How can you avoid getting duped when choosing a school? NYC got advice from Pamela Wheaton, project director at Insideschools.org, an independent website that reviews New York City public schools.
Wheaton’s tips:
¥ Visit Insideschools.org for unbiased information on New York City public schools. Insideschools.org tries to visit every school in the city on a regular basis. (When a new school opens, they usually visit during its second year of operation.)
“We try to speak to students, to teachers, to the principal,” said Wheaton. “We sit in on classes and try to catch students in the hallway or after school.” Students can also post comments on the Insideschools site, but Wheaton notes that unfortunately, the lowest-performing schools usually receive the fewest comments.
“What we tell people is: Use the big high school directory [published by the Department of Education], take a look at it, but then visit Insideschools.org,” said Wheaton. “we’re independent, and our job is not to do public relations for the schools.”
¥ Look at the stats. “We include a capsule report of attendance, enrollment, the free lunch rate, admissions requirements,” said Wheaton. The site’s report on Franklin K. Lane shows some key numbers. “Only 13% of kids are coming in reading at grade level; the graduation rate is 30.8%. Those would be warning flags for a good student, or really any student,” she said.
¥ Know what to look for. What’s the most important number to check when evaluating a school? “If I were a parent, I’d look at the attendance rate,” said Wheaton. “That’s a telling point about how well the school is performing, and at Franklin K. Lane last year it was only 60%.” (Only 60% of students showed up at school on an average day.)
Another number to check is the graduation rate. If a school’s graduation rate is lower than that of comparable schools, it’s a bad sign. But because some students-recent immigrants, for example-may need more time to complete their course load, Insideschools looks at both a high school’s 7-year graduation rate and its 4-year rate.
¥ See for yourself. If you’re considering a specific school, there’s no substitute for seeing it firsthand. “I would advise, if at all possible, that you visit the school,” said Wheaton. “Call the principal’s office; call the parent coordinator; ask for a tour.”
¥ Do your homework. “When you go to the city’s enrollment office, have a good idea where you want to attend,” Wheaton advised. She also recommended New York City’s Best Public High Schools by Clara Hemphill, a book available online or in bookstores.
Before You Enroll…
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.