Trained to Restrain?

What staff should do to keep us safe.

One afternoon last spring, I was coming back from my boxing lesson and stopped to talk to two friends. They were smoking weed near the main building of the Leake and Watts Residential Treatment Center, in Yonkers, New York, where we all lived at the time.
After about 15 minutes, a van with two Safety Response Unit (SRU) members pulled up and the driver said to all of us, “Hey! Mr. Whaley wants to see you!”
Victor Whaley was the supervisor of the SRU. I was scared. Most everyone I knew at the RTC was afraid of the 20 or so SRU staff who patrolled our campus with walkie-talkies.
When you’re high or drunk, dangerous, disruptive or AWOL, the SRU staff is supposed to take you to the SRU building. There you get locked in a room and have to sit behind a small desk from sunrise to sunset looking up words in a dictionary. Or you’re alone in an empty room with a single chair looking at the walls. It’s like being in jail.
Even the Easy Way Is Hard
A short, stocky, bald-headed officer ordered me to get into the van.
“Why should I get in the van?” I asked. “I didn’t do anything.”
“We can do this the easy way or we can do this the hard way,” he said. He had a nice guy face, but a tough guy attitude.
I got in the van.
When I got to the SRU building, an SRU staff told me to take off my shoes and have a seat.
“Why do I have to take off my shoes just to talk?” I asked.
“You got caught smoking, so you have to stay,” said the bald guy.
Punished for Nothing
I hadn’t been smoking, yet I had to sit in the SRU building for five long hours. I was heated.
After my punishment, I explained my side of the story to another SRU staff. He listened to my story, wrote up a note that he put in a file, and that was it.
But I stayed mad.
I had read in the Leake and Watts residents’ manual that SRU staff cannot touch residents unless they are a danger to themselves or others. While the SRU officer didn’t touch me, I felt sure he would have if I hadn’t taken “the easy way” and obeyed his order.
On Different Pages
I decided to play fair and get the SRU’s side of the story, so I asked for an interview with Paul Martin, the residential director of the RTC.
Martin not only agreed to talk to me, he had Whaley and Shelley Karmin, the RTC’s director of clinical services, sit in to help answer my questions.
Mr. Martin, Mr. Whaley and Ms. Karmin took me seriously, even though it was clear we were on different pages. I noticed right away that while I saw the SRU as a jail, they saw it as a safe place for residents to take time outs, think and cool off from stress.
My main concern was about how the staff gets residents to cooperate. When SRU members approached residents, I thought they moved too close, gripping our arms or standing behind us. It felt like they were always ready to attack. They were rude, too.
Defending the SRU
Martin said that threats and tricks shouldn’t be used. He and Whaley said that restraints are not supposed to injure residents, but sometimes residents are agitated and upset and interpret the actions of the SRU as abusive.
The SRU doesn’t use physical restraints very often, Martin added. He pointed out that from January to August 2005, 1,462 teens were brought to the SRU building, but only 27 were restrained-that’s less than 2%. Last year’s numbers were also small, he said.
Martin said he is always trying to reduce the number of restraints. A resident is only supposed to be restrained if he or she refuses to cooperate. Whaley added that, whenever possible, “we make sure we talk to them at length instead of taking them down.”
I wasn’t Treated Right
I told them my story and asked if I’d been treated correctly. Martin said no. “If there is any instance where someone is spoken to inappropriately, you should make a complaint,” he said. “Any complaint automatically triggers an investigation.”
Martin said residents should complain to their RTC’s director, their social worker, or their house manager.
I had told my house manager. He listened, but told me I was in the wrong place at the wrong time. I didn’t press the issue because I didn’t want to be seen as making trouble. The more trouble you get in, the longer you have to stay at the RTC.
Are Staff Trained?
On the internet, I saw that Leake and Watts was advertising for a new assistant supervisor for the SRU and a new SRU counselor. I noticed that the assistant supervisor position required only an associate’s degree or three years of experience. The counselor position required no college at all-just a GED and a driver’s license. I thought, “How can SRU staff know how to work with kids in emotional situations if they don’t have a good education?”
Martin said that SRU staff may not have a college education, but they do have a lot of experience dealing with “at-risk youth.” The average SRU staff has worked there 4.5 years, he said.
Whaley added that every staff gets four days of crisis intervention training after they’re hired. Three days are spent on learning how to talk to and calm residents. Only one day is spent learning how to do restraints. That’s because verbal communication is considered most important, Whaley said, and “physical is not necessarily where we go,” to get a resident to calm down.
can’t We All Just Get Along?
After the interview, I realized that they want to do the right thing and keep residents safe. Still, I thought there was a big difference between what Martin, Whaley and Karmin told me about how the SRU is supposed to work and how residents see the SRU working.
I’m not sure what could be done to fix that gap, but better communication between residents and management would be a great start.
Talking to them also reminded me that some residents don’t follow rules and make it difficult for adults who are supposed to help them. But I wondered if Martin knew what happened when he wasn’t around.
Taking Residents Seriously
I heard that Martin wanted to establish a resident advisory council to help deal with problems at the RTC. I think this would be a good idea. My house manager didn’t fully listen to me when I told him my SRU experience, but I didn’t fully open up to him, either. My experiences with adults have left me suspicious. It seems to me that adults always take the side of other adults.
But I might have opened up if I could have told my story to another resident who could relate to me. If the staff took complaints that they got from resident council members seriously, maybe residents would feel safer. And if residents felt respected and listened to by the SRU, they might be more willing to cooperate.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.