In New York City, at least one in four students is chronically absent from school each year. Chronically absent means missing school at least 10% of the time-about 18 days in a 180-day school year.
Chronically absent students are risking more than just their education. There are actions taken against the parents and guardians of absentees. Being a chronically absent student raises a red flag with New York City’s Administration for Children’s Services (ACS). The parent of student that misses 10 days in a row, or 20 days in four months, can be reported to ACS for educational neglect. This can land you and your parents in family court, and may end up with you being sent to foster care.
I learned these things from a 43-page report by the Youth Justice Board (YJB), From Absent to Present: Reducing Teen Chronic Absenteeism in New York City, and by interviewing two people involved in the research. The YJB is an after-school program for New York City teens that gives youth a voice in the policies affecting them. Its report goes beyond the statistics; it also gives reasons for kids skipping school and recommendations for solving the problem.
The report starts out with the costs of chronic absenteeism. It notes that, “Chronic absenteeism can result in a snowball effect.” If you miss a lot of school, the likelihood that you’ll drop out goes up, which then means the ability to make a decent living is harder. A high school dropout makes, on average, almost $10,000 less per year than a high school graduate.
There’s also a pretty strong link between cutting school and crime. Chronic absenteeism, the report says, is “an early warning sign for future delinquency.” In fact, 80% of serious juvenile offenders cut school a lot.
The Youth Justice Board tackled the question “Why are so many teens missing school?” and found that attendance issues run deeper than a general lack of motivation. The things that cause students to skip school can be categorized as push or pull factors. Push factors are the things about school that make students not want to attend, and pull factors are things outside of school that deter students from coming to school.
Examples of push factors are a school’s poor facilities, unsupportive staff, safety concerns, bullying, and the lack of educational needs being met. Pull factors include a student’s homelessness or foster care living situation, drug use, or if you are acting as the family’s primary caretaker. Gangs were categorized as both push and pull factors because gang activity can occur inside or outside of school.
What Schools Can Do
Along with the list of causes that prevent students from attending school, the Youth Justice Board also came up with a series of solutions to right these wrongs. Each recommendation highlights a different aspect of what may prevent a student from going to class. The recommendations are aimed at the city’s education department and others who work with city students. The ones that made the most sense to me were:
Recommendation: Help teens draw connections between school and their future early in their schooling.
This resonates because a lot of my friends and classmates don’t think school is that important. They do homework when it’s convenient, and their school day ends long before their last class. It gets hard to see where school will take you when every day is almost the same. But as the YJB recommends, making the connection between school and future success helps motivate students to do well in school.
Recommendation: Examine the impact of security procedures on school attendance.
This has affected me personally. In my high school, we weren’t allowed in the building if our first class was second period but we arrived during first period. Also, we weren’t allowed in the building if we were more than 20 minutes late. The doors were locked and we’d have to stand outside until 10 minutes before the next period started. Students often chose to go home instead of waiting out in the cold or rain. If I was running late, I’d come to school even later to avoid standing outside.
Recommendation: Develop clear, consistent expectations around student confidentiality.
I can especially relate to this recommendation. I’ve been shy and evasive when teachers asked me personal things. I’m not alone. YJB talked to teens and found that “many students felt uncomfortable discussing the reasons behind their absences” with school staff because they never knew if what they said would be kept secret. To develop trust, YJB says school staff should tell kids, upfront, what they can and can’t keep secret. Giving students this heads up is a good way of making students feel less betrayed and cast out.
YJB also says that schools should make sure to provide “safe, private rooms” for kids to discuss their absences with school staff. That could help students feel more comfortable explaining what’s behind their absences, especially if it’s because of a mental health issue, a family problem, or something else that might be hard to talk about publically.
Recommendation: Use “chronic absenteeism” rather than “truancy” to refer to attendance issues.
I like this idea because the term “chronically absent” doesn’t sound like accusing someone of a felony. In YJB’s report, Evan Elkin of the Vera Institute of Justice is quoted saying that the vocabulary should shift from harsh “kid-blaming” language-like “truancy”-to softer words that help to provide insight. I agree.
Other recommendations focused on having schools offer more support (like mentoring) to students, especially those who are going through some sort of transition, returning from long absences, or students who have been left back. The only recommendation I really didn’t agree with was the idea to “support parents and foster parents to ensure that they are familiar with the education system and the importance of daily school attendance.” It may be effective to focus efforts on the parents when students are younger, but as a student gets older, attending school becomes more of the student’s choice and less of their parents’ choice. This recommendation may not be as effective for older students as the other recommendations will be.
Convincing Teens
I interviewed Malik, one of the teens who worked on the report, about how YJB will get schools to take these recommendations. He said one way to implement the recommendation about getting teens to see the connection between absenteeism and future success is to have teens write a pamphlet that explains clearly what people lose when they drop out of high school.
I believe that this pamphlet should say something like: You’re going to want money when you’re older. To get money, you need a well-paying job. To get a well-paying job, you need to have gone to college. To get into college, you need to keep your grades up in high school. To keep your grades up, you have to go to school every day.
The pamphlet should just cut to the chase. High school students need to know how much is riding on their school attendance.
Find the full report at courtinnovation.org .
