In Haiti, where I was born, the countryside is known as “The Lost Country” because people from the city don’t know anything about it. City people sometimes make fun of country people and their accent, but I think country people are smarter than city people. City people depend on food transported from other countries, but country people are self-sufficient and grow their own.
This isn’t always easy, as I learned a few years ago. I lived in a rural town called Diegue. When I turned 7, my godmother gave me a baby goat. I had never dreamed of getting a goat for my birthday, but I was so happy. The goat was brown with a little bit of white on her face.
At first I left the goat untied, because I wanted her to follow me around, until one day a man who lived nearby came to my house with a machete. He explained that the goat had eaten his crops, and if he found her in his garden ever again he would cut off her head. I decided it would be a good idea to tie my goat.
Man’s Best Friend
This goat and I became great friends. I even ate my dinner near her and fed her some of my rice. My older cousin Fabian also loved taking care of the goat and gave her the name “Manush.” I liked it, so the goat now had a name. I promised my cousin that one day I would give her a baby goat like my godmother gave me.
After some time, we took Manush to a place where they had male goats and paid the owner to leave her there for one day. After a few months, she had three babies. I really wanted to give my cousin one, but I couldn’t bear to give up any of them, so I asked her to wait until Manush had other babies.
After two years I had about seven goats and all of them were friendly. But I had a special relationship with Manush; some people say that dogs are man’s best friend, but this female goat was mine.
On my 10th birthday, my mother asked me if I wanted to eat one of the goats for my birthday. At that time nothing was in my mind except that I was about to eat a lot of meat, which I loved so much. Goat meat is one of the most expensive meats in Haiti and I felt honored to have a whole goat cooked just for my birthday.
When my godfather was about to kill the goat (not Manush), he called me so I could hold its feet while he cut it under the throat. I was excited-some other kids were watching and this made me feel more grown-up and important than them.
Like a Crime
I held the goat’s legs, but before my godfather could even put the knife on the goat, I started crying. My hands were shaking. I suddenly felt as if the life of one of my best friends was about to be taken away. I felt weak and guilty knowing that I was going to play a part in killing my goat.
My brother called me soft and made me go away for the rest of the day. I went into the woods where I had put Manush and the rest of the goats. As soon as Manush saw me she started trying to come near me. I walked to her and petted her for a while.
I was thinking about the goat’s head being cut off its body. To me it felt like a crime. Eventually my sister came to get me. I went home and sat at the table alone. Everyone was watching me as I ate the food, including the meat, with anger and sadness.
I tried hard not to let the goat’s death affect me because I knew if I didn’t get over it, my family and friends would make fun of me. On my next birthday they wanted to kill Manush, but I wouldn’t let them, so they killed another of Manush’s babies. Even though the goats belonged to me, I had no choice about this because everyone was waiting on the goat meat and the great-tasting soup my mother would make from it.
In America, it’s nice not to have to eat one of my lovely goats every March 19th (my birthday), but the day still reminds me of them. It sounds thoughtful that my family would kill a goat just to please me, but my birthday has become one of the worst days of the year because I can’t help thinking about the times when I had to eat creatures I cared about.
I Miss My Friend
I left Haiti on May 16, 2003, when I was 12. Two nights before I left, I went into the yard where the goats were and sat there talking to Manush. I knew I wasn’t going to have any time to say goodbye if I didn’t do it then. I felt like crying, but I didn’t. I sat there petting Manush on the head, telling her that Fabian was going to take good care of her.
Now I live in a big city where I can find almost everything that I need, except for the atmosphere of the countryside-the aroma of coffee and fresh-made bread, roosters singing in the morning, the woods. I miss my favorite friend, Manush, most of all.
Two years ago I went to Haiti for a few days. When I asked about Manush my mother told me my godmother was watching over her, but when I asked to go see her, they never took me. That made me suspicious. Now my cousin tells me on the phone that Manush is still alive, but I don’t believe her. It makes more sense that my family would sell her, because goats are worth a lot of money in Haiti.
Soon I will be going back there for another visit and I will have the chance to see for myself, but I have a bad feeling. Everyone else thought of her as just a goat, but Manush was family to me.
The Things We Miss
A Goat Named Manush
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.