A Student Bill of Rights

City teens take back the schools

“Education is the property of no one! If education is not given to the people, it will have to be taken!” Judging from the fire of the speeches coming from inside Judson Memorial Church near Washington Square Park, passers-by might have thought the group inside was planning a massive overthrow of the government.
But teen speaker Tenelle Pierce, who quoted Argentinean revolutionary Ernesto “Che” Guevara in her speech, wasn’t planning a coup d’etat. She was one of hundreds of teenagers gathered at the Manhattan church in mid-November to fight for change in the New York City school system.
Prisoners in School
Pierce and other teens who attended the teen-organized convention said they were tired of being treated as prisoners inside their own schools. They could no longer stand their schools’ lack of college preparation. And they were united in their support of a proposed student bill of rights, which would include the right to safe high schools, college preparation and a voice in school policy decisions.
The student rights convention was organized by the Urban Youth Collaborative (UYC), an association created by teen activist groups in 2004 to give students a voice in New York City high school reform. UYC-which includes teen activist groups like Make the Road by Walking, Sistas and Brothas United and Youth on the Move-proposed the student bill of rights in summer 2006.
There’s a lot of work to be done. With only 54% of New York City high school students graduating on time-compared to the national on-time graduation rate of 70%-our school system has to change.
A Failing System
Teens Liz Vincent and Albert Ramos, who spoke at the convention, described the school system as being designed to prevent students from ever achieving. They spoke of school police officers instilling fear into the hearts of students. They were concerned about students who are undocumented immigrants, who fear the police could get them sent back to their home countries.
Teens also spoke of college preparation being reserved only for students with the top grades, and of failing students not always being given the chance to change.
And I know that failing students often drop out of school and either can’t get or don’t bother to look for work.
There are actually about 170,000 young people ages 16 through 24 who are “disconnected,” which means they aren’t in school or working. That’s one in six young people who have given up, according to the Community Service Society.
Tired of not being a priority, one teen speaker at the convention shouted, “Time to take action!”
Turning Noise Into Action
There were many adults who were fed up as well. Robert Jackson, a New York City Council Member and chairman of the council’s education committee, also attended the convention. Jackson recalled visiting Christopher Columbus HS in the Bronx and noticing that it felt “like prison.” He endorsed the bill of rights, and encouraged the students to turn their noise into action.
Jackson, who said he hoped to get the City Council to pass a resolution supporting the bill of rights, also promised to ask New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg to endorse it. He agreed to inform UYC of the mayor’s response.
But even if Jackson convinces the City Council to pass a resolution supporting the bill, it just means the City Council supports it. If the Council doesn’t pass a law, the Department of Education doesn’t have to enforce it. But I think getting a law passed would be hard because the movement is still so young.
Andres Alonso, the city Department of Education’s deputy chancellor for teaching and learning, appeared at the start of the convention. He said, “I commend you. I look forward to continuing the conversation about our schools.” Apparently, the conversation really needs to be continued, because Alonso made his exit without endorsing the bill of rights.
The Department of Education has its own “Bill of Student Rights” but none of the teens at the convention mentioned it (and it was hard to find online).
Education Through Resistance
While this student rights movement may not yet be known by all New York City students, I think it’s amazing that teens are forming a resistance instead of coasting through high school. And participating in the movement may also be a lifesaver for many of them.
Commitment to such an important cause will encourage the students to reach for a better situation, in and out of school. It will also teach them advocacy, courage and dedication. Many of the skills they are learning from the movement will help them to stand up for their rights and succeed in life.
Information about the proposed student bill of rights should be delivered to all city high schools and youth organizations so that more students, parents and teachers can get involved to make it become a reality.
If you want to get involved, visit www.urbanyouthcollaborative.org.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.