I still remember the brief and awkward conversation a guidance counselor had with my English class after one of my schoolmates committed suicide. His death came on a day close to the one-year anniversary of the deaths of two other schoolmates, which had left my classmates and me reeling.
It seemed like a foreign concept to have an adult at school ask us about our emotions. And in many New York City public schools, it is. But that’s not because we teens don’t need someone to talk to. Many of us do.
One in five children in New York City has a diagnosable mental, emotional or behavioral disorder, and at least one in 10 has a serious emotional disturbance that interferes with their ability to function on a daily basis, according to the New York State Coalition for School-Based Primary Care.
Yet 70% of teens with a severe diagnosis don’t receive any mental health services, and about 100,000 teens are on waiting lists for mental health services in New York City.
Demanding More Funds
Hoping to make sure more young people get the help they need, about 200 teens invited by school-based health centers (SBHCs) around the city joined New York City Council Member Gale Brewer and health and youth advocacy groups last June in front of City Hall.
They were rallying to demand more attention to the problem of youth mental health care. Participants included the Primary Care Development Corporation, Citizen’s Committee for Children of New York, the New York State Coalition for School-Based Primary Care, school-based health centers staff and others.
They wanted Mayor Michael Bloomberg and the City Council to spend $6 million to provide at least one full-time clinical social worker or psychologist in each SBHC-the health centers in schools where students can receive medical, mental health and dental services. They also wanted to open more health centers in schools that don’t have them.
Right now, schools with SBHCs do not have adequate mental health services, according to the Children’s Aid Society. The society and other supporters of SBHCs recommend that schools have one full-time mental health provider for every 1,000 students. But one-fourth of the schools with an SBHC have no mental health provider, one-fourth have one part-time mental health provider for up to 4,000 students, and half have one full-time provider for up to 4,000 students.
Preventing’Killing Scenes’
Advocates like Adria Cruz-Pea, school health services manager of the Children’s Aid Society, thought that the timing was right for this cause, given the recent shooting at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University. (A Virginia Tech student shot and killed 32 people on April 16, and then killed himself.)
“When we were pushing for this [funding], we had just learned about the killing scene in Virginia,” said Cruz-Pea. “We think this type of thing can be prevented when you have mental health services and information.”
But when the city government’s budget was released in mid-June, the advocates’ funding request wasn’t on it. “It’s so disappointing because we know the impact that the services have on the mental health of our teenagers,” Cruz-Pea said. “We would prefer to have this support in all schools.”
The New York State School-Based Health Centers Program, which Cruz-Pea called “the best-kept secret in New York,” was created in 1981 to treat children in low-income, high-risk communities, including many without health insurance.
The program was intended to provide health services to children through “health teams” composed of school nurses, nurse practitioners, physicians, physician’s assistants, community health aides, social workers, psychologists, psychiatrists, health educators, nutritionists and dentists.
Since the program’s creation, many other states have followed suit and brought SBHCs to their schools, and there are now 61 centers in New York City high schools and middle schools, according to the New York State Coalition for School-Based Primary Care.
Thinking More Positively
Advocates of SBHCs say that the schools providing mental health services are making a profound difference. Students who received mental health services at SBHCs became less depressed and began to think more positively about themselves, according to Children’s Aid Society’s reports. The society also found that adolescents were far more likely to seek help for depression and suicidal thoughts at SBHCs than at community programs.
A Struggle for Care
Children in schools without school-based health centers often have an even tougher time accessing mental health services. Although the Department of Education must hire a school nurse for every New York City public school, they do not have to hire professionals trained in mental health issues, said Council Member Gale Brewer.
Without more money from the city, the school-based health centers struggle to get funding. Currently, the health centers are funded through grants from state and city governments and private foundations or through agreements with private health centers or nearby hospitals, according to Brewer and Cruz-Pea. This means that not every school can have the services offered in a SBHC, because not every school has a hospital nearby that’s willing to help or can get funding for a center.
Council Member Gale Brewer said she has visited schools both with and without funding for centers and the difference is astonishing. “Young people have issues,” Brewer said. “Communities are challenged with drugs, incest and housing, and there’s nobody to talk to. You need somebody on-site because if you tell people to go to a hospital, they’re not going to go. [Mental illness has] a stigma, so it has to be on-site. If you’re at a [school] clinic…no one knows who you’re going to see.”
‘Not Teen-Friendly’
Teens who don’t have access to these centers are left with few options besides government health clinics which are, “understaffed and not necessarily teen-friendly,” according to Dr. Chris Kjolhede, a steering committee member of the New York State Coalition for School-Based Primary Care.
The coalition plans to try again next year to get the funding they rallied for in June.
But some people believe the need for more mental health services for teens may be exaggerated. In his column for Youth Today, a newspaper for adults working with youth, writer and sociologist Mike Males cites numerous studies showing that teens are happier than they’veever been. He refers to a Kansas State University study that showed that only 5% of students use mental health services, a rate that has not changed in 15 years.
Bowed Heads, Watery Eyes
His argument doesn’t convince Council Member Brewer. She argues that 5% is quite a large number in New York City’s 1 million-student school system. And “It’s just someone to talk to,” she said. It doesn’t have to be more than that.”
I know what she means. After the guidance counselor left my classroom following my classmate’s suicide, a quick glance around revealed bowed heads and watery eyes. It was clear many of us did need someone to talk to. It really didn’t have to be more than that.
Someone To Talk To
Teens rally for more mental health services in schools
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.