In Dire Need

In Dire Need

We should mend the holes in our safety net

What happens if a circus performer falls from a trapeze? If she’s lucky, the circus has provided a safety net and it catches her.
What if you lose your job, savings, and home? If you’re lucky, you can take advantage of the social safety net, which will catch you.
Or will it?
The “social safety net” is a term for government programs that benefit the poor, the unemployed, and anyone who might struggle to afford basic necessities like food, clothing, shelter, and medical treatment. Most people agree that as a society, we have the duty to help anyone in dire need. That’s why we have emergency services, such as the fire department and ambulances, and that’s why our taxes also pay for services like food stamps and Medicaid.
Safety net programs are well-intentioned, but much like a regular net, they have holes. Some of these holes are identified in “Battered by the Storm: How the Safety Net Is Failing Americans and How to Fix It,” a 2009 report published by the Institute for Policy Studies.
This report’s authors found that some government assistance programs have eligibility requirements that make it difficult for people to get help they really need. Other programs offer too little assistance to meet the needs of participants. The report also suggested that safety net programs can and should do more to pull people out of poverty permanently.
Holes in the Net
To show how the safety net fails people, the report used several case studies. For example, it described how a woman called Jan, who worked as a registered nurse in Cleveland, Ohio, for 30 years, slipped into poverty after having three strokes. Jan’s health insurance company wouldn’t pay her medical bills because they claimed she had a “pre-existing condition,” or a health problem that disqualified her from receiving insurance benefits. (The government’s new health care bill will soon make it illegal for insurance companies to drop paying customers like this.)
Paralyzed on the left side of her body, Jan couldn’t keep working. But the Social Security Administration, which gives disabled people cash assistance, denied her benefits for eight months. Even after she received them, she was told she didn’t qualify for Medicaid, which is government-sponsored health care for low-income people. Later, Jan needed surgery that cost her $30,000; she’s now jobless, uninsured, and losing her house because she can no longer afford to pay for it.
The social safety net failed Jan, as it has failed many Americans. An effective safety net would help people keep some kind of home, but in a given year, about 3.5 million people (1.3 million of them children) experience homelessness in America, according to the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty.
Begging and Waiting
I feel fortunate that safety net programs have helped my family. My parents are working-class immigrants, so they don’t have family here to fall back on the way that many middle- and upper-income, non-immigrant adults would.
Yet to me it seems there’s an unwritten requirement for receiving any type of assistance: Beg and beg for help until you’re approved. Like Jan spent eight months waiting for Social Security, my parents spent eight months trying to get food stamps. The program only gives us $150 a month to feed four people, but “It’s something,” said my stepmother.
I don’t think people should have to beg for months to get such basic help. Some people argue for making it as difficult as possible to get assistance; they usually accuse those who benefit from safety net programs of laziness. I do think any formula we use to distribute assistance should prevent lazy people from taking advantage of these programs and giving them a bad name. But critics should also look at the federal budget: The government spends only about 11% of tax dollars on safety net programs. That’s a lot less than the 21% it spends on war and security, for example.
Many people who haven’t had to depend on government assistance don’t understand how easily people can lose their jobs, homes, and hard-earned savings. At their best, safety net programs let people live somewhat normal lives without going hungry, until they get back on their feet.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.