Opportunity, Not Shame, Can Prevent Teen Pregnancy

NYC needs more than ads to help teens make good decisions

It takes two to tango, so how many does it take to raise a baby? A New York City public education campaign intended to prevent teen pregnancy seems to suggest it only takes one, the mother. With the goal of preventing unplanned pregnancies, the city is plastering bus stands and trains with posters meant to make teens think twice before becoming young parents, but they focus mainly on girls.
One poster reads, above a picture of a baby’s face, “Honestly Momâchances are he won’t stay with you. What happens to me?” followed by “Are you ready to raise a child by yourself? 90% of teen parents don’t marry each other.”
The campaign is a great attention grabber, but it’s been controversial from the start. Although its goal is to prevent teen pregnancy in the first place, family planning groups argue that stigmatizing and shaming teen mothers won’t accomplish that.
Excluding teen boys from the conversation is not going to bring teen pregnancy rates down either. The only poster that directly addresses young fathers has the taunting message, “Dad, you’ll be paying to support me for the next 20 years.” To me, it suggests that the only thing a teenage father cares about is how much money he has to pay to help raise his child. The ads also send the message that men walk out on their families and that parenting is the mother’s responsibility.
I talked to several teenage fathers about how they felt about the campaign. Most said that the campaign was thought-provoking, but were turned off by what they felt were misconceptions about teen dads. They, too, got the message from the ads that teen dads don’t stick around, and that they are just a paycheck.
While it’s true that teen moms are much more likely to be the primary caregiver, a lot of young fathers are involved in their children’s lives, even if they don’t stay in a relationship with the mother. In 2005, Time magazine reported on a study in which 82% of teen fathers reported having daily contact with their children, and 74% said they contributed to the child’s financial support.
There are many reasons why teens have babies. Most teen parents I know aren’t lacking knowledge about birth control; their reasons are more psychological. Some teens see having a baby as a way of cementing a relationship, hoping that having a child with their partner will increase the chances that they stay together. Some young men see having a baby as a way of leaving a legacy. And while the ad campaign tries to address these factors, the teens I talked to found its tone insulting, which makes me think they’re less likely to have an open mind about the facts it presents.
Denial also plays a big role in teens’ decisions to have unprotected sex. The teen fathers I talked to said that, in the heat of the moment, they dismissed the risk of pregnancy with the thought, “Sex feels better without a condom,” and “It won’t happen to me.” Other teens I’ve talked to think, “It’ll be hard if I/she gets pregnant, but we’ll find a way.” While the city’s ad campaign tries to get teens to think through the consequences rationally, passion is more powerful at the moment of decision.
I think many teens have babies because they don’t have a lot of other positive opportunities-especially in poor neighborhoods like mine.
Instead of focusing on the negative, it would be helpful if the city invested in school mentoring programs that could match students up with adults in the career field they’re interested in. Teenagers bound by poverty usually don’t have role models to show how college can change us, and that can discourage us from going after those opportunities. Everyone should have the chance to see what else is out there before starting a family.
So, rather than making teen parents feel bad, how about we put more money into creating actual opportunities for teens-boys and girls-so that they can see other possibilities and futures for themselves rather than becoming parents before they’re really prepared?
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.