We had a dog named Button when I was in elementary school and living with my aunt and my beloved grandmother. Button was a collie, a black and hairy little thing with a white patch of fur on her neck and a big fluffy tail. Her coat was always well kept, as if she were the president’s pooch.
When somebody rang the doorbell, there she’d go, carrying on with her annoying “woof woof.” Then it was between my grandmother and my aunt to say, “Shut up, Button.” She would obey, then go to her spot looking grumpy, as if she felt she wasn’t appreciated for protecting the family.
I loved Button. She always knew when to come around. When my grandmother made me sit at the table until I finished everything on my plate, here came Super Dog, Button, the lifesaver. Once Button finished everything, I would put my plate in the sink and let Grandma know I was finished. I knew she was checking the garbage can for napkins full of food.
My Guardian Angel on the Night Shift
That wasn’t the only time Button stood by my side. When I was little I had nightmares about monsters under my bed and ghosts in the basement that traveled the house at night. I kept the light on for safety. The electricity bill must have run sky high, because my grandma started saying, “You know, I’m not married to Con Edison, so turn the light off.” Then I could just barely see those green glowing eyes-Button! She’d post up right beside my bed until I fell asleep. She was my guardian angel on the night shift as I slept.
On days when I got suspended from school, my aunt told me that when Grandma got home she was going to beat my butt. I would go to bed and cry, trying to think of a good technique to avoid consequences for my behavior. Here came Button to cheer me up, slapping her wet sandpaper tongue against my face.
My buddy was my whole family’s best friend. My Grandma wasn’t with Grandpa, so she needed some attention. My Grandma would hum an opera melody to our dog (waking me from my sheep and fences, thinking to myself, “Who can tolerate such pain to the sensitive ears?”)
To my surprise, I’d see Button enjoying the big lady singing. She would sit there and wag her tail, as if she really knew about Mozart or Beethoven or any of those people. Button just wasn’t your average dog. (Though I still tell Grandma, “Her tail was only wagging because the poor dog was hungry, just waiting for you to put some food on her plate.”)
Button by My Side
What really drew me close to Button was her big heart. When she realized that I needed attention, she’d come leaping up on me to give me comfort.
At that time, I was going through stages, wanting my mother to be there for me more often, and feeling a lot of anger that I’d been deprived of a father. My anger interfered with how I interacted with the other kids in school, because I didn’t really know how to handle myself in rough situations. I would fight. I believed that if Button could tag along with me in school, then I’d have no problems. At least when I got home, she was always by my side.
Betrayed by My Buddy
Until the day it happened. I was playing with her by holding her jaw shut. The moment I let go, she bit me right in the middle of my thumb. I lay on my bed crying, holding my thumb with a napkin to stop the bleeding, and feeling like my buddy had betrayed me. There she lay beside my bed, whining as if to apologize for what she had done. I wasn’t hearing it. Instead I threw teddy bears at her until she left me alone. From that day on, I didn’t think to pet her or even meet her eyes.
You know, it’s like they always say: don’t bite the hand that feeds you. (If I bit my grandmother, do you think for one moment that she’d be feeding me? No, I’d probably be in the loony wards, taking therapy and writing 100 times, “I eat food, not people.” I can only imagine telling my grandma, “I’m sorry for biting you, can I come back home now?” The phone clicks in reply.)
But Button didn’t give up. She still came to the side of my bed each night. I didn’t really acknowledge her. She’d already bitten me once.
So I slept with the covers over my head, though at times I’d peek out. I wouldn’t see her until she opened her eyes to make contact with mine. Then there she was. I didn’t have it in my heart to forgive her, but I didn’t chase her away either.
Finding Forgiveness
At the time, my mother came to visit the family almost every day. When she found out Button bit me, she said that it wasn’t like Button to bite, so something must be wrong. For the next couple of days we all kept an eye on Button. We noticed that she was hardly eating. Then she stopped eating altogether. We took her to the vet, but I guess there was nothing they could do. They advised us to put her to sleep if she didn’t get any better.
For a while, Button held on. Then one day she started bleeding from her mouth and nobody could stand to watch her suffer anymore. That day my grandma explained to me that Button was going to die and there was nothing that anybody could do about it.
I was still upset that she’d bitten me, but I went to Button and cried as I held her in my arms. Then I realized that I was no longer angry with Button. I forgave her. I loved her.
Her Last Night
Finding out that Button was dying left me feeling like a child who’s lost her mother. Even though Button was just a dog, she was my plate cleaner, my guardian angel, and most of all, she was my friend. Knowing she wouldn’t be there for me left me feeling empty. I felt so sad, knowing that night would be her last.
That night I didn’t go to sleep. Instead, Button and I switched up our routine-I watched over her until she fell asleep. I talked to her, letting her know how much I was going to miss her, and how much she would like it in doggy heaven. I told her the angels would give her lots of Milkbones and she wouldn’t have to worry about who was going to walk her. In doggy heaven, she’d be able to walk herself.
The next morning my uncle came to pick up Button. As my uncle strapped Button in the back seat of his car, we all stood in the doorway, feeling helpless, with tears in our eyes. Button was a member of our Knights family, and now I felt as if a part of me was being ripped away. As my uncle pulled away, we all waved goodbye to Button. Her eyes never left our sight, as if she knew this was the end.
Empty Without My Dog
For a long time after that, I felt empty. It just felt good to know that there was someone watching over me, protecting me and tending to my needs, even if that love was coming from a dog.
Later I realized that Button taught me a lot of lessons in life. She taught me to never hold a grudge, and to forgive people because once they’re gone they never come back. My pal also taught me that life goes on even after you lose someone you love. Most of all Button taught me (I’m not saying that I’ve fully mastered it and all-come on, no one’s perfect) that there are just some things in life that you can’t change. There are some hurtful things in life that I need to accept and move on from.
Thanks to my companion, Button, I realized that even after someone’s gone, I don’t have to feel like I’ve been left empty. My memories of our good times together have left me full.
A Smooch from a Pooch
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.