I was totally shocked when my editor told me that my school received a B on its progress report. I believe it should’ve received a C or a D. For one thing, it’s overcrowded. When I arrived at the school in 2004 there were maybe 300 kids, but over the past few years, that number has soared as more freshmen have started. Now there are 533 students in a school that’s too small for them.
The hallways are tiny, so changing classes is a nightmare. And classrooms are always crowded. If you have to use the bathroom during class, there’s no way to make it through the crowd of noisy kids squished into the room.
As for attendance, one component of the grade, I looked up the progress report on the New York City Department of Education (DOE) website and I saw that we got an 88.3%, which seems like a pretty good grade. Yet, each morning at school I see lines across the gym for late passes, and I know at least six people in my classes who are absent once a week. From what I can see, we have horrible attendance.
I don’t See Improvement
Part of the grade is also based on student surveys that were handed out in school last spring. But no one I know took the surveys seriously. Some students threw them out and some just circled any answers without thinking about it. Others, like me, had no idea what was going on. We weren’t given any directions. And the survey was handed out during gym, at a time when I could care less about a survey because I was busy trying to get changed.
When it comes to my school’s graduation rate, the report seems closer to what I’m seeing at school. It says that 75.6% of students graduate in four years, and 89.1% in six years. This I believe, because many students are held back and stay an extra year or two to make up classes and earn all of their credits. Out of 90 seniors in my graduating class, only about 20 are officially seniors. The rest still need to take junior classes to graduate on time.
More than half of the grade (55%) is based on student progress, but it’s hard to see how our test grades could be improving. Students cut class and leave early. The school doesn’t feel safe. One day a kid went around knocking down garbage cans in the lunchroom and then pretended to pull out a gun, terrifying students. At lunch, kids are running around, fighting and screaming or selling drugs. Someone is always getting into a fight and getting arrested.
Comparing Schools Is Unfair
And how did we get a B in the first place? We only got 19 out of 55 points for student progress, and 7.4 out of 15 in the student environment category of the progress report.
Well, one reason might be that the DOE isn’t only grading schools on how they perform, but on how they compare with similar schools (schools with similar populations or incoming students’ test scores). In other words, my school was probably in a group of 40 bad schools. Compared to a bunch of other bad schools, mine might actually be a “B” school. But if you were to put my school up against a better school, I’m sure our grade would have been a lot lower.
I think the system of comparing schools is unfair and isn’t the best way figure out which schools need to get better. I know my school needs improvement. But since it’s grouped with other bad schools, it came out looking OK. I worry that because of that, the administrators and teachers may not work to make the school better.
Basically, my school is crap. If I can see it and my classmates can see it, how is it that the Department of Education remains blind to it? I think they need to reevaluate my school. Better yet, they should spend a day in the life of a student here-that’s the only way they’ll really know how to grade my school.
Breaking Down the Grade
The Department of Ed Must Be Blind
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.