(Names in this story have been changed.)
In my sophomore year in high school I met two girls, Jessica and Elizabeth. Soon I was dating both of them.
Jessica was a pretty girl in my Humanities class. She dressed to get a guy’s attention, with tight jeans and a tight shirt showing off her body. She was the kind of girl who’s always with guys and never stops talking about them. That irritated me, but she was cute, so I started flirting with her.
Jessica was well known around the school and she knew a lot of pretty girls. I hadn’t dated anyone at the school yet, and I figured that if girls saw me with her, they would start to notice me more and maybe want to be with me also.
Kissing All Over the School
I started talking to Jessica and we became friends. About two weeks later, we had our first kiss. We started messing around in school, during lunch and after classes, but we didn’t see each other outside of school. I didn’t know what she did after school and I didn’t care; Jessica did her thing and I did mine.
Me and Jessica would kiss in class, lunch, gym, pretty much any place in school. And of course we kissed in front of school at dismissal.
Lots of people in school mess around like that, so it’s not like we stood out. But you know in high school everyone talks.
Jessica and I had been messing around for about two months when I met Elizabeth, my friend’s ex-girlfriend. She was sweet and not as much of a flirt as Jessica. Sometimes she’d wear tight clothes, but most other times she just wore jeans and a shirt and a pair of Tims. Elizabeth had just come to the school that year, so not that many people knew her.
Messing with Elizabeth
I always was happy when I was with Elizabeth. Although I was still messing around with Jessica, I liked Elizabeth more. I was on the baseball team for my school and Elizabeth was on the girls’ team, so we spent a lot of time together after school.
When Elizabeth and I started messing around, she didn’t ask me if I was involved with anyone else and I didn’t bring it up either. I figured that if she were to find out that I was with someone else she’d get mad. But I told myself that if she didn’t ask, she didn’t care, so I never mentioned to Elizabeth that I was with Jessica.
Being with two girls made me feel really good about myself and gave me a new sense of confidence. I felt more popular. I figured if I could get two girls in one school, I could get any girl.
I loved it. It was like all my problems went away and I just had girls on my mind all the time. Having two girls is a burden, but it’s better than having to think about school work.
To me, my relationships with Elizabeth and Jessica were casual. I liked messing around and hanging out with them but didn’t want the relationship to become more than that. I liked them, but not enough for either of them to be my girl, and how I felt about them never came up in conversation with either one.
I liked it that way. I thought it was cool to go from one girl to another without either of them knowing. To go and kiss Jessica when I had just kissed Elizabeth gave me a thrill. It made me feel more confident about myself and my ability to attract girls. I didn’t want to lose that feeling.
I was doing OK with my double burden for a week until Jessica missed a day of school. So now I only had one girl to deal with. Easy, right? I don’t think so.
Caught in the Hall
At dismissal, I was in the hall and getting ready to go home when Elizabeth came up to me. “Baby I’m in a rush. I got to go,” I told her. I didn’t want to spend too much time there because everyone passes through. Plus, that hall was more Jessica territory.
But Elizabeth said, “Let me get a kiss.” So we started to make out. When we stopped, though, I looked to my left and saw all of Jessica’s friends just looking at me in disgust.
For a moment, I was a little alarmed, because it was like I got caught, but I just smiled at them and walked away. I really didn’t think anything would happen, but I don’t know why I thought that.
The next day, when I was in class doing my work, Jessica came to the door asking to speak to me. Everyone in the class started whispering. I went outside the class and I saw Elizabeth there.
When I saw both of them, all I could think about was what the hell was I going to say. They both looked real pissed.
Pick One, Drop One?
“Why didn’t you tell me you was with someone?” Elizabeth said to me.
“You didn’t ask,” I said.
They both said, “You’re going to have to choose one or the other.” I guess they both took the relationships more seriously then I did.
“All right, I’ll tell you after school,” I said. The rest of the day I tried to avoid Elizabeth and Jessica.
For a split second, I wondered who I would choose, but I quickly decided I needed to say something that would allow me to keep both Jessica and Elizabeth. Both of them were pretty, and they were good people to be around.
But even more important to me was how cool it was to be with two girls from the same school. I didn’t want to lose either of them because it was such a thrill to be with both. All I was thinking about was how good I felt. I was looking out for my happiness, not theirs.
I Lied to Both
So at the end of the day, I went to Elizabeth and told her that I was going to be with her and not Jessica. I gave her a kiss and then went to the other side of the school to Jessica. I told Jessica that I was going to be with her and only her. I gave her a kiss and then went home through the back way so I wouldn’t see both girls at the same time. I felt pretty smooth.
My plan worked for about a month. I looked forward to coming to school because every day was an adventure. I didn’t know if I was going to get caught. My schedule worked perfectly with my relationships, because I only shared classes and lunch with Jessica, not Elizabeth.
The halls, though, were unsafe. I was vulnerable there, because either girl could come up to me and kiss me with people watching; I could’ve gotten caught at any time.
I don’t know how I was doing it; I was the envy of a lot of guys in the school. They would come up to me and say, “Yo, how you didn’t get caught yet?” or “You the man.” Hearing that gassed up my head. I would tell them, “I got skills, don’t be hating on me.” I thought I was the man of the school.
Drama in the Stairway
One day, class had finished and everyone was going to lunch. I took Jessica to the staircase with me. We started kissing and I heard someone coming down the stairs, but I didn’t pay any attention and kept on kissing Jessica. I opened one eye to see who was passing by, and it was Elizabeth.
“Holy sh-t,” I thought. For a second I got scared, but I gathered my thoughts and calmed down. Elizabeth didn’t say anything. She just kept on walking down the stairs.
“That’s good, she knows now that you’re mine,” said Jessica. But I didn’t really pay attention to what Jessica was saying. I was more worried about what I was going to tell Elizabeth. I told Jessica I had to see a teacher and ran down the stairs hoping to catch up with Elizabeth.
When I did, I said that Jessica was kissing me; I wasn’t kissing her back. “She forced me to kiss her,” I lied. Elizabeth didn’t say anything and just started to kiss me. Elizabeth didn’t like Jessica, so she was happy to blame her instead of me. “Tell that b-tch that it’s over between you two,” she said.
“All right,” I said.
“Yeah, right,” I thought. I didn’t want to change anything.
I Cared About Me Only
I planned to keep telling Elizabeth I’m with her and only her and telling Jessica the same. I was so caught up in the fun of being with two girls that I didn’t care about what they wanted. I only cared about myself.
It’s such a small school that I don’t think that they really believed me when I told them that I was only with one girl. I think maybe neither one wanted to give up first; they were having their own competition. I kept thinking that if I got caught again, one or the other would break up with me, but that didn’t happen.
I also worried that their competition over me might escalate into a fight. Well, honestly, I would say about 25% of me didn’t want them to fight because I didn’t want them to get hurt. The other 75% of me thought it might be cool to see two girls fight over me.
But no one got into any fights, and I continued my daily adventure with Elizabeth and Jessica. I was loving it. I felt like I was the king of the world.
Baseball Brawl
Then one April day after school, I had a baseball game and Elizabeth came with me, which wasn’t unusual. But in the third inning of my game I saw Jessica coming with her friends.
“What the hell is she doing here?” I said. I turned my head and acted like she wasn’t there. I didn’t want to deal with two girls at the moment; I just wanted to play my game.
But I could hear Jessica in the back saying to her friends real loud, “Stupid people don’t know how to say ‘Hi,’ because his two girls are here.” I didn’t feel embarrassed, but I was really pissed off because I didn’t want anything to break my concentration from the game.
So when I heard that, I called her over and said, “Yo that’s it, it’s over between us, I don’t want to be with you anymore.”
“Fine,” she said. “Then stay with that little b-tch.”
“Don’t talk about her like that, aight, and just leave me alone,” I said. When I finished speaking to her I was a little ticked off, so I put on my Walkman and listened to music to clear my head.
Ending It
Everyone on the team just looked at me in amazement, wondering why I just broke up with Jessica. Jessica was popular, while Elizabeth attracted less attention in school. But Jessica made me mad, and I liked Elizabeth better. Later on in the game I called Elizabeth over, making sure that Jessica heard me, and gave Elizabeth a real big kiss.
My relationship with Elizabeth didn’t last long, though. Summer was coming up and I didn’t want to have a girl during the summer because that’s when I like to be with a whole bunch of girls.
So, in June, I called Elizabeth and started to tell her that the relationship was not going any further. She said she felt the same, so we just agreed to go our separate ways.
When we got back to school after the summer, things were OK between me and Elizabeth and Jessica. Two years after my adventure, I’m still friendly with both. I’m not dating anyone in school now because my school is too small and everyone knows your business.
I’d Do It Again
When I was with Jessica and Elizabeth, I never thought how it was to be in their shoes. I was too into the fact that I was with two girls from the same school. I didn’t want to think about how they might have felt.
It helped that no one ever came up to me and told me that I was a dog, even if they were saying it under their breath. But even if someone did confront me about it, my head was so big over having two girls that I wouldn’t have cared.
For me, though, being with Elizabeth and Jessica at the same time was a good experience. It made me feel more popular and I was more well known throughout the school. I’d do it again.
I think if I wanted to, and if I played my cards right and didn’t get caught, I could be with about five or six girls at once. Just not in the same school, of course. They’d have to live in different parts of the Bronx.
But now I’m seeing a girl outside of school and we’ve been together for about a month. She’s the first girl I’ve introduced to my mother, and I actually bought her a present (I don’t usually buy girls things). We’re girlfriend and boyfriend, so I don’t plan on playing her like I did to Elizabeth and Jessica.
A Dog’s Tale
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.