When I was a kid, I thought holy water was magic and came from a magic place. It wasn’t until after I left Catholic school at age 11 that I found out it was tap water blessed by the priest. Looking back at elementary school, I realize I was in awe of a lot of things. Like the holy water, I thought the popular girls among my classmates were exclusive and regal.
I went to Catholic school for seven years, from kindergarten through 6th grade. My parents were hardworking people, first-generation immigrants from China who owned and ran a business in Brooklyn. Mom always told me she wanted me to have the “enhanced” education only a private school would provide, and that she never had. She and my dad worked strenuously to afford my tuition, which was five grand a year.
I never questioned the ideas that were presented to me in elementary school. I was told that by being humble I would enter heaven, so I became what I thought was “humble”-actually, I was timid and submissive. When I was told that the sacrament of Communion was a “cookie” that good, baptized kids could receive, I felt envious of my peers who were baptized and could therefore go up to the altar to receive the sacrament.
I also didn’t question the social hierarchy of the school, at least for several years.
Power of the Popular
I started out thinking that I blended in well with my peers. But as time passed, I started to notice the school’s lack of diversity. It wasn’t just that we all wore uniforms: Out of the entire student body, I think there were about 15 of us Asian-Americans, and there were almost no new faces of any color. Year after year I saw the same people. I suppose because it was such a small, tightly-knit group, it was easy for the most popular kids to inflate their egos and for the rest of us to buy into it.
During lunch and homeroom, I would catch floating bits of conversation from classmates talking about the “cool girls.” The girls they were talking about were predominantly upper middle-class Caucasian kids, and most of them flaunted glossy, chocolate-colored hair and faux diamonds on their fake nails. It was clear that their parents were wealthy, since by 5th grade they already had North Face jackets, book bags, and their own cell phones.
I don’t remember thinking highly of these girls until I reached 6th grade, when the time came to construct my social life with a careful selection of “chill peeps” to associate with. I felt a dark sense of admiration for the girls who seemed to have everything: hot boyfriends, nerdy people to let them copy homework and the cutest feathery pens ever.
I soon found that if you wanted to get to know them, like I did, these girls could subtly control you. They had a mysterious power that made you want to win their approval. A condescending glance here, a critical comment there, all added up to almost telepathic nudges to the “cool side.” When they even spoke to poor little me, it was like bait to a fish. They’d utter a few sentences, then get distracted and leave me hanging.
Looking for Approval
For me, 6th grade was all about ass-kissing. I can clearly remember leaning on a wall in the hallway just after Language Arts class, waiting for Queen Nicole to grace me with her presence since she had hinted I should hang back for her. Exiting the classroom, Nicole spotted me and strolled over. I hastily patted down my fluffy black hair, flashed an eye-blinding grin, and gushed, “Hey, Nicole. How are you?”
“I’m OK. You got a piece of Winterfresh?” she said, putting her 90 pounds of body weight on her right leg. She said it in a long, lazy drawl.
“Oh, yeah, right here,” I said earnestly, quickly procuring it from my cardigan pocket.
Her white acrylic nail tips pinched my skin as she took it from my palm. “You’re the best,” she said daintily, popping the piece of gum into her mouth.
I detected a hint of insincerity in her tone, but disregarded it. For the rest of the day I felt fulfilled from the simple acknowledgement she had given me. A smile from the queen was enough to make me feel important.
If you’d asked me why I needed Nicole’s approval, I don’t think I could have explained it. I suppose I just wanted acknowledgement for something-for my artistic skills, or my singing, or my sense of humor, or my choice of reading. But none of those characteristics mattered to the orange-tinted girls. All their concerns seemed to revolve around gossip, crushes on boys, Sephora mascara, and Seventeen magazine.
Preparing for the Worst
One autumn night, as my mom was collecting the dirty dishes after dinner, she said absentmindedly, “You’re transferring to a public school, honey. Next year you’ll be switching.”
It was my mother’s habit to tell me important things at the most inappropriate times or the very last minute. But this one took the cake. “Deem gai ah?” (“Why?”) I inquired bewilderedly in Cantonese. I felt a sensation of unease in my ribcage.
“The tuition is too expensive, and besides, your personality’s changing from being in that school.” She said the last few words crisply and dropped dishes into the scum-filled sink.
I didn’t flip out. I didn’t collapse or release waves of tears. It’s futile to fight against my mother. Instead, I just resigned myself and took it as an excuse to catch all the phone numbers of the queen bees and cute guys.
When they heard that I was leaving the school, a couple of students seemed genuinely sad and wished me well. Nicole, Her Majesty, simply tilted her head, drawled, “Really? Good luck!” and hugged me. (Her idea of a hug was to grasp my shoulders daintily with her manicured nails, bump our cheeks together with puckered lips, and leave an airy space in between us.)
“Hey Crystal. Did you know that people get beat up in public school?” one of my classmates, James, whispered to me through his braces.
My eyes widened and I gaped at him. “What do you mean?”
“The schools are really violent and most of the teachers just don’t care much about the students,” he said. He looked grave. James may not have been the brightest guy in class, but comparing my rap sheet with his, I was pretty sure he was more street smart than I was. I took his words into consideration and prepared for the worst.
First Day Jitters
The summer months went by speedily and in September I entered a completely different environment. My new school was quite run-down, and instead of gleaming wood and slate, the building looked like it was made out of recycled plaster and dried up Play-Doh.
Making things more awkward, I was late on the first day and had to ask a lady in the main office where to find my homeroom. Then I had to hike up several flights of stairs to room 505. Going to class sweaty was totally not ideal for the first day at a new school.
I stood outside of room 505 and peered in through the glass panel at a full class. “Please don’t stare at me. Please don’t stare at me,” I prayed silently. It took me roughly half a minute to muster the courage to turn the doorknob.
I walked inside and 30 pairs of eyes of a variety of shades began scrutinizing my every move.
“Hi, Miss, I’m the new student,” I said. The words ran off my tongue like water. I found myself rubbing the sides of my sneakers together.
She nodded and gestured toward an empty seat next to the window. I made my way to it, saying “Excuse me” and “Sorry” all the way.
A Welcome Change
During the first weeks of school, James’ stupid words kept echoing in my head. I acted aggressive toward my peers because I didn’t know where they came from or whether they were going to steal my wallet.
But when Stewart, the class clown, accused me of having “a b-tchy white girl’s attitude,” I was stunned into muteness. I never expected or intended to be placed in that pile. Five months ago, I would have felt complimented and would have planted a wet kiss on Stewart’s face for the statement. Now, I realized I didn’t want to be a b-tchy white girl. My behavior and obsessions at Catholic school had been misguided.
Already, I was beginning to see that the world was bigger than the kingdom of the queen bees. I was learning a lot. I’d never known that there were pale-complexioned Hispanics like Stewart, for example, or secular Jews like David. There was also an entire clique of Asian girls. (I could have latched onto them, but I didn’t feel I matched their Hello Kitty cutesyness.)
Warming up to the new school took a couple of months, but it turned out to be the most welcome change I could have had. It was liberation from a musty regime that I’d had to follow for the last seven years of my life. I wasn’t obligated to pledge allegiance to the American flag, nor did I have to recite the Lord’s Prayer. I adored wearing denim every day of the week.
And gradually, my peers helped me break out of that lost-at-sea state. I started speaking to Zachary, a Jamaican boy; to Russian Alexei; and to Nataly, half-Peruvian and half-Chinese. I learned the joys of anime, illicit card playing, and being foul-mouthed. I joyfully taught Victor, Ingmar, and Jason how to play Chinese Poker.
A Place for Me
In my Catholic school, there were only about 400 students and everybody knew everyone. Or more to the point, they thought they did. Everyone was so familiar with the usual faces that no one would ever bother to say, “Hey, I see you all the time in literature class but I never really chatted with you. I’m Crystal. Tell me about yourself.”
I also felt like no one at my small elementary school cared about the things that mattered most to me: music, art, and writing. I had no outlet for my creative interests. But after moving to public school, I brought a roomful of people to tears by serenading them. Later, I’m proud to say, I became editor-in-chief of my high school literary magazine.
I feel like I have not yet fully discovered myself, but I’m basking in the liberty of figuring out who and what I am. More important, I am joyous that I have a large group of friends to help me define myself-perverse, intelligent, original, freaky, friendly, and strange friends.
My public school classmates occupy a special place in my mind because they’vetaught me that the world has a place for someone like me. I am thankful and indebted to them.
Escape From Private School
I learned there's more to life than serving queen bees
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.