JENNIFER CARLSON
English teacher
Brooklyn International HS
Has taught for 3 1/2 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
Everyone has ability and talent. I wish I could get them realize their talents, and I’d probably tell the student their strengths and that if they drop out they won’t be able to realize their potential.
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
One, the school door is still open for them if they change their mind. Two, there are alternative GED programs for students who drop out if they decide later that they want a diploma. Three, their life is going to be difficult without a high school diploma. They should find a way to get themselves in school in some way.
What problems do you think students encounter that lead them to drop out?
One thing that leads student to drop out at Brooklyn InternationaI HS is economic need. Some families think it’s more important that students begin working as soon as they have the English skills. Another thing is personal problems. They become overwhelming and the students can’t continue with school.
YELENA WEINSTEIN
Math teacher
New York City Lab School
Has taught for 15 years
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
One, pick a favorite subject and assess how well you can do in that subject. Anything positive that you can extract is very beneficial. Two, drop a class that makes you unhappy, if possible. Three, try to complete your graduation requirements as painlessly as possible, because nothing is worse than dropping out.
If you could change one thing about the school system to help struggling students, what would it be?
Early intervention-if the problems are not addressed earlier, the students begin to develop poor learning habits.
LISA MUHAMMAD
HS for Legal Studies
Has taught for 5 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
I’d tell them to be diligent in finding their passion, because I think finding their gifts, strengths or what they like to do will enable them to endure their difficulty.
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
One, find a channel for creativity-writing, arts, dance, drama. Two, find a physical outlet (sports). Three, find someone that they feel comfortable talking to, an adult that can offer guidance, motivation, and some truthful assessment.
What problems do you think students encounter that lead them to drop out?
First and foremost, an ineffective educational system that won’t admit its inadequacies, won’t support real change and won’t support the process of improvement. Then boredom, family financial challenges, no sense of values. Or they feel nobody cares, and they need a will to fight. They give up too easily.
If you could change one thing about the school system to help struggling students, what would it be?
Infuse the curriculum somehow with information that fosters self-knowledge, self-analysis and self-correction. I think education can’t be relevant without the person being empowered to do for him or herself, assist others and effect necessary change.
ALISON FORNES
Science teacher
Queens International HS
Has taught for 6 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
My first reaction is that it’s usually not because of school. It’s because of something else. I want them to know that challenges or difficulties won’t always be the same.
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
One, find a teacher or an adult they trust and talk to them. Two, identify something they’re passionate about, like music or reading. Three, it’s hard to go back but it’s not impossible, so keep pushing.
If you could change one thing about the school system to help struggling students, what would it be?
I’d change graduation assessment requirements. Most schools need to pass Regents for graduation. I’d change it to no Regents but a portfolio instead.
LINDA BROWN
English teacher
South Brooklyn Community HS
Has taught for 30 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
Teenagers aren’t crazy when they think that the teen years are really hard. They are. If you can live through the teenage years, it gets better.
JOHN FAGER
Teacher/Resource Coordinator
City-As-School
Has taught for 7 years
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
Ask their teachers for help, have a conversation about their problems. If appropriate, I’d suggest they see a guidance counselor. If appropriate, involve their parents in finding a solution to the problem.
If you could change one thing about the school system to help struggling students, what would it be?
Listen to students. From the chancellor to the classroom teacher, people should listen to what students have to say.
JOANNA BUECKERT
English teacher
Landmark HS
Has taught for 8 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
It’s so important to finish high school because it gives you so much more freedom and choice later in your life.
What problems do you think students encounter that lead them to drop out?
Attendance is one major factor. And for a lot of kids whose adult family members work, they’re expected to be adults when they’re 14-get up, make your own breakfast, get yourself out the door on time.
The “village” where uncles, aunts, grandparents and neighbors once helped each other out doesn’t exist for many people.
That said, I think there are some schools in New York that are hell on earth-and who would want to go there? Fighting, dirty hallways, too many inexperienced teachers or teachers who get burnt out. Too many kids in classrooms that are too small.
Lastly, standardized testing is terrible. It means curriculum in class is way less exciting and adds pressure and anxiety to a kid’s educational experience.
What are three things you’d tell a student to try before dropping out?
One, talk to a social worker at school. What things in your life need to change in order for you to do well at school? Different eating habits? Help from different relatives? A change in after-school job hours? Two, talk to adults you admire-parents, uncles, coaches, whoever. Get their advice and inspiration. Three, talk to your teachers. When can you come in for extra help? When is there extra tutoring available?
FRED WAMBLOT
English teacher
Brooklyn International HS
Has taught for 8 years
What do you wish you could tell a student who’s struggling in school or thinking of dropping out?
I’d tell them that there are a lot of people that can help them: teachers, counselors and tutors. They just have to look for the support.
What are three things you would tell a student to try before dropping out?
I’d first tell them to set up a goal for themselves, a realistic goal, something that they want in the future. Then I’d tell them to find a mentor, an adult inside or outside of school. The last thing I’d tell them is to find a friend who’s doing well in school. [Then] they’ll also have the ambition to do well in class.
What problems do you think students encounter that lead them to drop out?
Learning difficulties, peer pressure, low expectations and not getting the right support from teachers and at home.
If you could change one thing about the school system to help struggling students, what would it be?
I’d change this culture of failure. I’d make it cool to be a good student. I do think that a lot of the kids who fail don’t want to be dorky, nerdy or a teacher’s pet. I believe in second chances but kids these days don’t work in school because they know they’re going to make it up in summer school. They won’t do it [right the first time] if they think they can do it later on.
Teachers Speak Out On Dropping Out
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.