Top Secret?

What confidential medical care means when you're in foster care

“Everything you say is confidential. This is just between you and me.” I’ve often heard social workers say that, but when my foster mom knows things about my health before I do-and things about my personal life that I’ve only shared with my doctor-I begin wondering if anything is really confidential for youth in foster care.
How much privacy do we have a right to expect, especially when it comes to our sexual health? This can be a sensitive topic to bring up even when you’re sure that everything you say will stay between you and your doctor. And when you don’t have that assurance, it can be really hard to come forward and seek care. But that might have serious consequences for your health.
There are ways of getting confidential information and treatment, even if you’re in foster care. To find out more, I interviewed Corinne Carey, a lawyer at the New York Civil Liberties Union. The NYCLU is a nonprofit organization that defends the rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States, including freedom of speech and the right to privacy. It has a youth program called the Teen Health Initiative that helps teens learn about their rights when it comes to reproductive health care.
Are teens in foster care entitled to confidentiality?
Generally, if you’re under 18, a parent or legal guardian (like a foster parent) has to consent (give permission) for medical care. But in New York and many other states, any minor is entitled to confidential care when it comes to reproductive health. That includes things like birth control, pelvic exams, abortions, and testing for sexually transmitted infections. You can receive sexual assault care and substance abuse treatment on your own, and some mental health treatments. Teens can also access abortion services without parental consent, though in some states they need permission from the court or a physician if they can’t tell a parent.
How much access do foster parents and social workers have to our health records?
When the foster care agency sets up the appointment and consents to your care, they generally have access to your records. However, if a minor goes on his or her own to seek health care, he or she is entitled to confidentiality and no one else can see the records. You can also request copies of your own medical records.
It’s hard to keep things private if the foster care agency gets the medical bill. Is there any way to prevent that?
The person who’s responsible for paying for the care (even if it’s just a deductible) has the right to see what care they’re paying for. Bills can sometimes reveal what kind of medical care you’ve received. So there’s a conflict between the rights of the teen to get confidential care and the rights of those paying for that care.
Sometimes the health care provider works with their billing department to label services in a different way. So for example, they can make sure that the billing code doesn’t say “STD testing” but something less obvious instead.
We recommend that teens who have concerns about confidentiality seek out a health care provider other than the one the foster parent or agency uses. You can also look for other ways to pay for that care. In some places, local community health centers will provide sexual health care, including abortion, for free or at low cost. You can also try Planned Parenthood to help you find funds.
So how can you make sure that the doctor respects your confidentiality?
Again, foster parents and agency staff may have full access to medical records for routine check-ups because the agency is the one consenting to or paying for the appointment.
So if the foster care agency sets up the appointment, or if a foster parent or group home staff takes you to the doctor, you have to be clear with the doctor that there are certain parts of the exam you want to be kept confidential. When something is confidential, the doctor is then supposed to keep those notes or records separate so they can turn over the other records to the parent or agency without revealing things that are confidential.
Always check with your doctor about confidentiality before sharing something you don’t want your guardian or foster care agency to know about. Many doctors will protect a teen patient’s confidentiality. If not, you might want to go somewhere else for care.
For More Information
Visit the NYCLU’s Teen Health Initiative website at www.thi.nyclu.org or call the NYCLU Reproductive Rights Project at 212-607-3341.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.