Rules of the House?

What you can do when foster parents go too far

“You have to go to church. You haven’t praised all week,” said my new foster mother.
“UmâI was never raised with a religion. I don’t go to church.”
“Well then, you can’t live in this house.” BOOM-this was a shot to my stomach.
“My second week in foster care and I’m already getting kicked out of the home,” I thought. “Now I have no one.”
Even though I didn’t know any of the rules of the system at the time, I did know that forcing a religion upon anyone was unethical. It made me angry that someone I’d just met would throw me out of her home simply because of differing beliefs.
I immediately ran upstairs to call my lawyer. She told me that she would take care of it. But I was very apprehensive. I didn’t want any tension in the house because I’d “told on” my foster mother. Sure enough, my foster mother came to me the next day and angrily told me that I was trying to get her in trouble.
“You know I was playing,” she angrily exclaimed in my bedroom doorway.
“I don’t know you yet. I just moved here. How do you expect me to know you were playing?” I forcefully said. It felt very uncomfortable.
Luckily, my biological mother went to my caseworker to advocate for me, and the problems were resolved. But sometimes you have to speak up for yourself.
A Stranger’s House
When you live in a foster home, conflicts are bound to arise over rules of the house and general differences in lifestyle. After all, you are living-at least at first-in a stranger’s house. So how do you know when a foster parent’s rules or ways of doings things are going too far? After talking to several other teens in care, I’ve realized how common these kinds of problems are, and how much confusion there is about our rights.
Cody, who’s 14, thinks his foster mother takes money meant for him and spends it on herself, because when he asks her for the rest of his money, she says she’ll give it to him once her husband goes back to work. Cody suspects she’s using his money without permission and writing herself an I.O.U. But she didn’t ask if that was OK with Cody.
“I find this situation absurd,” Cody says. Over a span of eight months Cody only received $100. He has to go to a conference to find out how much money he was really supposed to receive.
This is a common complaint of children in foster care, that they don’t receive the money they are by law entitled to, like allowances and stipends for things like basic clothing needs and independent living.
Out in the Cold
When Kimberly was 17, she had a baby and was struggling to provide for herself. She says her foster mother was cheating her out of money that she was supposed to receive.
“She used to give me $100 a month for me and my son and that was supposed to cover everything,” Kimberly says. “She was getting paid all this money and this was all she was giving me.”
She said it took four months of complaining for the system to finally do something about it.
“They told her to give me $400 a month. For everything.” The agency also made her foster mother give her an apartment key-but only after Kimberly had been locked out in the cold with her son for 3½ hours.
What the Law Says
According to staff attorney Kimberly Forte of the Legal Aid Society, which represents children in foster care, New York State regulations don’t address specifics like having a key to the house. However, Ms. Forte would argue that not having access to the home for hours is a safety issue.
On the question of religion, lawyer Jennifer Baum from the Legal Aid Society says, “No foster child can be forced into changing their religion. That goes against the United States Constitution.”
Jarel Melendez, a 23-year-old youth advocate who works at Lawyers for Children in New York, says safety and finances are common sources of conflict between foster teens and foster parents, and children are entitled to a lot that they’re not aware of. Melendez was once in foster care, so he knows firsthand.
Melendez says his foster mother didn’t allow him in the house until after 8:30 p.m., and she only gave him $2.25 a week for allowance
“She always told me the income she got from the agency was for her, not for me,” says Melendez. This, of course, is not accurate. A portion of that money is to go to the foster youth.
I decided to look up the regulations myself. Rules vary in different states and even in different foster care systems. But I found out that every child in New York State is entitled to an allowance.
In the New York City system, how much you get depends on your age. You’re also supposed to get a clothing stipend and (if you’re over 15), a stipend if you attend Independent Living workshops. Stipends are for a set amount of money, while allowance is not.
Of course, just because lawyers know about rights being honored does not mean that all foster kids know. As a teen, Melendez didn’t even know that his lawyer was there to represent him-not the foster care agency.
Be Firm
Though it’s not a written rule, when teens first meet their law guardian, it’s the law guardian’s job to explain their rights to them. If no one lays it out for them when they first enter care, teens should ask their law guardian.
Once Melendez learned the truth about his rights, he did not hesitate to advocate for himself. He went to court immediately with his law guardian to get himself and his little brother out of the foster home.
“You need to be firm,” Melendez says.
“The judge don’t wanna hear from me” is what Melendez used to think, but he learned how to find out who would help him and to persist with those people.
So how do you raise a complaint in a way that people will take you seriously? Ms. Baum suggests that teens do exactly what lawyers do: start out by asking questions, and try to do it in a constructive way.
“You can catch more flies with honey,” she says, meaning even if you are feeling sour inside, approach your foster parent in a respectful but firm manner. Start with something positive, like something you appreciate about her. Then, calmly let her know you have a concern you want to talk about. Ask the foster parent questions, and then ask the caseworker if there’s a rule about it.
If you don’t receive a satisfactory answer, the next step is to call your lawyer. And if you ever feel threatened by a foster parent or afraid to approach them first, you don’t have to. In those cases, it’s best to go to the caseworker or lawyer first.
Working Things Out
If foster parents are violating a rule, the caseworker or lawyer will probably give them a warning. If they continue violating the rules, the agency that licensed the foster home could choose to close that home.
Other times, foster parents may not be violating official rules, but there could still be a way to try to work things out if you believe there’s a good reason for them to change their ways.
“If there’s a really good reason, be a good advocate for yourself and ask for that exception to policy,” says Baum. Exception to policy is when the agency has a rule but is willing to bend it for a good reason if it doesn’t cause a safety concern. Sometimes an agency does this in its own, and sometimes a judge can urge the agency to do it in a particular case.
For example, let’s say you need a new suit to attend your graduation or a job interview, but you’ve used up your clothing allowance. That’s a time when an exception to policy might be appropriate.
In any case, the first step is asking for what you need. That’s where advocacy has to start.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.