“You don’t have enough credits to graduate,” the guidance counselor told Cristhians Gonzalez a couple of years ago when she’d fallen behind in school. (See her story on page 4.) Cristhians wanted to know if she could catch up, maybe repeat the classes she’d failed and eventually finish high school. Her guidance counselor seemed to think it was impossible, and encouraged Cristhians to drop out. Why would a guidance counselor do that?
“It is a push out,” says Rebecca Shore, a lawyer for a non-profit organization called Advocates for Children of New York (AFC). A “push out” is a case where a student is “encouraged or forced to leave school for reasons that are against the law,” according to AFC.
The way the New York City school system is set up, schools with bad test scores, or too many failing or “over-age” students (students like Cristhians who may take five, six, or seven years to graduate), are likely to be shut down.
“If a student is not doing well on all of the standardized testing and it doesn’t look like the student is going to graduate [on time], all of that goes to the school’s rating. So the school has a somewhat frightening incentive to push these students out,” Shore told us back when we first reported on push outs in 2009.
In 2002, AFC began receiving complaints that many schools were trying to push out some students in an attempt to boost test scores and graduation rates. When AFC lawyers investigated, they discovered that it was usually the kids needing the most support who were given the cold shoulder: immigrant students who were still struggling to learn a new language, students with learning disabilities or special education needs, and those with behavior problems.
Of course, schools cannot legally kick kids out for bad grades alone. So, several high schools found creative ways to get the “bad” students off their rosters. Guidance counselors and principals pressured struggling students to transfer to one of the city’s “second chance” or “alternative” schools, or to drop out altogether. Another tactic was to tell students that they were “too old” to be in high school, even though state law allows students up to 21 years old to attend high school.
In 2003, AFC filed several lawsuits on behalf of all the students who were pushed out. Eventually, the city’s Department of Education (DoE) settled each lawsuit out of court. It admitted no wrongdoing, but the schools named in the lawsuits agreed to let the excluded students return to school. A DoE spokesperson added that all students are given information packets that explain their rights.
Unfortunately, even after the school chancellor promised to end the practice of forcing kids out, Shore says her organization is still receiving complaints from students who have been pushed out. And Shore noted that for every kid who realizes they’re being treated unfairly and knows to call AFC, there are probably many more who never speak up.
If you feel you’re being illegally pushed out of school, there are several things you can do to fight it:
¥ First, ask for help: If you are having trouble in school with homework or tests, talk to your teachers and principal about getting help. You may have the right to free tutoring, counseling, or other services.
¥ Know your rights: In New York, students are allowed to attend high school until they turn 21.
¥ Find an advocate: Contact Advocates for Children (advocatesforchildren.org or 866-427-6033) to ask for help.
¥ Fight back: Tell your guidance counselor, principal, or other school administrator that you want to stay in school and have a right to do so. If they don’t listen, call 311 or the DoE’s office of enrollment and tell them what’s going on.
A version of this story first appeared in the Nov. 2009 issue of YCteen (formerly New Youth Connections). Rumonat Akinlolu contributed to the reporting.
Don’t Get Pushed Out!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.