What Would You Do? Teens Debate What it Means to Do the Right Thing

To Tell or Not to Tell

“Hey, did you study?” asked a student in my 10th grade history class, right before a big test. He showed me his notes, trying to convince me to cheat with him and two other kids. “Come sit with us,” he urged.
I hadn’t studied either. I thought about copying the answers like they wanted me to, but I decided against it. It just didn’t feel right. In fact, it made me a little angry.
These boys cheated all the time, using some low trick just to get a passing grade. When I thought about the perspective of those who had studied, I got mad, because these guys were trying to get the same result without working for it.
I felt like I had to choose whether to be honest and fair to those who did study, or be loyal to these “friends.” I decided to tip the teacher off about the cheating, but without saying who was doing it.
“Miss xxxxx, can we use the textbook and handouts during the test? I saw someone using them,” I said.
“No, nothing. Everything off the tables now,” she said as she started walking around the room to check the tables. The people who wanted to cheat couldn’t peek at the answers now that the teacher was paying more attention. They showed their middle fingers to me, but I just ignored them and finished my test.
Afterwards, they cornered me in the classroom.
“F-ck you, what do you think you’re doing? You mother f-cker,” one of them said.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about. I was just asking if we could use books or handouts,” I said, playing dumb. They kept cursing at me.
It felt a little bit good to tell on them, but I decided later that I shouldn’t care so much about things that aren’t my business. People who want to cheat are going to do it somehow, anyway. Just because I stopped it once doesn’t mean they won’t do it on the next exam, so what’s the point?
-Anonymous
Do you think it’s a big deal to cheat on a test?
Cinorow: Yes. If someone worked hard to be successful, why couldn’t you just do the same thing?
Jane: I think there’s an understanding between students that we all want to pass, we all want to graduate. I guess this understanding makes us more lenient toward cheating. We give each other answers sometimes. But not on big tests, like APs or Regents. You’re going overboard if you cheat on state tests.
So there are codes of conduct even in cheating?
Ayana: I’ll write the answers on my hand, but I wouldn’t steal someone else’s answers. That’s basically just using them, especially if the only time you talk to them is when you need answers.
Torres: I think cheating is mostly wrong in games or sports because there’s only one winner. But in school, if I work to get an A and someone cheats to get an A+, it’s not like their cheating makes me any less smart. It’s not going to directly affect me.
Does cheating make you angry?
Lana: Yes. If I study hard to pass a test, it’s not fair for kids to cheat.
Ayana: No, because I used to do it. Nobody is too good for cheating.
Did the writer make the right decision telling the teacher that people were cheating?
Cinorow: I don’t think it’s good to tell, period. There are other ways to handle the situation. Go talk to the people who are cheating. Tell them, “You cheated. Try to study next time, it might be more fun.”
Ayana: He got cursed out-but they could have beat him up, jumped him. It could have escalated. And he told on people who were trying to give him the answers and be nice to him! That’s just so disrespectful.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.