In the News: Cuts To Childcare

Kelly, one of Represent’s teen writers, recently wrote about how as a 7th grader she regularly cared for three younger siblings while her mother worked. One day, Kelly’s little brother went missing while she was supposed to be babysitting. The boy was found unharmed by the police on the roof, but Kelly and her siblings were placed in foster care.
“Sometimes I blame myself-if I did what my mother told me, none of this would be happening and we’d all be together in my mom’s house,” Kelly wrote.
Kelly’s experience shows a dilemma faced by thousands of parents who must choose between work and paying for childcare. Because of the recession, states and counties don’t have enough money for all their programs. Many are freezing or cutting childcare subsidies (payments) for low-income families. But it’s not a smart way to save money, say child welfare advocates, because it threatens kids’ well-being and forces families onto welfare rolls.
In February, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg proposed cutting childcare subsidies for nearly 17,000 poor families. Other cities and many states have taken similar actions. Last year, Washington State cut $51 million from its welfare-to-work program, which provides job training and childcare subsidies for working parents. Arizona, Michigan, North Carolina, and other states have also cut the budgets of childcare subsidy programs or made it harder for people to get the subsidies.
Under the budget bill released by the Republican-controlled House of Representatives in February, the federal Head Start program would also face big cuts-nearly 25%-depriving childcare and early childhood education opportunities to families that rely on it.
Foster care prevention service programs across the country also face big reductions. Families that are not receiving enough help paying for childcare may be forced to make terrible choices. Some may resort to keeping older kids out of school to care for younger siblings or ask other unqualified people to babysit, endangering children and putting them at risk of going into foster care.
And for many other families, losing childcare subsidies and programs like Head Start sometimes means parents can no longer afford to work, turning instead to welfare to make ends meet.
As long as politicians believe that they have to keep taxes on rich people low, budget cuts are unavoidable. But this is not the place to scrimp. It is far more expensive and destructive to put children in foster care than it is to help families pay for childcare.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.