“Run after him and I’ll shoot you in the head!”
I did not say a word. I was frozen, terrified.
It was a Friday evening. The weather was hot, so my friend Jean and I had decided to play basketball in the park next to my grandmother’s house. The court was full when we got there, so we sat on a bench waiting for a few guys to come and form a team. I was listening to music and Jean was sitting next to me.
After a while, four guys arrived, but they had no intention of playing basketball. One came up to me, grabbed my mp4 player and took off. By the time I turned to call Jean, he was running fast toward home. I was by myself with three guys about 20 years of age. I was 14. To make matters worse, I was new to the country and I could barely express myself in English. Meanwhile, Jean was 17 and had been here for seven years.
I thought about running after the one who took my mp4 player, but the other three guys were blocking the way. That’s when they threatened to shoot me. I didn’t see a gun, but there were often shootings in this park, and I didn’t want to take my chances.
After a while, they left me alone. I slowly walked back to my house, pissed off. That mp4 player had all my favorite songs on it and was a gift from my sister.
When I got home, I saw Jean on the phone, telling my grandma the story. As soon as he saw me, he ran to me and said, “Are you OK? Did they hurt you?”
I just gave him a look that said, “Like you care.” I didn’t feel like talking. But after I settled down, I told him exactly what happened.
“Why did you run and leave me by myself?” I asked him.
He obviously felt remorseful; his eyes were wet. “I just wanted to avoid trouble. I’m sorry!” he said.
“You know what, get out of my house and don’t even bother to call me anymore, our friendship is done!” I told him.
He looked horrified and shocked, like he’d made an irreversible error. He walked slowly from the house. Part of me thought he didn’t deserve this. Then again, I thought, he would have let me get killed.
I didn’t know whether I should be fair and push him out of my life for being a bad friend, or be generous, forgive him, and try to forget about what happened.
Finally, I ran after him and said, “Why don’t you come inside so we can play video games?
“OK, let’s go!” he said, smiling.
We’d been friends for a year, I thought-why end our friendship because I almost got hurt? It was just an mp4 player, after all.
But everything between us changed after that day. The first week following the event, he couldn’t look me in the eye or joke around with me. Then we stopped hanging out like we used to. Now, we don’t talk on the phone or share stories like we used to, and when we go to a restaurant, he offers to pay for me. We don’t even get into fights anymore. It’s like he puts himself down for me, and it makes me feel bad. In a way, I think ending our friendship would have been better than going through all this.
-Philippe Sainvil
Would you have forgiven Jean?
Ben: If my friend abandoned me, I’d forgive him, but not without letting him know how I felt about it. If people don’t know what they did was wrong, then you’re forgiving them for nothing, because they’ll do it again. But you don’t have to just let the friendship go.
Can you forgive someone without forgetting what they’vedone?
Ayana: Some things you just can’t forget, and if you can’t forget there’s no such thing as true forgiveness. It’s always going to be in the back of your mind.
Perry: I think the writer wanted to forget his friend was a bad friend. But I think if someone does you wrong, that’s the end of it. They’re dead to you.
Jane: We might forgive someone in the moment, but if we think about it later on, it might spark anger and resentment. If, after an incident, you look at that person differently, then it’s not going to be the same type of friendship that it was before.
Have you ever felt you were forgiven too easily?
Cinorow: I told my cousin to walk with me somewhere, and we got jumped by some people I had a problem with. I thought my cousin was going to be mad, because he didn’t even want to come with me in the first place, but he wasn’t at all. He actually was telling me to forget about it. I felt guilty. But we still cool.
What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing
No Friend in Need
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.