Occupy the Classroom

My Spanish teacher opens our eyes to the world

My Spanish class is a place of learning and worship. Bright posters of revolutionaries like Che Guevara and artists like the Mexican painter Frida Kahlo decorate the walls, and the colorful flags of every Latin American country are taped to the ceiling. Beautiful paintings by famous artists such as Francisco de Goya and Salvador Dal’ are taped to the bottom of the chalkboard, while students’ awkward attempts at replicating the works of Pablo Picasso hang on the next wall.
This classroom isn’t just a place where we learn a language-we get familiar with a whole world many of us had never imagined before. Our teacher, Ms. P., wants us to appreciate all of the influences that have created present-day Latin America, from art and literature to politics and race.
Ms. P. is writing our lesson on the board. I take my seat next to my imitation of Picasso’s “Portrait of Jaime Sabartes,” which I did several months ago, and take out my book. The class has begun.
Banned Books?
“Buenas tardes, everyone,” says Ms. P, telling the class to come together for a conversation. “Have any of you heard about the law that’s been passed in Arizona?” She looks around the room. There are a couple of murmurs, and Ms. P. takes this as a sign to continue.
“Well, in case you didn’t know, this law is banning certain books that teach about Hispanic culture from being used in classrooms.” She points to the back of the room.
“That book, Rethinking Columbus , is one of the books on the list.” Rethinking Columbus is a book that exposes the brutality of European colonization, and the toll it took on the indigenous inhabitants of the Americas.
“I am letting you all know so that maybe you can take action,” she said. “Write letters; tell your friends and family about this. These books are essential in teaching others about Hispanic culture.”
I’m stunned. Why would politicians pass a law that bans these books from being used to teach students? I wonder if other teachers know about this law, and if so, are they taking a stand like Ms. P?
Ms. P.’s lecture inspired me to learn more. I did some further research and found out that the law bans classes devoted to learning about particular ethnic groups, like Mexican-American studies or African-American studies, as well as the use in classrooms of certain books that some conservative politicians claim cause racial division.
Sponsors of the law said that it would prevent one race’s perspective from being privileged over others. But as a result the state has banned some books that awaken cultural awareness in students. The law also bans teachers from using books that are perceived as being too critical of the United States.
I thought that this was completely preposterous. How can studying about one’s culture cause racial division? I was grateful that Ms. P. took the time to tell us about this.
Learning to Stand Up
I’ve never had a teacher like Ms. P.: someone who stands up to what she feels is unjust-not just in her own community, but around the world. No one else in my school seems to discuss world events in the classroom. I have always admired people who fight for what they believe in and refuse to conform to what society expects of them.
I felt personally connected to what she talked about. For instance, whenever she spoke about social and economic issues in Latin America I thought of my homeland, Mexico, and the poverty many of my people are living in while I’m in the land of opportunity. Ms. P. made me reflect on those my family left behind and people who struggle in other parts of the world.
For Ms. P, becoming a teacher was a big step in becoming a human rights activist. She was raised in Honduras in a well-off, very political family that believed in helping people.
Ms. P. was always reading-she claims she was a teacher’s pet-and because of her family she was exposed to political books pretty quickly. When she was a teenager she read a Honduran novel called Green Prison about the exploitation of plantation workers by U.S. banana companies. It made a big impression on her.
She moved with her family to New York when she was 15, and she describes their situation here as working class. It was during this time that she started to get involved with the Honduran community in New York. As a teenager she volunteered at the Honduran consulate. This inspired her to stand up for immigrant rights, because she saw the suffering and the struggle many face when coming to the United States.
Advocate for Her Culture
But while attending a bilingual school, Morris High School in the South Bronx, she noticed that most of the teachers who were teaching her in Spanish were not Hispanic and spoke only the Castilian Spanish used in Spain. She describes this as her first culture shock in the United States because she felt that the education system needed a stronger Hispanic presence. If her teachers could not speak the Spanish she grew up with, how could they hope to understand her culture?
Ms. P. was disappointed that her classrooms did not reflect Hispanic culture. For Ms. P, Castilian Spanish represented the oppression that the Spanish colonists inflicted on Latin Americans before independence. The revolutionaries in Spanish language literature all spoke the Spanish that most Latin Americans speak today.
Ms. P. later attended Baruch College, where she took literature courses in Spanish. But again, most of her professors were not Hispanic. Ms. P. challenged why this was so, and as a result she says she got into arguments with some of her professors for questioning what it meant to be Latino or Hispanic in the United States.
One professor began to pay attention to her ideas and awakened her to the possibility of becoming a teacher as a way of being an advocate for her culture. He made her realize that she could make a living doing something she cared deeply about: teaching people about the culture she loved and knew so well.
Lectures on Injustice
Today, Ms. P. sees activism as part of her mission as a teacher. “Advocacy and human rights, as well as political activism, have been a big part of my life. Being an activist makes you a more complete person: it gives you a lot of self-confidence and security because you realize that you can influence events and policies,” she said.
One event that changed her life and advanced her political convictions was the military coup that occurred in Honduras on June 29, 2008, when President Jose Manuel Zelaya was removed from office by the country’s own military. Those behind the coup said they objected to Zelaya’s proposed changes to the country’s constitution, which might have allowed him to stay in power beyond his legal term.
But many Hondurans, including Ms. P., felt that removing a democratically elected president from office by force, instead of letting voters decide, was an attack on the Honduran people. Since the coup, Ms. P. has done a lot of campaigning to raise awareness in the United States about what she describes as a “vicious” attack on the political stability of her country.
If it weren’t for Ms. P., I wouldn’t know much about politics in Latin America because my family doesn’t discuss politics. Now, I’m discovering ways to advocate for and against laws and political positions in my own country. Ms. P. encourages me to take a stand against things I feel are unfair. I have learned so much thanks to Ms. P.’s voice continually lecturing me about injustice.
The Art of Argument
While she does encourage us to think more deeply about the world, Ms. P.’s lectures don’t always inspire me. When students express doubts about what she preaches or have opinions different from her own, Ms. P. isn’t very tolerant. For example, I did a research project and presentation on Costa Rica. Ms. P said that the country was too influenced by the United States and basically a tourist spot and retirement home for Americans wanting to settle down somewhere peaceful.
Despite Ms. P.’s opinions, I discovered through my research some admirable things about Costa Rica. For instance, I was intrigued that Costa Rica doesn’t have an army because they want to show the world that they are a peaceful country. I also found it interesting that they are extremely involved in preserving their environment, and that it is, in fact, one of the most eco-friendly countries in Latin America.
After I presented my paper in front of the class, I told Ms. P that Costa Rica actually sounded pretty good to me. She asked me why, going on again about what was wrong with the country. The discussion became very heated and finally I just gave up. There was no winning if you disagreed with Ms. P, and I was getting tired of repeating myself.
Looking back at this incident, I’ve realized that even though Ms. P. rebutted my opinion, it put me on the spot to defend my point of view. I think that gave me a taste of what it’s like to have to build a strong argument, and I think with more practice I could develop better debating and critical thinking skills.
More Current Events, Please
Students are too often ignorant of the rest of the world. Classes generally teach students about the United States economy and the problems that the United States has faced; kids have a vague sense of other countries but they don’t delve too deep. Developing countries, especially, are often overlooked. But Ms. P tries to keep her students aware of what’s happening-both in the United States and around the world.
Students need more educators like Ms. P. who are ready and willing to discuss such sensitive topics. Ignorance can have negative effects on our ability to contribute to society. How can we vote at 18 when we don’t even understand the news? How can we prepare to be effective doctors, lawyers, and politicians when we aren’t given the opportunity to study current events?
Schools need teachers that will challenge a student’s outlook, helping them develop their opinions so that they can present them to the world with confidence. Talking to students in a serious way about politics and making them aware of the larger world are important.
Ms. P’s outspokenness and persistence are admirable. She is a woman who thinks for herself, fights for what she believes in, and sticks up for the underdog. It is important for everyone, not just teachers, to do all of these things. I will certainly try my best to carry Ms. P.’s example into my future because I want to see the world change for the better.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.