Names have been changed.
It was Cassie.
Cassie? Why on earth would she send me a friend request? I clicked on the bubble next to the “friends” icon again, absolutely sure it was a mistake. The last time I’d seen her was three years ago at junior high graduation. I never expected to hear about her after that, much less get a friend request from her on Facebook.
Cassie and I had been classmates for six years but we were never friends. In fact, during most of that time, we were bitter enemies. Cassie and her friends gave off a better-than-you attitude and treated the rest of the students as if they were less worthy. She was definitely the leader.
We’d met when I started at a new school. On the first day, I made my way to the 3rd grade line. As I took my place, I heard someone in front scoff so I turned my head in that direction. “She’s in our class?” I didn’t know who she was at the time, but it was Cassie, grimacing. I looked away and scowled, and thus began our mutual dislike for each other.
But that was nearly 10 years ago. I sat in front of my computer, cursor poised over the “accept” button. Should I? I leaned back in my chair, contemplating the pros and cons.
Bullied and Humiliated
Cassie had always cast a shadow on my experiences at school. My first year, she bossed me around and teased me. If she told me to get something for her, I would. I thought that if I was nice to her and listened to what she said, then maybe she would stop making fun of me and giving me weird looks. I was wrong.
In 4th grade, I opened the door to our classroom after lunch one day and found Cassie and her friend Sarah sitting on my desk, my diary in her hand, reading it out loud. I snatched it away. I felt humiliated.
“Calm down, it’s just a joke,” Cassie said. She rolled her eyes. “Gosh, what’s your problem?”
That’s what Cassie said to justify her mean behavior: It was a joke. I had always tried to smile when she said it, as if I got the joke, but really, I was hurt. I blamed myself for not being able to understand her humor. She joked around with her friends in that same way, threatening to read their diaries and insulting them lightheartedly.
Looking back, I wish I had asked her to stop treating me the way she did. But I hated confrontation. It was also a question of pride. If I admitted that I felt hurt, it would just show that I wasn’t tough enough to take her jokes. It didn’t occur to me then that her behavior was a form of bullying.
Afraid She Would “Get” Us
Middle school brought a whole slew of incidents. Once Cassie and her friends made a fake AIM account to harass my best friend. They sent her messages incessantly and pretended to be guys flirting with her. Another time they took our diaries out of our bags and read them. They ripped out all the pages and threw them in the garbage.
No one disputed anything Cassie said. Why? What was so scary about her? “Cassie knows how to get back at you,” one of her friends told us in a rare moment when we were all sitting in class wondering why we kept doing this to each other.
It was true. I realized we were afraid she would “get” us. She was loud, and eager to be confrontational. I didn’t know about the rest of my friends but that’s what really scared me: confrontation that could result in public humiliation. That’s what kept me from fighting back.
Then We “Got” Her
Eventually my friends and I did the next best thing. When my friend could no longer handle the late-night harassment on AIM, she told one of our teachers. Cassie and her friends quickly denied that they had done anything, but my friend printed out a copy of the online conversations. The principal suspended them all for a day.
We reacted similarly after we found the wrecked diaries. We asked one of our nicest teachers for advice, and she spent a whole class period talking about kindness and respect, trying to be as indirect as possible while still getting the point across. Cassie and her friends knew it was directed at them.
They called us tattletales, wimps, and teachers’ pets, but we still felt triumphant. The teachers had done what we had always been too afraid to do. They had confronted Cassie and her friends and put them in their place.
That wasn’t the end of it. Our little spats continued until we graduated from 8th grade. I had been accepted into a specialized high school and wouldn’t be going with the rest of my classmates. I was grateful for that. It meant I could leave all the drama of middle school behind and get a fresh start.
Forgiveness
A few days after I received Cassie’s Facebook request, I was talking to my best friend about a play she was in when she suddenly brought up Cassie.
“She’s really different now. She’s in the play too and she’s really nice and normal.”
“Oh wow, really? I guess she changed.”
“She’s not like that anymore, we don’t hate her.”
“Yeah, well, you watched her change,” I started, quick to defend myself. “I haven’t had contact with her and the last image I have of her isn’t really a pleasant one.”
“She’s really different now.”
I laughed bitterly. “I guess everything got better after I left. Maybe I was the problem and Cassie was the one who was fine all along.”
“Nah, we all just grew up. High school really changes you, I guess.”
I still couldn’t give up the resentment I had toward Cassie. She may have changed, but the only Cassie I knew was the intimidating, manipulative one.
But later, I realized the person I was resentful towards wasn’t Cassie now, but the person she used to be. The girl seeking to reconnect with me is a different Cassie. Shouldn’t people get second chances?
I eventually decided to accept her friend request. Maybe I was tired of deliberating, or recalling the same incidents over and over. Maybe I wanted to give her another chance. Maybe I’d moved on.
I knew all my resentment for her wouldn’t disappear once I pressed “accept.”
But I decided that, by accepting, I am showing her that I have moved past the petty fights we had. I am showing her that I’m no longer afraid to face her. And although I haven’t completely forgiven her for everything she’s done to me, maybe I will someday. Forgiveness may not happen with the click of a button, but it can start there.
Hated Her in High School
Why I Gave a Bully a Second Chance
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.