I’m from Guangzhou, China, and when I had my first math class in kindergarten, I knew math was not for me. I was slow at calculating. When other kids got the answers, I was still counting on my fingers. If there was a number greater than 10, I would give up because I didn’t have enough fingers.
But people assume I’m good at math because I’m Asian. I think the Chinese do statistically better in math because it’s important in our culture. we’re expected to put in a lot of effort; it’s not biological.
Throughout elementary school I was slow at getting the answers. I sometimes pissed off my math teacher because when the whole class understood, I was still working and that held the class up. Once I got a particularly hard problem wrong after the teacher explained it. She took me out of the room and walked me into another class. She interrupted their class and wrote the problem on the board. Then she said, “What’s the answer to this problem?” I was so embarrassed when they all answered correctly at once. Before I walked out they started clapping and laughing at me.
One reason Chinese kids probably try a lot harder in school is because teachers are stricter than they are in New York. Even though what that teacher did probably seems extreme to American kids, it’s a normal thing to do in Chinese schools. They punish and humiliate students so that next time they will pay better attention. For example, teachers often make you stand until the end of class if you don’t know the answer.
Changing the Equation
In China, when you turn 6, you are interviewed and tested so the education department can place you in an elementary school. I can still remember walking into the testing room. There were multiple interviews going on; each kid was assigned to a teacher, and they were making puzzles, drawing, singing, and dancing. I met a young teacher with a pretty, smiling face and she started to talk to me. The interview was relaxing. I sang her a short English song, told her a story, drew her a picture, and said I knew how to dance but I couldn’t remember the dance steps. That made her laugh.
Then the teacher gave me 10 math problems. She told me I could skip some if I didn’t know the answers. I skipped the ones with “big” numbers: 8+6=? Even though I didn’t do that well, I guess my behavior earlier in the interview left a good impression because I was assigned to one of the best elementary schools in the district.
After that, I went to extra classes to improve my math skills. I sacrificed my free time on weekends practicing drills. I stayed after school to study. It was worth it because I got into the best middle school in the city.
Then, two years ago, I came to America. I had already learned the math that kids in my grade were learning so I always got an A+. But this had nothing to do with the fact that I was Chinese and somehow biologically predisposed to be good at math. I’d just learned it before the kids in New York did.
As soon as my classmates found out I had already learned everything, they started asking me for help. But then if I made a tiny mistake they would laugh and clap as if it was an event they should celebrate with a party. I felt bad when they did that. I asked them why they laughed. “You’re Chinese, you’re not supposed to make a mistake,” they said.
Put to the Test
Once my math teacher asked the class if anyone could solve the equation on the board and explain it to the class. I didn’t want to look like I was showing off, so I stayed quiet. When nobody volunteered, my math teacher called on me. I solved the equation correctly, and explained it to the class.
After I got back to my seat, one of my classmates asked me how I got the answer but before I could reply another student interrupted and said, “Because she’s Chinese. All Chinese are good at math.” I said politely, “I believe it has nothing to do with where you were born, so please don’t make that assumption.”
I have a friend from Indonesia who is good at basketball and spends a lot of time practicing. One day when he made a similar remark I said to him sarcastically, “I guess you’re good at basketball because you’re Indonesian, right? I’m sure it has nothing to do with your hard work.” He understood what I meant. “You’re right,” he said. “I’m sorry about what I said.”
Gradually my classmates started to get the message. Now, two years later, I still get A’s in math, but I don’t think anyone from my school would say it’s because I’m Chinese. They know I work hard and that I’m also talented in different areas like writing and drawing, two things I’m naturally good at. They know me as myself, as Kelly.
Not All Asians Get Straight A’s
I'm Chinese but I'm not gifted in math
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.