Saving Yearbook

I took action when my favorite class was threatened

In the first 16 years of my life, I was never an involved student. I spent my first two years of high school simply showing up on time, doing my homework, and panicking over my finals. I knew nothing about the school’s budget or administration, and I didn’t spend much time getting to know my teachers. For me, it was enough to keep an 85 average, which sometimes meant not studying for a few months, then cramming for the test the night before.
I was still accepted into the school’s Honor Society my junior year-my GPA met the requirement by literally half a point. Being accepted into this elite, among students who were so dedicated and self-disciplined, I found I wanted to be a model student too. These people knew how to manage stress while still working productively. I wanted to pride myself in getting a difficult job done too. I realized that my former coasting made me feel useless and that I’d rather measure up to the Honor Society.
As an honors student, I was required to maintain a 90 average and complete 20 hours in community service a semester. To get even more involved, I also signed up for the yearbook staff. Our school counts yearbook as a class, but a class where the students have more control than usual. As a junior, I shadowed the seniors, learned the ropes, and helped out here and there.
Cult Member
The motto of yearbook is: “What happens in yearbook stays in yearbook.”
Yearbook is, in many ways, a cult. You sign a contract promising you won’t gossip and spread confidential information. The class is run like a business. Instead of lessons and tests, the final product-the yearbook itself-determines your grade.
The editors pick a theme that accurately represents the senior class. Then you get to work, supervised by the art teacher Ms. A. Ms. A’s hands-off approach meant that the student editors were really in control of the yearbook. She tried to interfere as little as possible to encourage leadership among the students. She was informal and open with the kids and let the editors do what they wanted. We all liked working with her.
Month after month, the staff clicked away at the computers, designing spreads, and editing copy, while photographers uploaded photos, and artists illustrated. Every page, every sentence and caption, was nitpicked. Between meeting deadlines, arguing with the editor over layouts, the editor growling at you, and trying to cram as many words as possible on a page, this class got very hectic.
By the spring term, we were done. The final product was a unified yearbook that chronicled the seniors’ experiences, all the way back to freshman year, detailed with artwork and photography of the campus, the classrooms, and students.
The effort paid off when, for the second year in a row, our yearbook received a national award. On the day the plaque was delivered, the seniors passed it around the room. They took turns ogling it and caressing it lovingly.
I had designed a few pages, and helped raise funds by begging parents for money at parent-teacher conferences. It was nice to know I played a small role in winning that award. I was beginning to feel like my work was worthwhile and notable, and I looked forward to being in charge next year, my senior year.
Fight for Survival
But rumors were swirling that yearbook might be cut as a class altogether, right when it was our turn. Our principal wanted to direct more of the school’s funding toward science research, and he was hinting that he’d cut yearbook to save money. If we couldn’t recruit enough students for a full staff, the principal would surely cut yearbook.
To find out if the rumors were true, the four juniors who would be editors next year visited the principal. It was uncomfortable in the little office. The walls were empty and nothing could distract me from looking straight at the principal across his desk.
We said our hellos, and mentioned that the yearbook got an award.
Our principal folded his hands in front of him, and a smile broke out on his face. “That’s great! You have big shoes to fill next year, don’t you?”
“Yesssss,” my friend hissed, looking down at her shoes. “About that.”
There was an awkward pause, and our principal began chuckling.
“Oh, so there’s a reason you’re here.”
The four of us stared at him. He stared back, completely pokerfaced. The lights buzzed in the yellow office.
My friend broke the silence.
“We need you to promote the class or we won’t have a staff next year. We feel that you aren’t doing enough.” Part of the principal’s job was to go to all the classrooms and announce next year’s classes. He was leaving yearbook off the list. We wondered if that was because a college class that he had introduced and pushed was at the same time as yearbook.
He nodded at our cute little speech.
“I understand. I understand,” he sighed. He says this a lot but he usually doesn’t understand. “Though I think you’re all capable enough to promote it on your own. But if you want, I can tell more students about it.”
“We would appreciate that,” my friend responded coldly. We knew that students weren’t the ones to promote classes; that was the principal’s job. So we weren’t too hopeful that he would keep his word.
He didn’t. A week later, only a dozen students out of the 100 juniors in our class had requested yearbook. If more people didn’t sign up, the class would be cut.
Big Changes Afoot
In the final months of junior year, our school was undergoing major changes. In our small faculty, two veteran math teachers, the senior adviser, the swim coach, a vice principal, one of our two full-time English teachers, and both our guidance counselors had left, retired, or been laid off. Yearbook didn’t look too secure when there wasn’t even a guidance counselor to help us with college applications.
Tension over the budget was spilling into class. The entire year in calculus, my math teacher would say, “English is just common sense!”
Hours later, I had English in the basement. Mr. E said suddenly, startling some of us awake, “Calculus? Who needs calculus? English is critical thinking.”
These two insulting each other was hilarious, but it was also demoralizing. Even if our school emphasizes the sciences, humanities are just as important. In the real world you can’t just be spitting out calculations. You have to know how to express those calculations eloquently to stand out. You have to tackle technical problems in creative ways. The arts help people develop their creativity and their eloquence. Humanities and the sciences go hand in hand, and my teachers shouldn’t be separating them.
Finding all of this very irritating, I began slacking off. I was called to meet Ms. Goldstein, the teacher running the Honor Society. I was in trouble for failing a class.
I was passing calculus, and getting by in an AP English class where we wrote literary analysis essays in 20 minutes.
“You’re failing gym ?” Ms. Goldstein said, flabbergasted. “How can you fail gym ?”
Standing in her office, I responded stoically, “I’m late every day.”
Why should I get to the gym at 7 a.m. just so I can sit around in sweatpants? What difference does it make if I’m five minutes late? I have more important things to worry about! My college degree, according to my English teacher, will be worth toilet paper because of the economy. I had no guidance counselor to guide me. I was losing motivation to do anything. I began doubting the value of a well-rounded education.
Ms. Goldstein put me on probation. If I didn’t get that grade up, I’d be kicked out of the Honor Society. So now, not only did I have to save yearbook, but I had to actually wake up early every single morning.
Wins and Losses
The pressure of having won the national award sent us into overdrive by late May. Because our yearbook flyers were mysteriously disappearing, we ended up pasting them all over the bathroom: in the stalls, on the mirrors, and all over the walls.
“JUNIORS!” it exclaimed in bright red letters. “Your yearbook needs YOU!”
Now when any junior was sitting on a toilet, they’d read our desperate plea.
Keeping the class at this point seemed unlikely. The faculty was being sliced practically in half, students were getting no college advice, and budget cuts threatened the humanities department.
But we succeeded. By the end of our flyer campaign, over 30 people had signed up for yearbook, enough for two staffs. About five students signed up for the principal’s college program. We four juniors sat back, relieved.
Meeting the principal again in his office, he was perplexed about the unpopularity of his college classes. “I was so sure they’d like it!”
When we reported that almost 40 people signed up for the yearbook class, he added, “I know! And you were worried .”
I passed gym, which was painful. (I had to run laps in make-up classes until I was ready to faint.) Enough people wanted yearbook, and so it would remain. Things seemed suspiciously OK.
In the last week of school, we helped Ms. A clean out her closet. We’d had yearbook in her art classroom, and we were happy we’d pulled it off with her help.
The room was a complete mess. Years and years worth of junk was strewn about-paintings of students, sketches, markers rolling around on the floor, broken guitars, broken amps, dusty art books, and a lab skeleton named Lucy. This was a collection of the artwork our students, both present and graduated, had made since the school first opened. The junk piled up to the ceiling so you couldn’t even see across the room.
“I have an announcement,” Ms. A suddenly said.
We sat around her in the sea of crap. She twiddled her thumbs.
“I won’t be your yearbook adviser next year.”
We gasped: ” Why ?”
“Because…I’m not coming back next year.” There was another uncomfortable pause, and then: “There will be no art.”
Politics
The entire art department was cut to save money. No creative expression, getting splattered in paint, or funny drawings. Instead of a balanced learning, we would be drilled with science, math, and then more science. And my teacher was no longer my teacher, just a person without a job. I had never been affected so directly by budget cuts.
The principal had a vision of a science research school, so over the years, the humanities department has shrunk. In a science school, art just isn’t a priority, and the school can’t afford it.
I wondered if Ms. A was also let go for annoying the principal so often.
“It’s all very political,” I murmured.
“Yes. It is very political,” said Ms. A.
We saved yearbook, but lost art. I am the new production editor, and I have to continue holding onto the yearbook class. It’s the only elective involving art that our principal kept, and it stayed because of our heavy promotion.
I’ve learned that making an effort can affect school policy. Students, teachers, and the principal are all affected by budget cuts and conflicting agendas. We needed yearbook, and the principal needed to save money. The popularity of the class, thanks to the students who signed up, made it a priority to keep.
I was up against the politics of staffing and the budget my junior year, but was still able to accomplish my goal. Knowing this, I can play an even greater role this year as a senior. It was discouraging to see how money drives so many decisions, but winning a victory and saving the yearbook class was exciting.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.