Listening to the loud bass of the song “Gasolina” by the reggaeton artist Daddy Yankee, I couldn’t help but look at my watch. It was 10:03 p.m. and I was driving with my boyfriend to the movie theater.
“I’m having second thoughts babe,” I said, turning to face him. “Remember, I have to be home early.”
“Damn, Jen! You’re 18! Why do you have to be home so early?” said our friend Sal, who was sitting in the back seat. But I decided to go home. I remembered my mother punishing me for staying out past my curfew before.
Once when I was 16, I came home late on a school night after hanging out with my friends and boyfriend. My mother was waiting for me, with a grumpy look on her face.
She didn’t Buy My Excuses
“Mira que hora es, Jennifer!” she said in Spanish, complaining about the time.
“Ay, Ma please, it is not that serious. Son las diez!” I replied, saying it was 10 o’clock. As I walked into the room, I noticed my phone wasn’t on the receiver. She had taken it to punish me. My pride and joy was gone.
She didn’t buy my excuses, telling me I was out of control. She said that I was not an adult yet and couldn’t come home at whatever time I wanted. She punished me for a week. During that time, I couldn’t go out or take any phone calls at the house.
A Citywide Curfew?
Parents like my mother have always used curfews as a way of keeping their kids safe. Now some members of the New York City Council are considering a citywide curfew for teenagers. The curfew would keep anyone under the age of 18 off the streets and out of public places between midnight and 6 a.m. It would affect the 24% of the city’s residents who are under 18.
In 2004, two Republican New York City Council members, Dennis Gallagher of Queens and James Oddo of Staten Island, proposed the curfew for the city. During those hours, police could stop anyone who looked like a minor and ask for proof of age.
“It’s about helping children,” said Gallagher. “There are those who may be out past curfew. [Under this proposed law] you could send them home. A large number of them may be getting in trouble.”
Teens caught after midnight could be required to perform up to 25 hours of community service for their first offense. A second offense could result in 50 hours of community service.
Parents May Be Fined
Their parents could be held responsible, too. If they let their children out past midnight, they could be fined up to $75 for the first offense.
Business owners and their employees would be held liable under the law if they knowingly allowed kids to hang out at their businesses after midnight. They could get fined up to $250 for a first offense.
There would be several exceptions to the proposed law. Minors could be out after midnight if accompanied by a parent, guardian or an adult age 21 or older, or if they were working or traveling directly to or from their workplace.
The city council decided not to vote on the curfew proposal last year, but Gallagher is going to try to get a council vote this year.
Several parents I interviewed are in favor of the citywide curfew. They argue that the curfews are necessary to keep young people out of trouble. They also say that teenagers are more likely to get in trouble late than they would during daylight. With a curfew, police wouldn’t have to wait for teens to commit crimes before moving young people indoors.
Reducing Crime
By keeping young people off the streets at night, parents say curfews will protect teens from becoming victims of crime.
After curfews were implemented in San Diego, California, violent juvenile crime dropped by 20% and violent crime against juveniles dropped by 40%. In Dallas, Texas, and New Orleans, Lousiana, juvenile arrests dropped by about 20% after curfews were put in place.
Not surprisingly, my mother, Arelis Morron, believes in curfews.
“It’s very dangerous to be out in the streets so late at night, especially for young girls,” she said. “There are many men out there who have perverted thoughts and will not let anything stand in their way to accomplish them.”
Out Late Alone
I worry about my safety too. When I was single and I violated curfew in the past, I ended up having a 15-minute walk back home late at night by myself. I got scared I might bump into the wild men out there who I know are waiting to find a nice young girl to grab. I tried to watch for people who were walking behind me. Thankfully, my boyfriend has a car and he drives me home at night now.
Even many teens I know understand that curfews might be a good idea, even if they don’t like them.
“Parents try to teach you good morals and they want everything that is best for you,” said my friend Michael Frankowski, 18, a recent graduate from Christ the King HS in Queens, who now attends Farmingdale University. “That’s why they give you curfews.”
But teens and others who argue against curfews say that the public is misinformed about the number of crimes committed by teens.
Not the Government’s Job?
They say that setting a curfew is a parent’s or guardian’s job, not the government’s. And I’ve heard that curfew laws can violate teenagers’ constitutional rights, like freedom of association and freedom of speech.
I know my boyfriend isn’t thinking about my constitutional rights when he’s trying to pressure me to hang out and break my curfew. We see our friends having so much fun and we want to stay out too.
My mother is very overprotective and even though I am 19 and attending LaGuardia Community College, I’ve had the same curfew since I was 16. Even though the proposed curfew would allow teens over 18 to stay out past midnight, I’d still have to be home by midnight at the latest. My friends think my mother is way too strict.
“I believe 18 is the age you should not have a curfew, because you know what is right from wrong and you are mature enough,” said my friend Jennifer Fernandez, 17, a recent graduate of Grover Cleveland HS, who now attends New York City College of Technology.
Of course my mother doesn’t agree with my friends. But although I get jealous of the fact that most of my girlfriends don’t have to be home until 2 or 3 a.m., I always think about them and ask myself, do their parents realize that their daughters are out that late?
Staying Out Late
Should the City Have a Teen Curfew?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.