Every year, thousands of immigrants arrive in the United States seeking the chance to work, study, and often, to stay. But the U.S. can’t allow every person who wants to immigrate here to do so. The government has to try and ensure that the people entering the country aren’t dangerous, and that they won’t overburden public systems like schools, hospitals, courts, jails, and social services.
That’s why there are laws restricting who can come to the U.S., and for what reasons. Visas for tourists, workers, and students, as well as for refugees and victims of violent crimes, offer immigrants permission to be in the United States for a period of months or years. Immigrants can also apply for a Permanent Residency Card, or “green card,” which allows someone the right to live and work here and to receive financial aid for college and certain government benefits. Obtaining permanent residency can also be a step to becoming a citizen.
Those are some of the legal paths to immigration. But about 12 million people living in the United States are here illegally-meaning they did not enter the country with government permission to begin with, or they stayed longer than their visa allowed. They are also called undocumented immigrants. These people still have the right to fair treatment under the law. They also have the right to many services, including the right to attend school.
Many undocumented immigrants have strong ties to this country, including family members who are U.S. citizens. Some undocumented immigrants were children when they came to the U.S. and had no say about it. Their situation can be especially tricky since they may only know the United States and feel “American,” yet are denied access to opportunities like financial aid for college and legal employment.
The economic recession has heated up the debate over immigration. Some people believe unemployment could be reduced by deporting more undocumented immigrants, tightening border security to prevent them from entering the U.S., and by increasing penalties on employers who knowingly hire undocumented workers.
When President Barack Obama took office in 2009, he promised a comprehensive immigration reform bill within a year to tighten up the system. Comprehensive reform was supposed to mean a big overhaul of the system. However, Republicans and Democrats in Congress disagreed about how to deal with the millions of undocumented immigrants who already live here, so no bill was passed. Last year, the Senate also failed to pass what’s known as the DREAM Act, which would have provided a way for those who immigrated as children to become legal residents and apply for U.S. citizenship.
Without comprehensive reform from the federal government, many states have been enacting their own laws-some meant to protect immigrants, some meant to penalize and restrict them. Illinois and California passed their own versions of the DREAM Act to provide more financial aid opportunities to undocumented college students.
Meanwhile, Arizona and Alabama cracked down on undocumented immigrants. Both allow local law enforcement to check peoples’ immigration status if they are pulled over or detained by the police. According to The Associated Press, employers in Alabama can be prosecuted for hiring undocumented workers, and schools are now required to check the immigration status of new students (though state officials have told parents that names will not be released to the police and students won’t be denied an education because of their status).
Most people agree that immigration reform is necessary. The question is how to make the laws fair and uphold the rights of all people in the United States-immigrants and citizens alike.
Making U.S. Immigration Work
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.