Speak Out on on the Student Survey
By Isma Aslam, Desiree Bailey, April Daley, Jill Feigelman, Yaki Lin, Nathanial Mack, Donald Moore and Cassius Naylor
Tiffanie Perea, Curtis HS:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“I thought it was retarded and why [did] they randomly want to ask us this?”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“Not too effective. People thought it was annoying and [I] felt students didn’t answer truthfully so they didn’t get what they wanted out of it.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“They just handed it out and [the assistant principal] said to complete it on the loud speaker.”
Osei Afriye, 17, Manhattan Village Academy:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“It was just [good] to be able to talk about the school. Those were good questions to ask students about their school.”
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out surveys?
“Some of them wanted to. They were relieved that they could say things about their school and get them changed. Some didn’t want to but they did [anyway].”
What was your overall impression of the survey? Do you think it asked effective questions or not?
“Some questions were effective but others were not.”
How did you teacher present the survey to the class?
There was a big envelope with little envelopes inside. She said it was important.”
Tamika Tannis, 18, Stuyvesant HS:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“I thought some of the questions were really cliched and silly but at the same time I could understand why they asked them. For example, we laughed and cracked jokes in my homeroom about some questions referring to bullying and if we ever feel unsafe or scared to come to school. But at the same time I know that for some New York City students that’s a reality.”
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out the survey?
“We thought it was a waste of time. Like I said, people in my homeroom cracked jokes about the questions, there were sounds that gave off the feeling of’Why would they even ask that?’ And everyone pretty much rushed through it.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“I don’t really remember what was on it. All I can remember thinking was’Oh, wow. Not one of these types of things.'”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“Somewhere along the lines of,’Here guys, you have to fill this out. Take one and pass it back.'”
Tristan Reginato, 15, Beacon HS:
What did you think about the NYC public school survey?
“It was pointless. I thought it was stupid and to give it out was a waste of time.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“It was not effective.”
How did you teacher present the survey to the class?
“My teacher first said it was a pop quiz. So [when it wasn’t] people were like,’Oh,’ and thought it was just a stupid test.”
Nydia Palaz, 18, Forest Hills HS:
What was your overall impression of the recent public school survey? Do you think it asked effective questions or not?
“Not effective. It’s a cultural issue. We [students/teens] don’t care in general so it couldn’t be taken seriously.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“(They didn’t.) We just filled it out and left it in the office.”
Monique Davis, 18, Metropolitan Corporate Academy:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“I didn’t. I just took it.”
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out the survey?
“They didn’t. They just didn’t care about it.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“I didn’t get the point of it.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“He just said the school has to take a survey so we have to take it.”
Tiffany Stone, 16, Fashion Industries HS:
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out the recent public school survey?
“They didn’t understand why they had to do it.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“I didn’t mind telling what was going on. Knowing our emotions helps the school understand what is going on.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“They just gave it out.”
Xavier Harding, 17, STAR Early College HS at Erasmus:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“It seemed inquisitive. One thing that I, and many of my classmates, complained about was that there was no choice you could pick that was’neutral’ or’I don’t know.’ It would have been helpful to include this.”
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out the survey?
“They felt (as did I) that it was kind of a hassle, a piece of paper asking them to take precious minutes of their time to fill out a questionnaire about one of the places they like the least. Then again, it was done during class, so we didn’t mind too much.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“Although [it was] long, I thought the questions were definitely effective.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“Our teacher simply said it was a survey for us to fill out from the Department of Education.”
Jenna Kass, 17, Wagner HS:
What did you think about the recent public school survey?
“It felt like a waste of time and a bad way to get an accurate gauge of school situations.”
How did students in your school react to being asked to fill out the survey?
“They were generally either annoyed at being forced to take it or happy because it took up class time.”
What was your overall impression of the survey?
“It was easy to see what it was aiming for, and therefore useless. If a student, or a whole group of students, had a grudge toward teachers, or a bad day, or had just received detention or something, they could have easily answered with that heavy bias. The same goes for the opposite end of the spectrum. There are too many variables to make it really accurate.”
How did your teacher present the survey to the class?
“My teacher told us that we had a mandatory survey to take, and had us sit and take it at the beginning of class. No one really took it seriously.”
Speak Out on the NYC Dept. of Education Student Survey
2007 Student Survey Sample Questions
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.