One afternoon in my 9th grade class in Pakistan, my teacher started collecting our Arabic homework. I was nervous. For the very first time, I hadn’t done my homework. I went to my teacher and said politely, “Miss! I’m sorry, I didn’t do my homework today.”
She looked at me in surprise and roared, “don’t make false excuses. Now you have to do your homework five times. Go and stand by the wall and do your work.”
Every one of the 92 students in my class watched me as I stood by the wall trying to do homework that I’d copied roughly from the blackboard into my scraggly notebook a day before.
I was so embarrassed that I started crying. I worked like that for the full period in shame. Afterwards I began to wonder, “How is this helping to educate students?”
Beatings With Rods
My punishment was lenient compared to things I saw growing up. In 8th grade, my teacher punished four students for murmuring while she was writing on the blackboard. She made them stand on their chairs for the next two periods with their arms raised straight up, while their entire bodies trembled from the strain. I saw other teachers punish students by beating them with rods.
This was common in Pakistani schools. Supposedly, it taught students to be organized and prepared, but I felt it only discouraged us.
I felt bored and disconnected from what I was learning. If somebody had asked me what I was good at, I wouldn’t have been able to answer. Though I was doing well in every subject, I didn’t care about any of it. Sometimes the only reason I paid attention was because I was scared I’d get hit by the teacher.
And I could never get individual attention from the teacher because the average class had 70 students. By the time I was in high school, I was fed up with school in Pakistan.
My American School
Then last summer, when I was 16, my family moved to New York City. My father had been here for more than four years and I was happy to see him. We spent the summer just looking through the windows of the shops in Manhattan and walking around our new neighborhood in Queens.
One day in August, one of my father’s Pakistani colleagues, Khadija (not her real name), came to our house to visit. “You’ll really enjoy your high school,” she told me. She said that schools in the U.S. were friendly, that teachers were affectionate and classes were small.
“When will you take us there?” I asked her. I was excited to see everything she’d told me about. Finally, about a week later, Khadija took my sister and me to International HS at LaGuardia Community College in Queens to register. On September 8th, I started my first day of school in the U.S.
Even though Khadija had given me an idea of what the school would be like, I was so nervous my legs wouldn’t stop trembling. In Pakistan, when a newcomer comes to school for their first day, all the other students play pranks on them, splashing water on the new student’s shirt or showing them the way to the bathroom instead of the classroom.
Free to Think
I peered into room MB48, where I was supposed to go. I was excited to see that it was small, unlike the huge classrooms in Pakistan filled with too many students. My guidance counselor took me inside and introduced me to the teachers and students.
I got my free Metrocard, which was like a fantasy because in Pakistan we had to pay for our transportation. Here it felt like the school was paying me to study. I watched students walking around, chatting with each other and talking frankly with teachers. I’d never imagined school could be like this.
My English teacher gave us assignments to discuss and work on with our classmates. Unlike Pakistan, where we were punished for talking to classmates, here we were actually required to talk to them.
One day, my English teacher was talking about our poetry project. I was listening quietly, as usual. Suddenly, he said, “Kanwal, what do you think Shakespeare’s point of view is in this poem?”
I was speechless. It was the first time a teacher had asked for my opinion. At first, I didn’t know what my opinion was, because I’d never really thought for myself before. But he encouraged me to just say whatever I thought.
He asked me the same question in different ways to help me think. “OK, what’s the main idea of this poem?” he asked. Then, “Tell me the similes and metaphors used for the woman in this poem.” He made me feel free to answer the question, so I told him how I thought Shakespeare was using metaphors to create a lively picture of what the woman looked like.
Learning to Be Curious
As I began to share my thoughts and ideas with the class in the weeks that followed, I started to learn that at my new school, being a good student wasn’t about being obedient and quiet like in Pakistan. It was about developing your curiosity to learn new things.
In November, my history class had to do a project based on a made-up court case. The case was about a newspaper that published an article about a secret laboratory where the government made explosives. The court was arguing whether the newspaper should be allowed to tell the government’s secrets.
Our class was divided in different groups consisting of lawyers and judges. I was a lawyer defending the newspaper. The day of the case, we all dressed up like lawyers and judges. The judges came into class and we all stood up. Our chief justice ordered us to sit down and start our arguments.
Our Passion Wins the Case
The government’s lawyers argued that the secret laboratory was making explosives to protect people, and that the newspaper should have kept it a secret. “Your Honor, the government has a right to change the rules and regulations to keep people safe,” they said.
Then it was our turn. I had prepared my arguments using the Constitution and previous court cases as a reference. I stood up and said, “Your Honor, the First Amendment clearly states that the press has the freedom to publish whatever they want. Our readers have a right to know that this lab has dangerous effects on the environment.”
As I delivered my arguments, I felt like I could do anything. Everyone was interested in what we were saying and our group won the case because of our preparation and our passion.
This project made me feel confident for the first time in my life. I wondered why teachers in Pakistan didn’t do these kinds of creative projects in classes. It taught us public speaking skills, responsibility and punctuality. And it helped create an atmosphere of politeness and encouragement.
Courageous and Alive
Now I’m almost finished with my first year in an American school and I see how much I’ve changed in such a short time. The tough discipline in Pakistan did make me a punctual and good student. But I wasn’t interested in anything. Now I’m eager to learn about current affairs, politics and music.
I think we can create a better society by educating students through affection and care than through intimidation and punishment. Students are the future pillars of the country, and if those pillars aren’t strong, the whole structure of the country may fall down. The best way to make students strong is to encourage their curiosity and build their confidence.
After a year in school in the U.S., I feel more sure of myself and my decisions, and I feel courageous and alive when I participate in class or have conversations with my teachers about the world around us. Before this year, I never thought about possible careers. Now I see there are many choices for me and I feel confident and excited about my future.
A Different Kind of Education
At my American high school, I learned to think for myself
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.