Breaking Down the Grade

My School's Rep wasn't Real

I was shocked to learn that my old high school in Brooklyn got a B, because I assumed it deserved an A.
I attended my old high school for four years until June 2006, when I transferred to South Brooklyn Community HS because I was behind in my credits.
When I was at my first high school, school officials and teachers praised it as one of the best high schools in the state. I never heard the end of it, especially every time the principal took the stage at a school meeting.
The principal would tell students that we should take advantage of the opportunities and safe environment the school offered. She’d remind us of the many students who wanted to attend our school but couldn’t because of space limits.
Privileges for Athletes
Thinking back, though, I realize that the school’s reputation might have had more to do with appearances than academics.
When I first walked through the school entrance, I noticed the showcasing frames full of trophies and banners commemorating the football team, marching band and ROTC triumphs against rival schools. The school got a lot of attention because of its successful teams.
I remember witnessing the special privileges that students who were part of the sports teams received. I had friends in these groups, and they saw themselves as the elite. They showed up to class just to claim a passing grade so they could play their sports. They only had to do their homework when forced by their coaches.
I felt angry at the students who I saw passing classes because they could catch and toss a ball. When I discovered the school’s grade, a sadistic smirk came over my face. I savored the moment of the school finally getting what it deserved-a “slap to the face” for favoring its athletes.
False Impression
Why did my old school get a B? Maybe it didn’t show much progress over the year (progress is 55% of a school’s grade). I think the school’s safe environment and outstanding teams created a false impression of the school-at least among its students-as one of the best schools in the city. Perhaps the grade has revealed the school’s less than perfect academics. My image of an outstanding academic school has been replaced by the truth.
The school’s B may remind the principal and others at my old school that they’vegot to shape up if they want to get a perfect score next time. After all, what is the school’s reputation worth if its academics don’t live up to the hype?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.