It just wasn’t a good day for Juanita Crawford.
She was in a bad mood and tired of the same old crappy food. Her dark feelings were piling up, causing her to skip meals.
Juanita had been found guilty of conspiracy and reckless endangerment, so she spent a year and a half behind the walls of Lansing Residential Center, a girls’ detention center near Ithaca, New York, starting when she was 13.
“I was having a bad day and didn’t like the food,” she told me in a recent interview.
But when the staff asked her why she wasn’t eating, she shrugged in silence, which was taken as a sign of disrespect. After she threw out her food too slowly and talked back to a staff member, the situation reached its boiling point.
Twisted Like a Pretzel
The staff member “was cursing me out in front of my peers,” Juanita said. “Then he twisted my arms up into a pretzel behind my back and he dropped me. I was hurt.”
She said she complained for two weeks about the pain in her arm, until she finally got medical attention. It turned out she had a torn ligament and had to get a cast for her arm.
Juanita is now 19 and an intern at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which recently released a report with Human Rights Watch about how girls are treated in state facilities. The report criticizes Lansing and Tyron Girls’ Center (near Albany), the two most secure facilities in New York State for girls who break the law.
I was upset about how the girls said they were treated in prison. And I was interested to hear from someone who actually experienced time in a detention center. When I interviewed Juanita recently at the ACLU’s Manhattan office, physical abuse was at the top of her list of things wrong with Lansing.
Physical and Sexual Abuse
She said she isn’t the only one who’s been injured by the “face down restraint” method used on her. There have been reports of rug burns on kids’ faces (from being pushed down face first), cuts, bruises, broken limbs and concussions. She also said that officers use the method for small offenses like talking back to a staffer.
There’s also sexual abuse, according to the report. During strip searches, it’s been reported that the officers touch the girls in sexual ways and girls locked up for prostitution feel singled out by the male employees.
The report also claims that officers engage in intercourse with the girls. One girl said she was having sex with a staff member in an office when another male staff member walked in on them. Instead of stopping it, he simply apologized and left.
She also said that family visits are nearly impossible because the facilities are so far from New York City, and most of the girls’ families can’t afford to travel such distances. Juanita’s family could never afford to visit her. For those whose family can make the trip, the visits are way too short (20 minutes is considered a long visit).
Another beef Juanita had was with the education. She felt the prison curriculum was below her grade level, and that Lansing didn’t teach skills needed to get a job or otherwise adapt to life on the outside.
“I was an honors student when I went into the facility but below grade level when I got out,” she said.
Depressed and Angry
During her time there with no visits and constant physical and verbal torment, Juanita said, “I felt depressed and angry.”
Lansing and Tyron, which are run by the state Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS), need outside monitoring to make sure the girls are being treated fairly and humanely, according to ACLU attorney Mie Lewis.
Brian Marchetti, an OCFS spokesman, told the New York Times that restraints were used to prevent juveniles from harming themselves and others, and that the agency had “zero tolerance” for “sexual misconduct” between staffers and the juveniles. He also said that young people arrive testing below grade level and improve an average of two grade levels while held at OCFS facilities.
Speaking Out
Now Mie and Juanita are trying to get more girls who’ve been at state detention centers to share their stories, and they’re testifying about girls’ prison conditions. Juanita spoke at a New York City Council hearing a week before I interviewed her.
The ACLU is also considering filing a lawsuit against OCFS.
Girls Fight Back
If you or a loved one has had first-hand experience at Tyron, Lansing or another state OCFS residential facility, the ACLU wants to know. You can contact Mie Lewis at 212-519-7848 or [email protected].
If you want to fight for change in the state juvenile justice system, you can join the ACLU’s Youth Justice Advisory Committee by emailing Juanita Crawford at [email protected] or writing her at ACLU Women’s Rights Project, 125 Broad Street, 18th floor, New York, NY 10004.
To read the report, visit http://www.aclu.org/custodyandcontrol.
Girls in Lockdown
What's really going on behind the prison walls?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.