If you saw me walking down the street you’d see just another white kid. But there’s a lot more to the story of my race than the lightness of my skin. My mother is a white, Jewish New Yorker. My father is brown and Muslim. He was born in the mountains of rural northern Pakistan. He came to America to go to college and wound up staying here and marrying my mother, though he never became a citizen. They met at a bus stop in New Jersey, got stuck in a blizzard on the way into New York, hit it off, and fell in love. I’m their only child.
My mother’s grandparents came through Ellis Island with countless other immigrants from the Ukraine. My grandmother worked in a clothing factory to support her family. My mother’s father was even put in foster care a few times, when there wasn’t enough money in the house to feed all three children. But my mother made it to and through college.
My parents come from two different races, religions, countries, classes, and cultures. Surprisingly, neither one of them has ever really experienced any resistance to their relationship from family, friends, or society at large.
Though I am mixed race, for most of my life I have lived alone with my white mother. My father is an alcoholic and he moved back to Pakistan when I was fairly young, which wasn’t easy for me or my mom. I’m still in touch with him but it was hard dealing with him growing up, and he hasn’t been a steady presence in my life.
Yet Pakistani culture is still a big part of me. My mother knows a ton about Pakistani culture and for years would only cook Pakistani food. She raised me to be aware of both sides of my heritage, and even though we don’t see my father often, I am very close with other members of my Pakistani family.
Neither religion nor culture has ever been an issue to me. The hard part for me was race, in particular the idea of being white. In middle school I was very firm about being considered Pakistani, but I never thought about whether this meant I was white or “Other.” I didn’t really explore the racial part of my identity until high school, when I became part of a much more racially diverse and socially inclusive circle of people. Was I white? Or was I a minority, even though my skin was fair?
What Am I?
My skin is light (not as light as the kids with two white parents, but still fair). I would “pass” for white anywhere in the world and I’ve never been subject to slurs.
I’ve enjoyed a lot of the privileges that come with a middle class life and are often associated with being white: a safe home in the Upper West Side (usually considered a “white” area), comfort, great schools, travel, and exposure to all sorts of culture and opportunity. Pretty much all the white people I knew had the same sorts of privileges.
However, if you looked at a picture of my dad, you’d see a dark-skinned, clearly non-European man. And my traditionally Muslim name conjures up an image of a guy in robes and a turban riding on a camel (which I did happen to do once in Pakistan), not a fair-skinned young man. At the airport I have a hard time getting my boarding pass, since my name is Muslim enough to warrant suspicion.
To make things even more confusing, it seemed that people’s perceptions of me shifted depending on what they knew about me. Most people-black, white, Hispanic, and even Pakistani-assumed I was white until I told them I was half Pakistani, and then I was a minority to them all.
In some ways, I felt more comfortable with the non-white kids. Maybe it was partly because, although my neighborhood is considered a “white” area, I actually lived in an almost totally Hispanic building.
Although very few people at my high school wanted to exclude anyone, there were definitely racial cliques. There was even a group known as “the white kids.” It wasn’t my crowd. (I had my own group of friends who weren’t in racially based cliques.) Other students of color would sometimes talk about “the white people” with me, clearly placing me in a separate group from them.
Thinking about all this I realized: I don’t want to be considered white, and for more reasons than just factual correctness.
What’s Wrong With White?
So I asked myself, “What’s wrong with being white?” For one thing, it seemed that being white gave you less credibility in certain circumstances. In my school we talked about race quite a bit. It definitely made me feel more confident and more credible to talk about race as a minority student. I could get all fired up about the way the white man had oppressed my Pakistani ancestors, or be an authority on Pakistani and Muslim culture.
I felt like my minority status also made it easier to socialize with all sorts of social groups, from the Latino kids who played handball at lunchtime to the white kids who chatted in a big circle in the park.
And maybe most importantly (to me, at least): Although I had light skin, I didn’t fit the stereotypes of white people. I wasn’t wealthy, or out of touch, or exclusive, or a hipster, or a snob. Even though I had white friends who didn’t fit these stereotypes, either, I still associated these negative traits with whiteness. So I preferred to be considered a minority student and not just another over-privileged, out-of-touch white kid from the Upper West Side.
Taking Stereotypes Too Seriously
After a while, though, I realized that no one in school actually cared about other people’s races. Respect and credibility came more from how you acted, who you hung out with, and the way you treated others, not your skin color. It was only my own perception that whiteness was bad.
I had taken the stereotypes of white people far too seriously, and in order to escape them, I’d embraced my minority identity. It had become a way for me to see myself as tougher, more credible, and more unique. I tied surviving the family struggles I had faced into my identity of being non-white.
Although I’ve never tried to pretend that I was from the hood, and I never tried to be something I wasn’t, I had been using my race to feel comfortable living a “white life” on the Upper West Side. I didn’t want people to assume that I did not understand struggle because of my light skin. Identifying as non-white solved this problem and simultaneously made me more comfortable with the privilege I had.
I’ll always be proud of my cultural heritage: Jewish and Muslim, Pakistani and American. Because of my father, I am a minority, a mixed-race American. But I’m beginning to realize that I don’t need to be a minority to prove anything to myself or others.
don’t Whitewash
For me, identity is a complicated question
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.