles: He’s the chief psychologist of New York Foundling and also the director of the Vincent J. Fontana Center for Child Protection. He supervises other psychologists. He also treats and evaluates children and families who come to New York Foundling.
We talked about what happens when staff and residents get involved. I learned how much of an effect relations between staff and residents can have on girls. It made me feel good to report about this issue because people need to know what should and shouldn’t happen in situations like this.
Q: Why are there rules in group homes and residential treatment centers that staff aren’t supposed to become romantically or sexually involved with the young people they work with?
A: Number one, although it’s not the most important, is that it’s against the law. It constitutes sexual abuse.
It’s also exploitation of children. Kids in care have had difficult lives. They’ve been separated from their parents and they may feel vulnerable. They often have a strong need for connection and family, and this can make them more vulnerable to being taken advantage of.
Staff are older and they’re the authority, so that can put them in a position where they could take advantage of someone who’s looking for love and connection. When staff sleep with residents, it’s a betrayal of trust, because the staff who do that are exercising their own needs.
Staff are hired to take care of the kids. They’re not there to gratify their own sex drive or need for a relationship. Those things should be taken care of outside the workplace. When they take care of their own needs rather than thinking of the needs of the young person, that’s a betrayal of trust and can have a very harmful effect.
Q: What are some of the harmful effects it could have on residents?
A: When the relationship starts, the young person may feel in love and taken care of. But the relationship is starting out secret. It’s illicit. It’s not allowed by society, so the relationship has some negative complications already.
Then, chances are, there’s going to be a break-up. The young person may feel abandoned or betrayed. She may feel hurt, angry and not as trusting of other authority figures. She might become self-destructive. If there’s a history of sexual abuse, this may compound the trauma. It may lead to suicide, low self-esteem or promiscuity if the young person feels the need to make up for the loss. When the young person gets older, she may feel used or taken advantage of.
The staff person, if caught, could go to jail or be fired. Then the youth might feel guilty or angry. She may have feelings that disrupt her adjustment in the home.
Q: Is it always harmful when staff have relations with residents?
A: People have different reactions. A resident may fall in love and get satisfaction, not just sexually, but also emotionally, from the relationship. It may help a young person’s self-esteem. And sometimes that love could be reciprocated, where the staff falls in love, too.
But because it’s a secret relationship, and because it’s a relationship with someone who’s in a position of authority and power, the overwhelming majority of times it’s not going to work out, and there’s going to be fallout as a result.
Even when there are negative consequences, some youth are more resilient than others. Some youth can take it in stride. But for most youth, when it happens, it’s going to be damaging.
Q: Is it worse if the youth is young, like 14, and the staff is older, versus if the youth and the staff are closer in age?
A: I tend to think that the greater the power discrepancy or age difference there is, the more possibility of manipulation. But it also has to do with the child’s vulnerability. There might be a 14-year-old who’s less vulnerable than an 18-year-old.
It depends on other factors, too. For instance, does the 18-year-old have a history of sexual abuse or neglect?
It also depends on how the relationship develops. Now if an 18-year-old and a 21-year-old meet outside a work situation, that’s not that large an age difference. But at work, staff have a power status that makes it different. It’s different from an 18-year-old going to a club and meeting a 21-year-old. There are different rules. So it could still be damaging even if there isn’t such a great age difference.
Q: Who should stop it, the residents or the staff?
A: Young people should know that they may wind up getting hurt by a relationship like this, and that it’s something to steer clear of. But it’s not the responsibility of the youth to stop this. Staff are really responsible and they should know better. They should be trained to know better.
We all fall in love and have crushes on older people. It’s the responsibility of the staff not to act on the young person’s crush.
Q: Have you dealt with situations where this has happened?
A: I have never dealt with a situation like this directly, and I hope it’s because we hire good staff. I don’t know what the statistics are about it, but I have heard of it happening, and there are adolescents in our program receiving treatment for it.
Q: How do you think these situations should be dealt with when they do happen?
A: One question is how to deal with the staff. The other is how to deal with the youth. I think the primary concern is how to deal with the youth.
As far as the staff, legally and morally, there has to be an investigation. It has to be called into the State Central Registry, which will do an investigation. If the agency doesn’t call it in and they’re found to be legally responsible, people in the administration can be arrested or the agency can be closed down. So you have to follow procedures. Not only may the staff be fired, but they may also be arrested.
Equally important is what the reaction of the youth is going to be. She may have a whole host of feelings. She may be angry at the administration for taking away someone who she really cares about. She may feel depressed, taken advantage of. She has to be helped and supported.
And the rest of the kids in the group home have to be spoken to and told what’s happened. There are confidentiality issues and you do have to respect that young person’s privacy. But usually on campuses things like this spread like wildfire and there has to be a way to address the questions.
Q: What do you think agencies can do so that it doesn’t happen in the first place?
A: Agencies need to train the staff. We have to talk about the issue and about the power imbalance. We can do role playing. Sometimes we assume people would know these things, but we shouldn’t assume that. Agencies have to put in place appropriate training and maintain good supervision.
An Unfair Advantage
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.