Failing Grades for Neighborhood Parks

About four hundred years ago, New York City was covered in forests, marshes and grass. Harlem was a flower-filled meadow. A brook running from Union Square through Greenwich Village was a popular spot for trout fishing.
Now if we want to experience the outdoors in the city, parks are where we go.
But while every borough still has at least one big, beautiful park (like Prospect Park in Brooklyn and Van Cortlandt Park in the Bronx), many of our smaller neighborhood parks are neglected and rundown.
Over the past 20 years, the city has reduced the parks department’s labor force by 60% and its budget by more than 20%. Mayor Bloomberg plans to decrease the budget even more in 2007, according to a recent article in Metro New York newspaper.
And parks are suffering, according to New Yorkers for Parks (NY4P), a nonprofit organization that works to protect and improve the city’s 28,000 acres of parks, beaches and playgrounds.
Every year, NY4P evaluates neighborhood parks from each of the five boroughs for its annual Report Card on Parks. In 2005, while overall park conditions had improved from previous years, 40% of neighborhood parks continued to receive C’s, D’s and F’s. NY4P argued that parks weren’t getting enough funding to be maintained properly.
Philip Abramson, a spokesman for the New York City Department of Parks and Recreation, disagreed. “Parks are much safer, cleaner and in better physical condition than they were 20 years ago. More than nine out of 10 parks meet our tough standards for cleanliness,” he said in an email interview.
So why are parks getting failing grades? I decided to speak to Christian DiPalermo, executive director of New Yorkers for Parks, to find out-and to see what teens can do to help their neighborhood parks.
-Kirandeep Toor
NYC: Why do some neighborhoods have better parks than others?
Christian DiPalermo: A lot of our flagship parks (big parks like Central Park and Prospect Park) receive private money to help maintain them. Central Park has about a $25 million annual budget and close to $20 million of that is raised privately. But neighborhood parks have to rely on public funds from the city.
Parks are a basic city service, like the police and fire departments. But unfortunately, when the city sees that parks can get private money, instead of using it to increase services to smaller parks, they use it as an excuse to cut funding. This has left neighborhood parks in need of attention.
NYC: What’s being done to help those parks?
DiPalermo: New Yorkers for Parks tries to get the city to reinvest in parks, especially neighborhood parks. Every year, we visit 150 to 200 neighborhood parks in all five boroughs and evaluate them from the park user’s perspective. Are they clean, well maintained and safe? If we found a sign that says the bathroom is supposed to be open from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. but it was closed, we’d fail that feature.
The borough most in need is the probably the Bronx. In a city that has world-class theaters and art institutions and is #1 in finance, we need to have world-class parks in all five boroughs.
We also try to empower community members. Every year we sponsor an Annual Parks Advocacy Day. We bring 300 to 500 park activists to City Hall so that City Council members understand that parks are important and that they need investment.
NYC: The Yankees are destroying 22 acres of parkland to make way for a new stadium in the South Bronx. How will this affect the community?
DiPalermo: This is basically ripping up the front and backyard of this community. While they’ll provide new parkland, the community will be without a track or ball field for up to four years. Four years is a lifetime for a child. In some ways, they’ll lose a childhood.
The Yankees have committed $100,000 a year to help maintain the [15 acres of new] parks that are going to be created. But I think the most expensive sports franchise in the world can do better than that.
NYC: Schoolyards take up nearly 1,000 acres of land in the city, but most are closed outside of school hours. Should there be more public access to schoolyards?
DiPalermo: Absolutely. Parkland is different in the city than it is elsewhere. When people think of parkland, in general they think of national and state parks, like the Grand Canyon and Bear Mountain. But urban parks are where we function on a daily basis.
In this city, we don’t have enough places for kids to play. So you have a playground in the neighborhood, but we’re not allowed to go in it because school’s not open? It’s silly.
NYC: What can teens can do to help?
DiPalermo: Teens can volunteer for their park and make sure that it stays clean. They can advocate to their City Council member to increase funding for that park. Usually 50 to 100 of the people who come to our Parks Advocacy Day are youth.
We also have a tool now called Track Your Park, where we train a couple of our youth groups to go in and basically do their own Report Card on the park.
The most effective advocates I’ve found have been youth because they’re the ones using the parks. Parks, specifically playgrounds, are probably the first interaction that youth have with a government service. The city owes it to youth to maintain parks at a high level. If a park isn’t well maintained, kids are going to think the city doesn’t care about them.
How to Get Involved
To find out more about Track Your Park, visit www.trackyourpark.org or contact Maura Lout at [email protected]. For more information on New Yorkers for Parks, visit www.ny4p.org.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.