Can Men Who Batter Stop? Part 1

Two perspectives on treatment

The idea of “treating” domestic violence offenders is relatively new, and there’s a lot of debate about it. Can men who batter women really change? And if so, what’s the best way to get them to do that? While all court-mandated programs have to meet certain guidelines, some programs take a hard-line approach, emphasizing that men who batter are choosing to do something wrong and need to take responsibility for that. Other programs are more therapeutic, with an added focus on helping men figure out for themselves why they’vebeen battering and how they can stop. We spoke with Vicki Gorder and Ted Bunch, who run two different treatment programs, to find out more.
Creating a Desire for Change
Interview with Vicki Gorder
Partners in Change is a counseling agency in Colorado Springs. We do all different types of counseling, but we specialize in domestic violence offender treatment and drug and alcohol counseling. Domestic violence offenders can join our program voluntarily, but most of them are sent here by the courts.
There are state goals and curricula that we have to follow, and there’s a lot of stress on accountability and education. But I’m from the camp that believes that for long-term change to occur, you also have to engage these men in a therapeutic relationship.
You can say, “This is bad, this is wrong, and if you do it again you’re going to go to jail,” and people may say “OK,” but the minute they get out of there, they’re gonna do what they’re gonna do. I believe that to see long-term change, I have to hold these men accountable but also create an environment where men want to change, not because I say it’s wrong, because they do.
Part of my approach is creating the desire to change. Most men (although not all) truly want to be a man of honor and integrity. I ask them, “What is your own sense of honor telling you? Most men are taught not to hit women, so they’re violating their own beliefs, not just mine.
A lot of my clients have never thought of it that way. They’re used to being told, “You’re a batterer, a bad person.” All the defense mechanisms kick in and they want to minimize their behavior and shift the blame. They say, “It wasn’t that wrong. It’s not like we’re Ike and Tina.” I say, “Well, how wrong do you see it as being? How wrong was it for you?” Often they’vecome from a violent home, so the fact that they punched a hole in the wall doesn’t seem that bad, because they didn’t punch their partner. Sometimes they think they’re handling their anger well.
I also tell, my clients, “We all do things for a reason. You use violence because there’s a payoff-it gets someone else to do what you want. But what does it cost you? For a lot of men, when they start to look at what kind of role model they’re being for their children, that’s the avenue of change. They want their sons to look up to them, and they don’t want their daughters to end up getting beaten.
Domestic violence treatment for offenders is still relatively new. There’s a lot of controversy around what does and doesn’t work, and the idea that we’ll find this one solution to fix offenders is not reality. They have potential and it’s up to us to help them change. We haven’t perfected that yet.
There are men who have been to treatment who are not going to change. But I don’t believe that’s the majority. Most men who are working to change will say they feel better about themselves and have a different type of relationship with their partners-one that’s loving, warm and nurturing. They begin to get what they really wanted.
These men want relationships, but they don’t know how to get their needs met without using violence. When they learn how to earn respect, admiration and love, they realize the difference between love and fear. Love is very different from compliance that they’veforced out of their partner by using violence.
Vicki Gorder is the co-director of Partners in Change, an offender treatment program in Colorado Springs.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.