Ruby can’t Do Fractions

Could getting the basics in elementary school lower New York City's dropout rate?

“Do you know the answer, Ruby?”
It’s Saturday morning, too early to be worrying about fractions and varying denominators, or about anything, for that matter. Yet here we are: Ruby (not her real name), 15 other students, and me-their tutor, worrying about fractions.
At the beginning of the class a few weeks earlier, I’d taken a poll. “Who learned fractions in school?” I’d bellowed from the front of the classroom. At least 10 little 5th grade hands shot up into the air. Ruby’s hand went up first. I laughed at how ridiculously easy this would be. I’d place a few review problems on the board and have a student do each one and explain it to the class.
Now, three weeks later, I’ve just scrawled on the board in big black ink, “1/2 + 2/5=?”
No one raises their hand. Maybe everyone is shy? I look at Ruby. She stares back at me with fear in those large chocolate eyes. She’s a deer in the headlights of my math session.
“Do you know the answer, Ruby?” There’s silence that seems to extend into the next day. Ruby doesn’t know. She showed me her report card last week and her math average is above 90, but Ruby doesn’t know. Neither do eight of the remaining 14 students, most of whom had said they’d learned fractions.
How Will They Catch Up?
That day I left confused. “Why?” I wondered. “How did those kids get to 5th grade without learning about fractions?” Most kids learn that in 3rd grade. It seemed to me that passing kids to the next grade before they’re ready would only hurt them later on. How would they ever catch up? wouldn’t they be more likely to not graduate high school on time, or to drop out altogether, if they didn’t get the basics early on?
Some might say, “What’s the big deal? She’s only 10.” But I’ve seen it happen with my peers. Ten quickly turns into 12. Twelve quickly turns into 16, and kids like Ruby, still behind and more frustrated than ever, simply stop going to school.
Many education experts agree. “Elementary school experiences do have an impact on the likelihood that a student will fall off the graduation track,” said Robert Balfanz, a research scientist at John Hopkins University. New York City does have a low high school graduation rate-only 54.3% of students graduated on time in 2004.
Promoting Is a Problem
That’s the thinking that led Mayor Michael Bloomberg to decide in 2004 that New York City’s 3rd graders now have to take tests that decide whether they’ll move on to the next grade or be held back.
Bloomberg hopes that by making sure even little kids have mastered their skills in school each year before they can move on, the high school dropout rate will go down. He’s also made other changes, including starting a city-wide tutoring program for kids who are struggling in school.
Some experts agree with Bloomberg. They say that “social promotion”-the act of passing a student to the next grade when they aren’t academically ready-happens each year to thousands of students in New York City, and that it’s a big problem.
Holding Kids Back Hurts
But other education experts say that while it’s a problem when kids like Ruby don’t learn the skills they need at school, banning social promotion is no solution.
“I think it’s a ridiculous strategy,” said Diana Autin, Executive Co-Director of the Statewide Parent Advocacy Network of New Jersey, and former managing attorney for Advocates for Children, about Bloomberg’s plan. Autin said holding students back doesn’t improve their performance-it actually makes it worse.
Several studies have shown that holding students back leads to higher dropout rates. Autin said that while students who are held back have better test scores the first year, their scores soon become lower than those of their peers who were socially promoted.
Students held back at any age are actually two to 11 times more likely to drop out of high school and less likely to receive a high school diploma than students who’ve been promoted, said Autin.
Early Warning Signs
Everyone-including me-agrees that the best solution is to make sure kids get the help they need early on, through tutoring, smaller classes and other reforms.
Part of the challenge is figuring out which kids need help. But Balfanz recently found there are warning signs long before high school that suggest when a kid is at a risk for dropping out.
Balfanz studied 6th graders in Philadelphia and found that poor attendance, inappropriate behavior, or failing math or English are all warning signs that a kid might later drop out. If adults can use these warning signs to target students most likely to fall off the graduation track, said Balfanz, they can help them right away. Too often, when kids are struggling in school, “the traditional response is to wait and see what happens,” said Balfanz, “to assume that many of the students will grow out of these problems.”
Tutoring Helps
Autin said that smaller class sizes and increasing parent involvement would help almost all students. “Things like tutoring, more effective instruction in school, after-school programs, and summer programs,” would also go a long way in helping struggling students, she said.
The city has just taken a step toward providing more tutoring. The new teacher’s contract requires that students performing below the appropriate level on standardized testing receive half an hour of after-school tutoring up to four days a week.
But in a recent New York Times article, Schools Chancellor Joel Klein said that thousands of children with failing scores on state reading and math tests won’t receive the new required tutoring. That’s because the contract limits tutoring groups to no more than 10 students per teacher, and in many schools the number of failing students is much higher than that.
Ruby Conquers Fractions
Luckily, the private program where I tutor reaches black and Hispanic students who are struggling in school, so I feel like I’m part of the solution. And I can see the results.
A week after I discovered just how far behind Ruby and her classmates were, I came to class armed with my elementary math textbook and patience that seemed to weigh more than I did. I wanted to figure out where Ruby and her peers had gotten lost, and to move her forward from there, so I started from the beginning. Walking to the frightening board once more, I scrawled, “2 x 3 =?”
The whole room erupted into numerous “Oh”s and “Ah”s. Everyone could answer it, including Ruby, who responded with a firm six. And so it began. Every Saturday, I walked into that room armed exactly the same way. We started at the two times tables and climbed until we reached the twelves. Finally, we began fractions and eventually, we conquered that too.
It wasn’t easy. Sometimes the patience was handier than the textbook. But Ruby stuck it out and I stuck it out with her. In the end, Ruby got some of the skills she’ll need to succeed in school, and though I know how hard the road can be, I believe she really will get there.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.