Speak Out on Grading Schools

Jayvee Rhoda, 16
Edward R. Murrow HS
Progress Report Grade: B
Do you know if your school got a grade (A to F) this year from the Department of Education?
“Yes, I’ve heard about the school’s grade. In fact, the school’s newspaper gave students a thorough explanation about what the grade was and what it meant.”
What do you think of grading a school? Should schools be graded on performance, attendance, improvement, etc?
“Absolutely not. There may be cases where [some] students give their school a bad [reputation even though] good students make up the majority of the school. The school shouldn’t be given a bad mark.”
Does the grade motivate you or discourage you?
“The [B] grade disappoints me and discourages me because I believe that teachers can do better to make the grade better, and maybe the principal has a part. The students are already doing what they can but it is the responsibility of the adults that our grade reflects our [school’s] claim to excellence.”
Taquan Pugh, 17
Benjamin Banneker Academy
Progress Report Grade: B
Do you know if your school got a grade this year from the department of Education?
“I did see in the newspaper that my school got a B.”
What do you think of grading schools? Should schools be graded on performance, attendance, improvement, etc?
“I don’t have a problem with grading, but schools shouldn’t be judged by their grade. I don’t think the grade can always determine the school as a whole. I believe that a school should be graded on things such as their performance, community involvement, extracurricular activities and the violence rate.”
What effects do you think this new system will have?
“Grading systems are gonna hurt schools, because struggling schools may not get a chance to show their improvement or ultimately get a chance to do better.”
What grade do you think your school should have gotten?
“I believe that a B is fair. The school performs well and the attendance is good, but the school has room for improvement.”
Does the grade motivate or discourage you?
“The grade definitely motivates me because it makes me feel good about where I am.”
Infinite Cubia, 20
John V. Lindsay Wildcat Academy
Progress Report Grade: didn’t get a grade. (A system for grading transfer schools like Wildcat Academy is under development.)
What do you think of grading schools? Should schools be graded on performance, attendance, improvement, etc?
“I think they should, because that’s what schools are about, and helping the students. If a student is doing poorly, they get a report card, and if they need to step it up, so do the schools. All schools should be graded by the city or state, and we all should start caring about these grades because the environment that [we] learn [in] is important.”
Monet Raymond, 16, Secondary School for Journalism
Progress Report Grade: C
Do you know if your school got a grade (A to F) this year from the Department of Education?
“I didn’t know at first, but I recently found out that we received a C.”
What effects do you think this new system will have?
“I don’t think the school should be graded as a whole because there are some students who care about grades and others that don’t. Students who neglect their grades are bringing us down. It’s not fair.”
What effects do you think this new system will have?
“It could help us because it encourages us to want more for ourselves, to do better and to think better.”
Does the grade motivate you or discourage you?
“This grade motivates me. I’m not going to be yet another statistic, because I feel that’s what people expect. I want us to receive an A next time.”
Durriyah Williams, 17, Secondary School for Journalism
Progress Report Grade: C
Do you know if your school got a grade (A to F) this year from the Department of Education?
“I knew about it, but didn’t pay any mind to it because I heard it was some type of scam.”
What do you think of grading schools? Should schools be graded on performance, attendance, improvement, etc?
“Schools shouldn’t be graded on these things because other things matter, such as effort, activities outside of school, and the type of classes and level of difficulty of each class.”
What effects do you think this new system will have?
“I think students don’t care about the new system, so it won’t really have an effect. The system itself won’t hurt or help the students-it’s the students that should want to do better for themselves.”
What grade do you think your school should have gotten?
“I think the school should have at least earned a B because the principal is really strict and all the yelling she does should have paid off.”
Courtney Tolliver, 17
Benjamin Banneker Academy
Progress Report Grade: B
Do you know if your school got a grade this year from the Department of Education?
“Yes, we got a B.”
What do you think of grading schools?
“I don’t agree with grading schools because it’s not showing the potential of the students.”
Should schools be grade on performance, attendance, improvement, etc.?
“Schools should be graded on the students’ performance as well as the teachers and administration.”
What grade do you think your school should have gotten?
“I believe the grade was fair. Teachers help us, Banneker [students] try hard and are motivated. I still believe Banneker has room for improvement.”
Have teachers, staff or the principal at your school talked about the your school’s grade?
“No. My mother is a school teacher. That’s how I was informed of my school’s grade.”
Does the grade motivate you or discourage you?
“It motivates me because I know that we’re at the top, yet we can strive and reach higher.”
Diana Perez, 17, Fort Hamilton HS
Progress Report Grade: B
What do you think of grading schools? Should schools be graded on performance, attendance, improvement, etc?
“I think grading a school is not worth the time. Not every school is perfect, and you can’t judge it with a grade.”
What grade do you think your school should have gotten? Why?
“My school should have gotten an D. From what I’ve seen this year, the school doesn’t do well with preventing violence and rules aren’t enforced as they should be. The effort that should be put into the school is barely there.”
Have teachers, staff or the principal at your school talked about your school’s grade?
“No, and I find this surprising. I hadn’t heard about school grading until now.”
Does the grade motivate or discourage you?
“It motivates me because even though I think that schools shouldn’t be graded, they will be anyway. As a senior I would like to see students attend a school that’s not violent and that everyone can be proud of.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.