Advice for Dr. Fernandez: What the New Chancellor Needs to Do

The New York City school system is an educational battlefield that has long befuddled teachers and administrators alike. On January 1, a new soldier will enter into this never-ending fray. He is Dr. Joseph A. Fernandez, the former superintendent of the Dade County-Miami schools, who will soon be the new schools chancellor.
Dr. Fernandez joins the system at a time of crisis. Thirty percent of all public school students will drop out before the 12th grade. Those who remain will be haunted by the presence of violence and drugs.
Meanwhile, incompetent staff and corrupt administrators continue to be a drain on the system.
It is apparent that the new schools chancellor must possess a special background in order to combat these problems. Dr. Fernandez appears to have the necessary experience.
Similar Problems In Miami
He hails from an area very much like New York. Miami schools are similar in their racial and ethnic population and in the types of issues they face. Dr. Fernandez’s achievements in Miami would seem to indicate that he’ll do well in New York.
Dr. Luis Reyes, deputy director for research and advocacy at ASPIRA of New York, a community based agency that provides services to the Latino community, echoed these sentiments.
“That he has done a good job in Dade County makes the possibility of him succeeding even better,” he said, commenting on Dr. Fernandez’s performance.
However, most of the previous chancellors also came from similar school systems, if not from New York itself. What, then, prevented them from effectively dealing with the issues?
“All of the chancellors in the past tried to address the problems, but never provided any long-term plans,” observed Dr. Gwendolyn C. Baker, a member of the New York City Board of Education. “I think one of the biggest problems is that people just jump in and try to solve them without considering them first.”
And indeed, Dr. Fernandez has considered the system’s problems to a great degree already, having announced plans to challenge one of New York’s greatest scholastic stumbling blocks-the issue of principal tenure.
Soon after he was appointed to the chancellor’s post in mid-September, Dr. Fernandez vowed to alter this system, whereby senior principals are granted near total immunity from job removal.
Issue of Principal Tenure
Many educational leaders applauded the proposal, while others have taken a more lukewarm view.
“The tenure process should be streamlined to get rid of administrators who are not doing their jobs,” said Dr. Reyes. “Principals should be judged on performance-based evaluations of how well they are able to improve education in their schools.”
Richard Murphy, coordinator of the Neighborhood Family Services Coalition, felt that efforts would be better concentrated on the attitudinal rather than the administrative character of principals.
“Does a principal have control over his teachers? Instead of [revising tenure policy], teach him how to be an inspirational leader,” he suggested.
This difference of opinion among education reformers is not uncommon. What is uncommon, though, is that virtually all education activists agree that greater importance should be placed on the schools themselves rather than on administrative quarrels.
Dr. Fernandez shares this view. One of his most praised accomplishments in Dade County was the establishment of a school-based management program that gives parents, faculties, and administrators significant control over policy implementation in individual schools.
School-Based Management
In New York, many educational leaders proposed extending the school-based management franchise to students. Heather Lewis, director of the Center for Collaborative Education, a network of eight public schools, is one of the numerous proponents of the plan.
“Teachers, parents, and students do not feel ownership of their schools,” she said of the current system. “The school can no longer be looked at as a building. We must create a sense of communication among administration and parents and students.”
Ms. Lewis said this goal could be achieved if schools were smaller and teachers were involved in the school’s decision-making process.
She added that students must be taught, not lectured to, Then they can become part of a learning process where they are not just passive participants.”
It seems logical that the best and most effective proposals would allow the students themselves to play active roles in the processes which govern them.
“I think Dr. Fernandez’s focus is the right way to go,” said Robin Wilner, deputy executive director of Interface, a public policy research organization. “His ideas for school-based planning are great, because that’s where the kids are. Schools can’t be run from 110 Livingston St.”
Dr. Baker summed up this approach best: “The system doesn’t belong to the Board. This system doesn’t belong to the administrators. The system belongs to the people of the City of New York.”
Addressing the Dropout Rate
But while educators emphasize the importance of concentrating on individual schools and students, they have not lost sight of the fact that administrators must be more carefully scrutinized. After all, many of our schools’ problems are due to the corrupt bureaucrats who plague the system. This issue is seen as a major objective which Dr. Fernandez must overcome.
“There should be a higher level of accountability in schools to improve them and provide innovative reforms,” commented Dr. Reyes.
Ms. Wilner agreed: “He needs to work on the accountability of the central Board so they stop creating problems.”
On the school level, Dr. Fernandez’s revised tenure system would get rid of a good portion of the incompetent administrators in the system.
Dr. Fernandez’s toughest challenge, however, will surely be the alarmingly high dropout rate. The best approach, said Dr. Baker, would be the gradual formulation of a battle plan to reduce dropouts.
“Take a look at the system first,” she warned. “Being a dropout is not a one-year or one-month or a one-day problem. In order to make children satisfied in school and what they do there, you have to provide a program that goes from kindergarten to grade 12.”
Mr. Murphy suggested a similar strategy for dealing with the deep-seated problems which weaken schools. “He has to make a two-tiered effort,” he said, referring to administrative and in-school reforms. “Look at where the lads are, then devise a system from that vantage point. Children spend only 20% of their hours in school. You have to find a way to address that other 80%.”
Student Concerns
Surprisingly, students who voiced their concerns often agreed with the reformers. “It’s so hard to get inefficient and unproductive teachers out of the system,” noted one student. Others called for more personal interaction with teachers and more freedom in decision making in their schools. More visible problems such as school violence took a secondary position to curricular and administrative concerns, primarily because students felt that the problems were caused by social conditions that the chancellor could not correct. Whatever issues Dr. Femandez chooses to address first, he will have to move quickly and decisively in restructuring the system. One thing is certain: the road to educational reform in New York will be a long one.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.