Does anyone recall the presidential election of 2000-how Al Gore won the popular vote but in the end George W. Bush managed to become president?
I remember how confused I was when this occurred. I’d always believed American citizens decided who would become the new tenant of the White House. I saw how the media tried so hard to convince citizens to vote, especially young people (who can forget those bland-looking T-shirts with the awkward message, “Vote or Die”?).
Now the claim “every vote counts” began to sound false. It seemed something called the Electoral College could go against the people’s decision. Gore, who won the majority of popular votes, was defeated because the Electoral College had the final word.
Votes Do Have a Voice
I could have just gone to Google and read up on how the political process works. But I didn’t, so all these years I’ve been contaminated with the misconception that we the voters don’t select our leader.
Researching this story, I dreaded reading what seemed like a bunch of boring articles. But as I continued, I began to understand that the Electoral College is a complex system by which a nationwide election can come down to just one state’s results and the outcome of a few hundred votes. In the end, I was stunned to find a personal vote really does give you a voice.
Here’s How It Works:
¥ The Electoral College was created by the same group of old guys who wrote the U.S. Constitution more than 200 years ago. During that time, some politicians worried the average voter didn’t know enough about politics to make a wise decision. But other politicians said it was undemocratic to let Congress choose the president. The Electoral College system was invented as a compromise.
¥ You can’t apply to the Electoral College; it’s just the term given to a group of “electors,” people active in politics who meet in their state capitals a few weeks after Election Day to ceremonially declare which candidate their state’s voters have chosen.
¥ To easily understand the Electoral College, remember that the national election is really a number of separate state elections. In every state except Maine and Nebraska, the candidate who wins the most votes gets all of that state’s electors. This is known as a “winner-take-all” system.
¥ States with many voters have more electors and therefore greater sway in the presidential election-California, for example, has 55 electors, while sparsely populated Alaska has only 3.
¥ The most important states are “swing states,” where voters tend to be equally divided between the Democratic and Republican parties, making it unclear which candidate will win all the electors for the state until all votes are counted. Ohio, Florida and Pennsylvania are three relatively big states that can “swing” either way, and may have the final say on who gets to be president if the race is very close. That’s why candidates spend lots of money and time advertising on TV and shaking hands with voters in these states.
The focus that the Electoral College system places on big swing states is one reason why it’s controversial. Why should voters in Pennsylvania get so much more attention from candidates and media than voters in New York?
Change the System
Another issue is the “winner-take-all” system. Let’s say you vote Republican in a mostly Democratic state like New York. The fact remains that the majority of voters will probably favor the Democratic candidate. That candidate will then be awarded all New York’s electoral votes, leaving your vote unnoticed in the national tally.
Even though I’m glad to know the Electoral College isn’t solely run by the federal government and is very much influenced by citizens, I think it’s time for a change. The present system is confusing, and unfair to voters outside swing states. Besides, in 2000’s election, it was clear Gore was more worthy of the presidency in most voters’ eyes. So it’s shocking to me to think of all the times people pulled their hair out over Bush’s actions and know that all the headaches might have been prevented without the Electoral College.
Electoral College Made Easy
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.