In the Census We (Should) Trust

We’ve learned a lot covering the 2010 Census. One important thing is this: By law, the Census Bureau is not allowed to share the information it gathers with any other part of government.
However, this law won’t mean much to you if you don’t take your government’s word for it.
“My father miscounts us on purpose,” said one foreign-born New York high school student who didn’t want to be named. “They say that they won’t share the information with other people, but who can trust them? The government is a chunk of people who will work for their own benefit.”
Whether it’s because they’re not documented, because their houses are illegally overcrowded, or just because they don’t like the idea of sharing personal information, some people will either ignore this year’s census or provide inaccurate details on their form because they don’t trust the government. Where does this distrust come from?
Unconvinced
In the case of foreign-born residents, some of them may come from parts of the world where their governments are corrupt or deceitful, and the idea of accepting the government at its word is a strange concept to them. Even though they’re living in the U.S. now, they may carry bad experiences from their home countries that make any government’s attempt to gather information feel like a threat.
“If I list everyone that lives in the apartment, we will go through a lot of questioning,” said the foreign-born father of another anonymous New York teen, whose family’s landlord doesn’t know how many people share their small apartment.
This teen’s father was not convinced he should count his whole family even after hearing about the additional government funding that his community will receive if more people are counted. As a third immigrant teen put it, “Some families can’t risk their hopes of a better future and opportunities for their kids for something like the census.”
While other countries’ shadowy governments are partly to blame for this attitude, Americans’ lack of confidence also comes from the current environment right here at home. After Sept. 11 the federal government passed the Patriot Act, which we associate with increased government surveillance of people’s private lives. Since the response to Sept. 11 has also involved tighter border controls, immigrants may feel especially paranoid. And news stories about practices like wiretapping, for example, make people around the U.S.-American-born and otherwise-less willing to provide the government with any information about their living conditions.
“I’m scared to give my family’s information to the government because you never know what they’ll do with it,” said one teen whose family has long lived in the U.S. “They may tell us one thing to get the info, but use it in another way that we may not have agreed to.”
The Power of Information
Of course, some of this distrust isn’t just about the government. Information is a powerful tool that can be used to accomplish many aims, and in the age of phishing and other forms of Internet fraud, Americans are more aware of this than ever. Worried that their personal information will fall into the wrong hands, many people are wary of any questionnaire.
“In 2010 we have a heightened consciousness about identity theft,” said Stacey Cumberbatch, New York City Census Coordinator.
If you’re feeling distrustful, it’s probably hard to convince you that your information is safe with the Census Bureau. But there are a few things we should keep in mind. The main one is this: The census form doesn’t actually ask you for much information. It does not ask you for your Social Security number or your immigration status. It also doesn’t ask you how big your apartment is, and with 300 million people in the country it’s hard to imagine the effort it would take even to figure out which homes are illegally overcrowded.
Finally, we have never heard of anyone suffering negative consequences because they filled out their census form. While that doesn’t prove it’s never happened, it means you can probably rest easy.
It’s not too late to participate in the 2010 Census. If your family has yet to fill out the census, census workers from your local community will soon be knocking on your door. Make sure your parent or guardian knows that opening the door means using the power of information to your advantage.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.