From Failure to College

It took more than smarts to succeed in school

Names have been changed.
When I was in elementary school, I dreaded parent-teacher conferences. “Welcome, it’s so good to have you here,” my teacher would say to my parents. I’d wish this happy tone would last forever but the conversation always took a solemn turn, and I was the subject.
“Tanisia’s a wonderful student. She tries hard. But she’s still not where she needs to be for her grade level,” my teacher would say. Then she’d show them my report card.
“Does she have any 3’s?” my mom would ask hopefully. (Three was the highest and one was the lowest.)
“No, but she could get them if she worked hard, right, Tanisia?” my teacher would say.
I wouldn’t reply. Her optimism seemed rehearsed. It felt like a mockery, because I’d failed so many times.
I’ll Never Be Smart
School had always been a problem for me. My parents spoke Jamaican English, or patois, at home. I couldn’t pronounce certain words, and I often put words together differently than American English. Teachers referred to my speech as “broken English,” like it was something that needed to be repaired. My self-esteem plummeted, and by 3rd grade, I just assumed I’d never be smart.
Still, I wanted so badly to know how it felt to be successful at something. By 5th grade, I desperately wanted to make a fresh start, but I didn’t know how. My parents tried to help me, but they became frustrated when they’d go over the work with me and I still couldn’t get it.
Grandma Believed in Me
Then, a couple weeks before starting junior high, I called my grandmother in Jamaica. She noticed that I was quieter than usual. “How’s everything?” she asked.
“Oh, everything’s just fine,” I said, trying to convince her when I couldn’t even convince myself. Finally, I told her about my fear of failing in school again.
“You’re going to achieve so much,” she said with conviction. “I know you’re going to make it. Trust me, you can do anything you want as long as you’re determined.”
I was quiet for a moment. I wanted to say, “But Grandma, I failed. My report card will make you think differently.” But she continued speaking.
“I know you’re going to make me proud,” she said. She reminded me that no one in my family had gone beyond high school and she knew I’d be the one to break the mold. For the first time, I felt hopeful. Someone believed in me, and I didn’t want to disappoint her.
Finding What Worked
At the beginning of 6th grade, keeping her words of encouragement in mind, I started experimenting with different learning methods to find out what was best for me. Soon I realized that it’s not just “smarts” but study habits and determination that lead to success.
In science class, I had to memorize the parts of an animal cell. I found I learned best by drawing diagrams. I studied a diagram about the cell’s structure in my textbook and then I drew the cell on my own without the labels. I examined my picture until I could visualize and remember the parts that made the cell whole, and I could label the parts and their functions without looking at the textbook.
In math class, I began to review math problems with my teacher. In the past, I’d seldom asked my teachers for help because I didn’t want them to think I wasn’t smart enough do it on my own. Now I realized that asking questions made me less confused and helped my teacher understand the way I thought, so that she could learn to explain problems in ways I could understand.
Notes and Outlines
I also took advantage of my school’s tutoring programs in math and reading. Two days a week, I worked with a group of students and a math teacher for about three hours. At home, I followed up with practice exercises from my math textbook. The other two days, we’d work on reading and writing with an English teacher. When I had the day off from my after-school programs, I’d study my notes.
In all my classes, I tried to develop better verbal and listening skills. I listened more carefully to my teachers in class, taking notes and repeating definitions and theories out loud to myself at home.
My Hard Work Paid Off
Finally, I tried learning by organizing the information in each chapter of my textbooks into outlines. It forced me to read all the text thoroughly until I had no further questions or uncertainty about the meaning. Before I knew it, I was using this method in math, science and other subjects. I started to love reading so much that I read outside of school.
I made several trips a week to the public library, often borrowing more books than I could carry. I developed a pattern of reading every day for at least two hours. I’d walk up to the 2nd floor of the library and put my book bag down at the last table near the history books.
Surrounded by hundreds of books, I felt like a kid in a candy store, and once I chose a book, I hardly ever made it back to my seat. I’d sit on the floor with my eyes buried in the pages. I liked the burning sensation I felt when I kept my eyes on the page too long.
Within a couple months, my test grades were higher and I was above many of my classmates. Teachers complimented me on my work. Some of my classmates thought I worked hard because I was a suck-up or I feared disappointing the teacher. But my only fear was disappointing my grandmother, the person who believed in me.
She kept me motivated all through junior high and high school. My parents noticed my progress and began encouraging me to keep up the good work. And during my junior year of high school, it all paid off. The head of the history department asked me to take a college-level class, AP U.S. History and Government, with 12 other students.
Being Wrong Was Alright
At first I wasn’t sure I could handle college-level work. But I kept remembering my grandmother’s advice “âyou can do anything you want as long as you’re determined.” It was the alarm clock I needed to wake me up whenever I doubted my abilities.
The classes were demanding. We had to read about 40 pages a night from our advanced level textbook, and in class my government teacher didn’t accept the simple answers so many of us were accustomed to giving.
“What is the main job of the judicial system?” he asked the class one day. Most of us raised our hands, so sure we knew the correct answer.
“The judicial system’s job is to interpret the Constitution,” I said, as my other classmates nodded in agreement.
“You’re 100%-“
“Right!” I thought to myself.
“Wrong,” he said. “The judicial system settles disputes and uses the Constitution as a reference.”
Getting the wrong answer felt different from the criticism I’d experienced as a child. I didn’t feel foolish because I knew the teacher saw my potential. He constantly challenged me to improve my thinking.
‘I’m Going to Make It’
It was in that class that I began developing a connection with other students who shared my drive to succeed. One day the class took a field trip to the Tenement Museum. Afterwards we all went to a pizza shop in Little Italy and talked about our future plans. College was on everyone’s priority list, which was a breath of fresh air compared to most of my other classmates in school.
“I want to go to Columbia University,” Carlita said. “I’ve been taking extra classes to meet their requirements.”
“I want to own my own clothing line and eventually have a franchise,” Katie said.
“That’s good, but that industry’s really competitive,” one of my other classmates said. “It might take you a long time to get to that dream.”
I expected Katie to lose some hope after this remark. But she replied, “I don’t expect it to come easily, but I’m creative. I know I’m going to make it.”
One of the Smart Kids
Her words brought me back to that day when my grandmother told me I was going to succeed. I realized my classmates must have also had moments in their lives when they doubted themselves. But, like me, they’d somehow managed to dismiss negativity from others and believe in themselves. Then it hit me that I was now one of them-one of the “smart kids.” I’d finally achieved the goal I’d had since elementary school.
Now I’m halfway through my freshman year at Lehman College, and excelling in all my classes. In elementary school, college seemed a dream that many thought I’d never achieve. I’m so glad I refused to give in to anyone’s perception of the person I could become.
My grandmother tells me she knew it all along. She still encourages me and never fails to tell me how proud she is of me, each time we talk on the phone. And once my parents saw my potential, they never doubted my abilities.
Although they couldn’t help me as much as I needed, they taught me a very important lesson in the process: independence. I learned that in the end, I was the only one who could change my pattern from failure to success.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.