(All student names have been changed.)
My best friend Chloe and I were ready to fight. We’d had enough of Jessica, a senior who constantly gave us dirty looks and told everyone at school not to talk to us because we were “ugly.”
Before going to high school that day, we smeared Vaseline on our faces so her punches would slip off. We hid our hair under black bandanas so she couldn’t pull it, and we dressed in baggy clothes. Shortly after we got to school, Jessica walked in with her friend. They looked at us and laughed.
“Now!” Chloe said.
I walked over to Jessica, pulled her shoulder and punched her dead in the face. We fought for a few minutes before we both hit the floor, still holding onto each other. “Talk sh-t now, b-tch,” Chloe yelled, kicking her.
Soon the dean separated us and brought us into his office. He suspended Chloe and me for five days (I heard that Jessica was suspended for three).
Straight’A’ Student
I don’t know how Chloe and I sank so low in our first few months of 9th grade. We’d once been such excellent students. I’d been a straight A student, and valedictorian of my 5th grade class.
I can remember my 5th grade teacher’s words clearly. I was in the PS 24 yard, still wearing my cap and gown after giving my graduation speech in Spanish. “Congratulations, Carmen. I’m so proud of you,” Ms. Nahar said. “I can see you being a reporter years from now.”
I continued to do well in middle school. I was student of the month twice in 6th grade, and I won awards for every class I took in 7th grade. It wasn’t until 8th grade that I started slacking.
I was sick of school. I was tired of doing my homework. While I was working my butt off, everyone else was goofing around and still passing their classes. I didn’t want to be a goody two shoes anymore. I wanted to stay home, where I wouldn’t have to see immature kids, broken chairs and dirty desks.
When the time came to fill out high school applications, Chloe and I were the only two students who weren’t the least bit excited. Nobody, not my teachers or my middle school dean, told me how important it was to choose my high schools carefully.
My Dreams Crushed
I wanted to attend a performing arts high school because I like to sing and act, and becoming a performer had always been my dream. But there was no point in dreaming because my mother wouldn’t let me list any performing arts schools. They were all “just too far away,” she said.
So every school I chose was one I had heard other students mention or was near my home in Sunset Park, Brooklyn.
I got accepted to every school I listed except one, but I didn’t want to go to any of them. Chloe and I rejected all of them and ended up having nowhere to go. I wasn’t thinking and I didn’t understand what would happen to me next. Since we didn’t make a decision, our middle school dean sent us to Brooklyn HS for Global Studies.
A Corner for Every Clique
Everyone else at Global Studies already seemed to know each other. There was a circle of friends in every corner, one for each clique. I was used to seeing people who were similar to me, teenagers wearing blue jeans and plain shirts, but these kids looked nothing like me.
There was a mixture of every type of person you could possibly imagine crowded into one place-gothic, geek and gayâeverything! For the first time, I saw different ways that people had of expressing themselves, other than seeing it on TV.
I had already decided I wasn’t going to be shy anymore, so that helped Chloe and me adapt to our new environment. All we had to know was who was with what crew, who had the most people behind their back, who not to mess with and how to act. We introduced ourselves to almost every person we came across.
Still, I was lucky if I didn’t get hit with a soda can or rocked with an apple during lunch. And those food fights were usually followed by real fights.
Egging Them On
Kids stood around waiting to pick on someone for no good reason. A second after a fight started, a huge crowd of students would surround the fighters and egg them on until the security guards arrived, out of breath, their hands clutching walkie-talkies.
My classes were crowded with kids sitting around facing their classmates and having loud conversations while the teachers tried desperately to quiet them down. There was no point trying to learn because the teachers wasted whole periods trying to control their classes.
Chloe and I starting cutting class all the time, rarely showing up at school at all. And we didn’t do enough homework to pass our classes, so we started to fail.
Then we had that fight with Jessica. That made us both realize we had to get out of Global Studies or we were going to fail high school and never amount to anything. We told our parents how sorry we were about cutting classes and failing school, and said how much we wanted to do better.
We asked if we could transfer schools and they agreed immediately. “we’re very proud of you girls for realizing this on your own. We just hope you don’t mess up again,” my mom said.
Nobody Helped Us
In the weeks that followed, we walked into countless schools’ main offices and heard the same things over and over: our grades were too low or our attendance was bad or there wasn’t enough room for us.
During our frantic search for a new school, nobody-not even my guidance counselor at Global Studies-ever mentioned we could go to a transfer or alternative school for failing students. We ended up going to our last choice: the Secondary School for Law, Journalism and Research in Park Slope, Brooklyn.
This school was just as bad as or worse than Global Studies. There were so many students in one classroom, kids often stood or sat on the floor during class. Students would curse and throw paper balls at the teachers while they tried to teach.
Teachers in Tears
Our English teacher tried hard to get students to be quiet and read, but they’d only tell her to shut up. After a while, she didn’t look frustrated anymore. She just looked sad. Sometimes she’d run out of the classroom in tears.
Chloe and I started cutting classes again because we weren’t learning. We had tried to save ourselves by transferring schools and it didn’t work. We didn’t know what to do next.
A year later, Chloe’s brother’s girlfriend told us about South Brooklyn Community HS, an alternative school designed to help truants graduate. We didn’t think our current school’s guidance counselors (whoever they were) would help us. So we called the school directly and they scheduled us for interviews within a few days.
As soon as I stepped into the school, I was taken aback at how clean and nice everything was. There was no graffiti. For the first time in my life, I saw a school with decent chairs and clean floors. The bathroom was the biggest shock of all: no doors were missing and they all had locks attached. And there was soap and napkins.
A nice lady with a big smile greeted me and walked me over to a small room on the second floor. She told me about the two timed tests I needed to take that day to determine what level classes I should take at South Brooklyn. After I finished the tests, we talked about why I started cutting classes and why I wanted to attend South Brooklyn.
After the interview, I felt like a great weight had been lifted off my shoulders. I didn’t feel as guilty about the lies I had told my parents and teachers when I was cutting school. I realized that there were many other kids like me. This nice woman wanted to help me, and I felt so happy. I still had a chance to graduate.
My first day at South Brooklyn was in October of 2004. I was 16 and had only 13 credits. (As a junior, I was supposed to have around 22.)
I was nervous. I expected annoying stares and lonely walks around the school, but it was nothing like that.
Instead, I experienced my first good day of high school. There were only 150 students in the school, and some of them actually came over to say hi.
The teachers were really nice and easy to talk to and I learned something new every day. I started doing well in school. I came early and did all my classwork and homework. But it’s not that easy to quit cutting. I still skipped school at least once a week. Chloe also started cutting classes again, became pregnant and dropped out.
But South Brooklyn didn’t let me get away with cutting. Every student had a counselor who was there for him or her 24/7, making sure each student was in school. My counselor, Ainsley, stayed on my back, doing everything he could to keep me coming to school. (Everyone at the school is called by their first name.)
“Hello, Mrs. Ruiz?” he’d say, calling my mother. “Yeah, I’m just calling to let you know that Carmen isn’t in school today.”
I wanted to kill him! As soon as I got home, my mom would yell at me for hours and punish me by not letting see my boyfriend.
Someone Had Faith in Me
Then one day at school, Ainsley stopped me to talk.
“What do you want now, Ainsley?” I said. “If you’re gonna ask me why I wasn’t in school yesterday, it’s because I didn’t feel like it. I was chillin’.”
“No, it has nothing to do with that. I was looking over your school records yesterday, and I was surprised at what I found.”
I was lost. What the hell was he talking about?
“You were a straight A student, Carmen. What happened? I saw everything, all the awards. You’re very bright and I’m not just telling you this. I really mean it. All these teachers here, they doubt you, but I’m telling them that they’re wrong. don’t make me look bad.”
He smiled, and I suddenly felt like I wanted to do better. I hadn’t heard anything like this in a long time.
This whole time I was praying for his death while he was worrying about me and believing in me. I smiled back and began to walk away.
“I want to see you bring that geek back in you,” he said. I laughed.
I Believed in Me
That day, I walked around feeling good. I wasn’t a dropout. I was smart. I was a student and not only that, I was once a straight A student. If I put my all into it, I could become that straight A student again, because someone really believed in me. At that moment, I really believed in me too.
I attended South Brooklyn for a year and three months. I passed five Regents exams there with the help of my teachers. I learned more in that school than in all of my other schools put together. I earned so many credits that I graduated on March 17, 2006, at age 17, three months before my scheduled graduation date.
The adults at South Brooklyn turned it around for me. They believed in me and treated me with respect. They made me feel smart again. They made me see that there’s some good in everyone, and they taught me to give people a chance. Now that I’m a high school graduate, I know that I can do anything I set my mind to. For me, that’s succeeding in college and becoming a famous writer. And that’s exactly what I plan to do.
Succeeding at South Brooklyn
An alternative school made me feel smart again
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.