Atheists Can Go to Heaven, Too

Call me a nerd, but one of the subjects I like most is philosophy. Philosophy is a field of human understanding, like science or religion. But where science seeks knowledge through experimentation and religion seeks knowledge through faith, philosophers approach knowledge by means of reason and argument.
I find philosophy interesting because there are questions science cannot answer and that religion answers too simply for my liking. I’m an atheist, and because of this, some people act like I have no sense of morals. But philosophy provides an alternative route to answering questions about the meaning of life and the difference between right and wrong.
Defining Piety
My school lets its students take college classes at LaGuardia Community College, and last fall I took an Introduction to Philosophy class. We were studying the many arguments Socrates (a famous Greek philosopher) got himself into, and one of those arguments was with Euthyphro.
Never mind his unpronounceable name-Euthyphro was (according to Euthyphro) an expert on moral matters. One day the two men got into an argument about what good behavior really is. Euthyphro finally said “piety” was doing whatever pleased the gods. This can be translated into more modern terms: Piety-or virtue, or doing the right thing-is doing whatever God likes.
At that moment Euthyphro probably thought he had defeated Socrates, or at least, satisfied his curiosity. But Socrates was a diehard pain in the butt. He responded with one of the most enigmatic (or puzzling) questions in human history.
“Yo, Euthyphro! I got a question: Are things good because God likes them, or does God like them because they are good?”
I don’t know what you would have answered if you were Euthyphro, but his response revolutionized modern thinking. He said that God likes good acts because they are good.
Big deal, you say? Well, it may not seem so interesting to you now, but if Euthyphro is right, I believe this actually means that I, an atheist, can go to heaven! (If I’m wrong, that is, and heaven exists.)
Not’Because He Said So’
Let me explain. According to Euthyphro’s answer, God is a super-intelligent being who can distinguish between good and evil and who enjoys good things. In other words, good things exist independently from God. Right is right and wrong is wrong, and the same things would be right and wrong even if God took himself out of the picture. What God does is only to identify what is good and instruct people to do those things.
That’s fortunate, because if God decides what’s good and bad, then the whole concept of morality (or judging right from wrong) becomes arbitrary. A good way to illustrate this is by supposing that God wakes up one day in a bad mood and orders all humans to rape infants. If God orders it, does it mean it is the right thing to do?
Many people don’t think that way, and will say that even if God ordered it, raping infants would still be wrong.
Other people may say that God would never order such a thing. But the question is, why not? He is God, after all. He can do whatever he wants.
There seems to be only one answer, and that is that God recognizes a truth that is apart from him. There exists a moral reality that is apart from the divine.
Virtue Without Belief
In other words, I can do good things for other people and for myself without having to believe in God. Belief in God possibly offers a path toward morality, but one can be the most virtuous person in the whole world without having to be a believer.
When we read this story in class, some of my classmates argued against Euthyphro’s position. But I felt vindicated. People seem to think not believing in God is wrong, but when I give to charity, I’m doing a better thing than a person who is religious but only walks past the misery of others.
Look, I’m not saying I’m the most moral person in the world. Like you, I commit my sins every time I have a chance (“sin,” in my case, means doing things that I consider wrong). I am just saying that not all atheists are the merciless, malevolent, or immoral beasts that some people think they are. They are people-with attributes, defects, and virtues, but always with the potential to do something good for others.
So be nice to them. You may have to live with some of them for all eternity in heaven.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.